Recently, I had the opportunity to face a challenging board meeting and see the difference between two board members’ approaches. I want to share the winning strategy with you.
Everyone on the board is passionate about the company, which is a good thing, but there was a decision to be made about something relatively minor but important. Two board members who thought they were at odds dueled it out, each taking a different approach to the decision to be made. Here is how it went:
TWO DIFFERENT APPROACHES
The first board member assertively advocated for their position, speaking calmly and with authority, and put their case forward. I listened, took a few notes, held back from asking any questions, and concluded that their position was very solid.
The second board member started off by asking a question: “If we all thought a decision needed to be made about X…” Each board member agreed that, in fact, we did need to make a decision. She continued by outlining three possible solutions and asked once again if anybody had any other ideas. No board members offered up a fourth idea. So, she continued and recommended solution one.
Immediately, the board agreed solution one was the right approach. We made a motion to accept this and all voted affirmatively, even the first board member. The decision was made, and the second board member received positive affirmations from other board members—”Thanks,” “Nice job,” and “I appreciate how you broke that down for us to understand.”
AN UNEXPECTED CONVERSATION
When the board meeting was over and I was walking to my car to head to my next meeting, the first board member approached me and asked if they could talk candidly. OK, whenever anyone “asks” if they can talk candidly, that is code for “I’m not happy,” or “I am going to complain about something.”
The first board member was confused and a bit irritated that the second board member received all the accolades when, in fact, solution one was the same solution they had offered. This board member was correct—they had proposed the same solution just minutes earlier. They felt that because they were a new board member and a little younger, their opinion was not valued by their peers and they were disappointed.
THE LESSON: INQUIRY VS ADVOCACY
In our meeting, board member one advocated their position. As they advocated their position, they didn’t leave the conversation open for input or questions, even though they thought they might have. They were focused on getting their points across vs. influencing their audience.
Board member two took an inquiry approach to stating her position. She asked an opening question, essentially inviting each board member to participate. Once agreed, she opened up a second conversation, further bringing board members along. To conclude, she made her recommendation, and by that point, everyone was on board with the recommendation because they had participated in the decision-making process.
THE POWER OF INFLUENCE
Keep in mind, both solutions were similar, but each board member’s approach was totally different. Time on the board, age, or gender did not play roles in one board member’s success over the other. It was all decided by the power of influence.
Advocacy puts you in a position of having a “stance.” When you advocate, you are trying to impart or enforce a particular action, position, or set of principles. You are trying to persuade by arguing for the position you are advocating.
Inquiry is an attempt to understand the position of others, rather than change their opinions. Once you consider and appreciate your audience’s position and ask questions, your ability to influence increases dramatically. You are effectively inquiring about their point of view and making them think, and thinking is a good thing.
This is not to say that advocacy is the root of all evil; there is a time and place for both approaches. However, advocacy can interfere with and short-circuit communication. Advocacy accounts for a lot of unnecessary conflict, where both sides focus on convincing the other rather than understanding or compromising.
A LEADERSHIP STRATEGY FOR SUCCESS
The next time you are compelled to advocate, pause. Ask questions that will help you understand the other side. Show your audience you respect them and want to know more. After all, you likely have a common goal for the result, it’s just a matter of how you get there. Once you understand the alternate point of view, flip to questioning that will make your audience contemplate and consider your point of view and possibly reconsider theirs.
With the right line of questioning, you can be revered as a poised, intelligent leader. Your audience will be moved to think and, in all likelihood, inspired to act to help you achieve your vision for the common goal.