Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Timing matters: The pitfalls of premature marketing

Use the RED Model to create relevant, emotive, and distinctive content for your next marketing campaign.

[Images: Adobe Stock / ValentinValkov]

Profile photo of Yumi Clevenger-Lee

Global CMO · Quest Global

With the temperatures high and summer in full swing, imagine my surprise on catching sight of my local retailer’s display for Halloween candy. That’s right, Halloween candy in July.

That candy display was labeled “autumn mix.” While many shoppers passed by without a second glance, the sweets evoked an emotional response in me—and not the way the retailer may have hoped. The source of my visceral reaction to seeing seasonal items for autumn in July stemmed from the unwelcome intrusion on my summertime vibes. 

Most of us like to celebrate those long, hot days of summer and all they represent. Summer is a time for backyard barbeques, cooling dips in the pool, and our all-important but all-too-short family vacations. We know summer is coming to an end, so we want to relish these moments in peace before school starts, the leaves change color, and jackets must come out of hiding.

The chief problem with Halloween candy in July is a failure to put people at the heart of the marketing promotion. No matter how much they might like Halloween, the average candy buyer doesn’t want to be forced into a premature ending to summer. The timing of this product represents a critical lack of relevance to the consumer because no matter how you position it, seasonal autumn candy just isn’t relevant right now. 

USE “RED” TO PUT HUMANS AT THE HEART OF YOUR MARKETING

While it sounds like a simple timing fail, this example got me thinking. If only the marketing team responsible for this promotion had used the RED model as a lens for designing their campaign, I am certain they would realize better business results. RED stands for relevant, emotive, and distinctive. I developed this model as a way of helping my marketing teams take a common approach to brand creative that puts people at the heart.

Whether your marketing is B2C or B2B, it’s essential to recognize that, at its core, the craft of marketing is business for humans (B4H). We must focus on creating relevant, emotive, and distinctive content to put people back at the center of our craft.

RED content focuses on what matters to your audience (relevance), intentionally sparks an emotional response (emotive), and stands out from the crowd in a way that is ownable for your brand (distinctive). For the RED model to be truly effective, all three elements must be equally prioritized to achieve maximum impact.

The Halloween candy display failed so spectacularly with me because it didn’t pass the relevance test. Relevancy means setting aside your business needs (i.e., getting a head start on selling Halloween candy) and taking the time to put yourself in your audience’s shoes. It’s carefully considering your audience’s needs, desires, fears, and motivations, and putting these ahead of your own goals.

TIMING IS EVERYTHING 

Have we all become slightly cynical about seasonal buying cycles? We’re accustomed to seeing Halloween and Thanksgiving items marketed side-by-side and Christmas trees on display as soon as the back-to-school signs go down. But my initial reaction to Halloween candy in July wasn’t just a roll of the eyes; it struck me as a teachable moment to look at the situation through a marketing lens.

Your marketing may be excellent, but it won’t matter if the timing is off. On one hand, I appreciate that the product was advertised as autumn candy. They tried to broaden the positioning of their product from a Halloween item only relevant for one day to a product that would be relevant all season. Clever as that might be, it was wasted because the timing was still off. Most customers are neither open nor willing to think about autumn while still savoring summer.

MARKETING: TREATS, NOT TRICKS

To create relevant marketing campaigns, we must put humans at the center of our craft. Step into their shoes and think about how to make their lives better. 

Marketing isn’t tricking someone into wanting your product. It’s not just slick advertising or clever social media campaigns. Marketing requires us to understand our consumers—not just as a demographic but as actual human beings. Our goal shouldn’t be convincing someone to buy something irrelevant and unneeded. If a product isn’t relevant to consumers, it will be quickly tuned out. 

On the other hand, if you are aligned with what real people care about, you will naturally offer a product that appeals to them. By putting humans at the focus of your marketing, you have the opportunity to bring something of value to their life, whether that’s a product that makes their life easier, or even just a feeling of joy or a moment of escapism. 

DO YOU HAVE AN AGENDA? 

No one wants to be that out-of-touch candy brand that tries to push their “autumn candy” while their customers are still reveling in the joys of summer. But it’s not just about seasonal promotion; the RED model applies to all aspects of marketing.

To avoid putting a business agenda ahead of the needs of the people we’re trying to reach, we must take the time to sit down and ask ourselves whether we’re providing something genuinely relevant. Are we giving the human at the center of this campaign what they need when they need it? What emotional reaction do we want to evoke, and how will that inspire someone to take action? And finally, how do we make our content distinctive enough to stand out from the crowd and be positively and memorably attributed back to our brand?

When people feel their needs are being addressed, they resonate with a brand. People are smart enough to know when we’re putting our needs ahead of their own. But when we give them what they need when they need it, we build trust.

When we consistently deliver relevant, emotive, and distinctive content, we are creating brand experiences that people love—and that’s the key to getting the brand results we all desire.