Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Should I hire a PR agency or do PR in-house? 

Here’s why a hybrid approach is the best-case scenario for businesses.

Man interviewing a woman

[Images: New Africa / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Shannon Tucker

Vice President · Next PR

TechCrunch Reporter Amanda Silberling once tweeted, “Does literally anyone respond to pitches that are like: ‘This CEO wants to tell you what he thinks is next for [industry].’” She added, “[S]poiler alert, he thinks his company is the next big thing.” 

Amanda underscores a big reason companies need outside counsel: When you’re too close to something, you lose sight of what’s newsworthy and place yourself (or your company) on an inappropriately high pedestal.  

That said, while I work at a PR agency (so I am obviously a believer in a company’s need for outside counsel), I think companies need both an agency and in-house PR to be successful. Here’s why a hybrid approach is the best-case scenario:  

PR AGENCIES BRING MORE DIVERSE EXPERIENCE, FRESH PERSPECTIVES

Let’s start with the benefits of an agency.  

Too often, companies get stuck in groupthink because they are too close to something. They need a BS meter to determine what’s news and what’s fluff.

One time, we had a company come to us to promote their product. They thought they wanted media coverage, but much to their shock, we said, “We have no idea what your company does, what the product is that you’re selling, and why someone would buy this. Your website and marketing materials are riddled with jargon and too many words.” Sometimes, you need fresh eyes. The partnership soon turned into a messaging workshop instead. 

Additionally, an in-house team gets limited opportunities to do big things: IPOs, acquisitions, funding, product launches, and national TV interviews don’t happen every week. However, at an agency, they do. A big part of the value you get with an agency is our experience. We have the reps. Agencies offer a full team of experts across multiple disciplines and industries who have the experience to say, “We did this before and here’s what worked and what didn’t.”  

People talk about how expensive PR agencies can be, and I know it’s not a small expense. Yet, to do PR right, you need to invest in expensive tools like wire services, news subscriptions, monitoring software, media databases, and reporter request platforms. By the time you pay for these tools, you could pay a PR agency retainer.  

IN-HOUSE TEAMS TURN IDEAS INTO ACTION   

While agencies are great and know the ins and outs of the media landscape, they simply lack the in-depth knowledge of the company’s product, messaging pillars, or spokespeople nuances. The in-house team lives and breathes those every day. Agencies rely on in-house teams to react to pitch messaging, determine which spokespeople are best for which topics, and how to best explain the product differentiators to a reporter. 

Sometimes when we have a half-baked idea for one of our clients, it’s the in-house team who can turn it into something we as an agency can execute. To be successful, agencies need someone on the inside who can facilitate asks, wrangle the right people, and pull data.  

One time we had a creative idea to conduct a social media contest with celebrity influencers. The in-house team explained some of the internal roadblocks preventing the exact idea from coming to fruition, but it sparked something: “We can’t do X, but we can do Y.”  

WHEN A HYBRID APPROACH IS OUT OF REACH  

Not every company can afford both, especially in this economic climate. Startups need to be particularly frugal, especially at the early stage. In those instances, internal teams should soak up all the knowledge they can from agencies: follow the ones you trust, read their blogs, engage with their expertise on social media.

Consider hiring a PR freelancer, which is typically more affordable, to provide necessary outside counsel and the ability to execute on the tasks you simply don’t have time for. Some agencies even offer special rates for startups or nonprofits, smaller packages for one-off services, or even pro bono PR services to companies that are giving back.  

THE FINAL WORD  

A hybrid approach is the best of both worlds. It’s when in-house PR teams and PR agencies act as true partners that the magic really happens.