Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The dangers of marketing orthodoxy and how to break the cycle

The comfortable pajamas of predictability and “best practices” are useful on occasion, but have limitations as a default behavior.

The dangers of marketing

[REDPIXEL / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Mick McCabe

Global Chief Strategy Officer · Ogilvy

It’s one of the most common refrains we hear from clients in the halls of marketing: “How is this concept or campaign different from the competition’s?” “How is it ownable?” “How is this unique to us?” 

These questions keep coming up for good reason—a brand differentiation crisis is upon us. A look at the BrandAsset Valuator (BAV), an ongoing 40-year global study of brand equity, points to brand differentiation as increasingly being the problem to solve. This is perhaps most evidenced by the level of brand switching and brand interchangeability now prevalent in so many categories.  

The comfortable pajamas of predictability and “best practices” are useful on occasion, but have limitations as a default behavior. This overreliance on familiar strategies has reached breaking point, with clients more and more dissatisfied with using the same playbook, the same design systems, the same “world is divided” insights, and the same way of going to market. There’s now recognition that this reliance on past practices may actually stifle innovation and dynamism within an organization.

Something has to give, not least because the value of a brand is a large line item on a balance sheet that can either wither and depreciate or grow and soar. Here are four recent examples of the unorthodox ways we have made sure it’s the latter—and their lessons. These are larger examples but show principles that can be applied at any level. (Full disclsoure: CeraVe, Coca Cola, SC Johnson, and Verizon are clients of Ogilyy.)

1. DON’T “MAKE SENSE”

Years back, a user on Reddit jokingly suggested that Michael Cera was somehow involved with the skincare brand CeraVe. Predictably, Reddit users began to build on the initial joke, adding layers of humor and mock evidence. So we asked ourselves, how can we take advantage of this organic sort of conspiracy theory? Answer: We had to treat CeraVe like an entertainment property.  

The “Michael CeraVe” campaign broke orthodoxy by being a social-first campaign, featuring a celebrity with absolutely no social media presence, stimulated by a single post years before. It was built by playfully designing and stimulating an online conspiracy, and following closely how people were talking, questioning, and theorizing about Michael Cera. 

The campaign involved influencers being part of the conspiracy theory as Cera took on dermatologists to “prove” CeraVe was his brainchild. Eventually, the myth was debunked by a boardroom of bemused CeraVe dermatologists in the Super Bowl CeraVe ad. For many campaigns, the Super Bowl is the starting point. But for CeraVe, it was a culminating moment that had been building for months. It took brave clients to make decision after decision to break the orthodox ways to “do” the Super Bowl successfully.

2. BREAK YOUR OWN SACRED RULES 

Coca-Cola’s iconic logo is a sacred symbol universally treated with reverence. But when the moment came to engage people in sustainability, the client took challenging convention to another level when its “Recycle Me” campaign dared to mess with its logo—a cardinal marketing sin.

The famous brand name was crushed into different shapes in a series of stunning images mimicking the first step in the recycling process. Yet no matter how warped the logo appeared on a Coke red background, it was still recognizable, only reinforcing the brand’s iconicity.

This purposeful and intelligent example of a brand hacking one of its own rules helped drive an important global initiative around sustainability. As a byproduct, it also helped Coca-Cola earn Brand of the Year at the Cannes International Festival of Creativity.

3. PUT O.G. BRAND VALUES IN A MODERN CONTEXT  

The best companies have an intrinsic core set of values and behaviors that cannot be copied. These origins, roots, and orientation are a central part of their history. Even as markets and generations change, they drive the way the organization thinks and behaves.  

SC Johnson, for instance, is a multi-generational family company that is global in its reach, but still maintains a core belief of prioritizing innovation in its household cleaning products in alignment with the brand’s long-held belief in sustainability. Beyond product innovation, however, this approach has also manifested in more enduring societal ways.  

For example, “Blue Paradox” is a permanent exhibit presented by SC Johnson at the Chicago Museum of Science and Industry that explores the harmful effects of plastic on the oceans. An immersive experience, it enrolls people in how we all can help protect our marine environments.

It was only by recontextualizing the roots of the brand for today’s challenges that this idea was born. So, always think if your brand was born today, what problem would it help solve to make the world a better place? 

4. GET PEOPLE TO MESS WITH YOUR PRODUCT

Social media has become a treasure trove of insights, revealing the nuanced ways in which consumers engage with brands and the world around them. We often hear the phrase “breaking the Internet,” but there’s very few who actually do have that level of influence.

Verizon traded in on that idea when it teamed up with Beyoncé in a Super Bowl spot. The core message was that while Beyoncé could “break the internet,” Verizon’s services would remain unaffected and reliable. 

Imagine the internal conversations that must have taken place before approving an ad that would stake a claim to unbreakability in front of an audience of over 100 million. “Wait, what? We are going to ask people to break the product, break the connection we provide?” That’s why the ad was a huge leap of faith for Verizon. 

THE TAKEAWAYS FOR MARKETERS

Marketers have to find novel ways to challenge convention. Remember, the world is speaking all day and every day on social media. One comment, one post, or one small act can be the catalyst for something big. So, think about how someone outside of marketing would approach a campaign.

The best marketers take what they hear and transform it into something imaginative and dynamic that blasts through the noise of a saturated marketplace. Orthodoxy may appear safe, but its only guarantee is more of the same. Heresy may appear crazy but its guarantee is people will take notice.