Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to build an effective non-profit website

Here are three essential steps needed to build a website that not only attracts and retains visitors, but also inspires and engages them.

How to build an effective non-profit website

[venusvi / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Daria Gonzalez

CEO, co-founder · Wunderdogs

A nonprofit’s website remains one of its most important tools for engaging audiences. It serves as a digital hub that ties together web strategies and directs visitors where they need to be. Think of it as the control center for your mission; it guides potential donors, volunteers, and partners toward meaningful action. 

But what makes a nonprofit website truly effective? In working with nonprofits, my team and I at Wunderdogs have developed a guide to the essential steps needed to build a website that not only attracts and retains visitors, but also inspires and engages them.

STRATEGY: LAYING THE FOUNDATION

Before diving into design or content, it’s important to define the website’s key goals. For most nonprofits, these include attracting donors, engaging participants, showcasing the mission, and building trust through transparency.

For instance, the website for an organization that helps people combat harassment might highlight the organization’s mission and history, while providing clear pathways for donations and resources. Setting clear goals like these ensures that every page and piece of content serves a purpose.

A well-thought-out sitemap is also crucial. Clear navigation allows users to find the information they need quickly, improving their experience and increasing the likelihood that they’ll engage further. Think about the different user flows: A potential donor should be able to find impact reports and donation options with ease, while someone looking to join a program should see participation opportunities. 

Choosing the right content management system (CMS) is another foundational step. WordPress and Webflow are two popular options for nonprofits due to their flexibility and user-friendly interfaces. They also support essential plugins for managing donations and forms, such as GiveWP for WordPress or Memberstack for Webflow. These tools allow nonprofits to easily accept online donations, manage subscription forms, and integrate with CRMs, ensuring that every interaction on the website is captured and nurtured.

CONTENT: PUTTING THE MISSION FIRST

Building a content-first website means prioritizing your message and your unique point of view. A website that aligns its content with its mission creates a stronger connection with users. It helps you tell your story in a way that resonates with your audience and encourages action. Additionally, content is key for search engine optimization (SEO), and makes it easier for new users to find your website organically.

The homepage serves as the gateway to your nonprofit’s mission. It should act as a roadmap to other content and provide a clear introduction to your organization while directing visitors to key pages. This setup not only draws in users, but also provides them with a sense of direction for exploring the site further.

Strong calls to action (CTAs) are the bridge between engagement and action. CTAs like “Donate Now” or “Join Our Cause” should be strategically placed throughout the website, guiding users to take the next step. It’s also helpful to include broader CTAs like “Get in Touch,” which can open doors for partnerships, media inquiries, or new opportunities. Make sure your CTAs are clear, action-oriented, and placed in spots where they’re likely to attract clicks, whether that’s on the homepage, at the end of blog posts, or within project pages.

DESIGN: ACCESSIBILITY AND USER EXPERIENCE

An effective nonprofit website is one that is not only visually appealing, but also accessible. ADA-compliant is no longer a best practice or a nice-to-have, it’s a requirement to ensure that people of all abilities can access and interact with your site. This includes providing alternative text for images, ensuring good color contrast, and making navigation easy to use with screen readers.

Another key consideration is ensuring the website performs well across devices. Today’s users expect a seamless experience whether they’re on a desktop, tablet, or smartphone. A responsive design ensures that content looks great and functions properly on any screen size. This not only improves user experience, but also helps with search engine rankings, as mobile usability is a critical factor in SEO.

CONCLUSION: A WEBSITE IS NEVER “DONE”

Launching a website is just the beginning. To remain effective, a nonprofit’s website requires ongoing attention and maintenance. This includes updating content regularly to keep it relevant, optimizing for SEO to maintain visibility, and addressing any technical issues that might arise. Hosting should be reliable, with regular backups and security checks to protect against potential threats.

In the end, building an effective nonprofit website is about doing the groundwork: having a clear strategy, engaging content, thoughtful design, and a plan for the future. When done right, a website can be a powerful tool to amplify your mission and foster a community of supporters. While it’s an ongoing project, investing in the right steps from the start sets you up for long-term success.