To understand why venture capital today is truly broken, look no further than the long list of firms that have either exited the space, shuttered funds, given back capital, or are choosing to stop raising altogether. The number of new funds is in sharp decline and average fund size is down 56%. On the founder side, 75% of venture-backed companies never return cash to investors, let alone get to the point of an Initial Public Offering (IPO).
To achieve outsized exits that can cover the losses in the rest of the portfolio that won’t, becoming a publicly backed organization is the golden path laid for VC-backed companies. In 2023, very few SaaS organizations achieved an IPO. This is a pervasive trend. It signals we could be nearing the end of the “unicorn” era and seeing a new trend rooted in strong business fundamentals.
Fortunately, more and more B2B SaaS startups are beginning to set their sights on a new definition of success, a path that’s actually well traveled, but historically hasn’t been synonymous with ‘success.’ This new cohort has veered off the moonshot course forced upon them by bankers and financiers, and in the process, stumbled upon an outlook that holds the key to refreshing the venture model—but without the startup casualty rates that have become the accepted norm.
For context, the traditional venture model relies on power law. Outsized returns of a few (often after an IPO) make up for scores of underperformers. Historically, this has allowed venture to perform very well as an asset class for investors.
However, when we analyze the startup outcomes, there’s a strong bell curve related to profitable exits that takes place at the early stages of company growth, when organizations have garnered between $2MM to $20MM of ARR, and where acquisition exits are prevalent at valuations of $50MM to $200MM. These companies have either achieved profitability or are navigating a path to doing so. What do they have in common? They are all B2B SaaS companies, and often they have a very strong niche focus. Their success shines light on a time-tested venture model that is anchored in something incredibly obvious: focusing on strong business fundamentals.
However, that’s not the goal of traditional VC, and if you ask a founder about their ultimate goals for their business, they often share a narrative rooted in ‘MORE’ because they believe it’s what all VCs want to hear. Growth at all costs on a line that has no end. When your plan has no end, it’s impossible to get there. That needs to change. As VCs, we hold a lot of sway, therefore the change begins with us.
INVESTMENT: ALIGNING RESOURCES WITH STRATEGIC GOALS
At the heart of any venture lies the question: What are we trying to achieve with this business? Can the business deliver value? If the answer is a resounding yes, next consider what is the ultimate best path for the founder, the business, and the investors.
A company may have enterprise value, but that doesn’t mean it has enough value to stand on its own, become a platform, and eventually, IPO. This recently played out with Spiff, a sales commission software and commission tracker. Backed by 19 investors, it’s safe to assume that many, if not all, were eyeing an IPO. Then the company was acquired by Salesforce. Not a bad exit at all, but if investors had unrealistic expectations that Spiff would become a unicorn, they might have been disappointed nonetheless.
Startups and their investors need to reset expectations. The essence of successful investment is in delivering tangible value. This requires a critical evaluation of the business’s potential to stand on its own merits and provide meaningful returns for all stakeholders involved.
The days of deploying indiscriminate capital in the pursuit of elusive unicorns are over. Instead, investors must recognize the importance of careful due diligence and strategic alignment with a business’s core objectives. Whether through traditional venture funds or specialized investment vehicles like SPVs (special purpose vehicles), there should be more emphasis on transparency, focused investment, and realistic exit strategies.
A RETURN TO LEVEL-HEADED THINKING
All of this is not to say that truly revolutionary companies are not in the works at this very moment. The doors AI will open are incredible. But for a lot of organizations, their solution, although certainly valuable to a market and end user, will not change the world. Honesty in this capacity, both around that fact and the resulting target outcome, avoids a lot of unnecessary carnage.
The traditional approach of expecting every investment to offset losses elsewhere is unsustainable and inefficient. The shift in mindset toward more discerning investment practices, reconsidering fund dynamics, and embracing transparency through models (like SPVs) that allow for tailored outcomes that don’t all have to end in IPO, is the new and better way. This new model really hinges on best practices in business that have been around for decades. It’s where investors aim for significant returns within a defined timeframe and meticulously evaluate results with a clear understanding of each investment’s viability. Then we do everything in our power, beyond simple financial support, to make that outcome a reality.
Unlike traditional fund structures, which often lack transparency and end in hasty capital deployment, this approach emphasizes diligence and alignment with strategic objectives, reducing waste and inefficiency. The prevailing sentiment among investors returning capital to limited partners (LPs) underscores the need for a shift toward performance-based acquisition models, like those centered on profitability or reliable growth multiples.
As the venture landscape continues to evolve, a return to business fundamentals isn’t an option—it’s an edict. The new venture model, rooted in principles of prudent investment, efficient growth strategies, and realistic outcomes, offers a compelling alternative to the blatant excesses that clearly haven’t worked.