Things are officially getting weird.
In a recent interview, Eric Yuan, the founder and CEO of Zoom, predicted generative AI would soon be powerful enough to create a digital twin capable of attending Zoom meetings for you, so you can stroll along the beach or do something more productive with your time.
And if you’ve watched any short films or deep fakes created using the latest version of the GenAI video program Runway, you’ll realize this isn’t as far-fetched as it sounds.
Yuan also suggested AI will answer our emails, taking yet another mundane task off our plates.
This has rekindled the ongoing debate about the “dead internet,” the notion that most online exchanges today are occurring with bots, not two-way interactions between actual humans. Once described as a conspiracy theory by Wikipedia, research conducted this year shows almost half of all web traffic is now coming from bots, and a quick tour of “likes” and comments on social media makes you wonder if we’ve already crossed the threshold where humans are outnumbered by their digital sparring partners.
Which makes you wonder why so many high-profile AI developers are targeting human interactions for replacement, especially in customer service roles and content creation, rather than applying advanced tech for more operational tasks. Sure, we occasionally hear of breakthroughs in automation or life-saving advances in the detection of diseases, but most of the money—and all the buzz—is fueling a race for digital doppelgängers.
On a recent trip through Heathrow airport, I wanted to make a change with my reservation and had a question about a connecting flight, a two-part puzzle that could be resolved with a quick conversation. I approached a woman from the airline who stood in the departures section of the terminal surrounded by a forest of digital kiosks, then asked her where I could find the line for people making changes to their itinerary. Rather than offer assistance, she asked, “Why would you want to talk to a person when we have all these wonderful machines?”
There was no sense of irony as she stood, alone, surrounded by machines that had taken all her colleagues’ jobs. After several minutes on the kiosk, it was clear my problem couldn’t be solved with a screen, so I tracked down a more helpful human who showed me the hidden queue on the far side of the terminal where people got help from actual people. After less than a minute’s conversation, my problem was sorted and I was on my way.
Such is the danger of the mad rush to eliminate as many jobs as possible rather than use technology to actually improve customer service. Until that contradiction is resolved, the seamless integration of AI into many businesses will continue to be a bumpy road.
It’s no secret Silicon Valley began massive layoffs after the broad adoption of AI, despite denials during analyst calls in the first half of the year. Economic headwinds are too strong and markets too volatile for corporations to prioritize customer experience or corporate culture over operational efficiency, despite what press releases may say. This will erode customer loyalty in the long run, but in the short term we’re seeing manic micromanagement of the bottom line.
Which brings us back to the flaw in the theory that sending a “virtual you” to attend a meeting in your stead is a viable plan. As much as you may enjoy the beach, it’s unlikely your current employer will pay you for the privilege of getting sand between your toes.
We should be asking why attending a meeting as a deep fake sounds so appealing to so many. After all, we’re not simply talking about the bad etiquette of staying off-camera, this is a scheme for dissing your colleagues altogether. Which makes you wonder, how important is that meeting if you can send a non-entity to parrot generic verbal responses and occasional head-nods?
Does it really take a dozen people on a conference call to make a decision in big companies today? Has an increasingly risk-averse business climate made committees a form of insurance, diluting responsibility and spreading blame if things go sideways? And, if you can answer all your emails without actually reading them, why isn’t that email considered spam?
You already know the answers to those questions, and AI is forcing us to confront them. When companies shifted their focus toward global efficiencies and manufacturing jobs went offshore, the result was a surge in college applications and a sudden explosion in white collar jobs across corporate America. That led to the PowerPoint economy, which generates enough paperwork annually to deforest Brazil, much of it desktop presentations designed to highlight all the actual work being done.
Fast-forward through two economic downturns with a pandemic squeezed in-between—a sandwich of uncertainty that has led to corporate downsizing and rolling layoffs for almost half a decade. That’s when AI showed up to the party, an unexpected guest who doesn’t play by the rules of corporate obeisance.
Suddenly the jobs that sit between the factory floor and the C-suite look less essential than they did a short while ago. Depending on the industry in which you work, if your job is currently threatened by the future potential of AI, odds are it’s already gone, your salary built into overhead reductions promised to analysts to boost the company’s share price.
It’s not too late to turn this dystopian future of mass unemployment, eroding customer service, and busywork for bots into a more utopian scenario of increased productivity, increased collaboration, and greater human interaction facilitated by technology.
But when you’re holding a hammer, everything looks like a nail, and AI is a mighty big hammer. Therefore it’s up to us to decide. Will we work towards making things better, or simply make things faster, cheaper, and more automated?
That seems like a decision worthy of discussion, even if you have to sit on a Zoom meeting to make the right call.