Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Beyond last-click attribution: Unlocking true incrementality for advertisers

By embracing a more nuanced approach to marketing attribution, brands can ensure they drive immediate sales and cultivate lasting relationships with their consumers.

Beyond last-click attribution

[Yakobchuk Olena / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Tim Vanderhook

CEO, Co-Founder & Chairman · Viant Technology

The strategies and metrics that once defined successful advertising are becoming muddled in an increasingly streaming-driven landscape. Almost half of marketers now struggle with accurately measuring ROI across digital platforms.

To make sense of performance, many advertisers default to last-click attribution—a model that gives all the credit for a sale to the final action before conversion. However, this approach ignores the critical role earlier touchpoints play in the buyer’s journey, often assigning credit for sales that would have happened anyway.

This leads to misallocated budgets and missed opportunities for long-term brand growth and true incrementality. By focusing solely on lower-funnel tactics, brands miss the broader picture: the significant role that brand awareness and upper-funnel activities play in driving consumer behavior, particularly in CTV. 

Here’s why relying so heavily on last-click attribution is fundamentally flawed and what digital advertisers should do instead.

THE FALLACY OF ATTRIBUTION

The issue at hand is one of attribution versus real contribution. Chasing measurable results, many brands allocate their budgets to channels that show immediate, quantifiable metrics. This often leads to over-investment in channels that simply capture existing demand rather than creating new demand. In essence, these brands are merely attributing sales to the last touchpoint without recognizing the preceding factors that truly contributed to the purchase decision.

Let’s take a look at a scenario my brother and business partner, Chris Vanderhook, recently recounted on LinkedIn. During the Paris Olympics, Nike sponsored athletes wearing a signature yellow shoe, in addition to running emotionally resonant CTV ads. When my nephew, inspired by Nike’s athlete endorsements and storytelling, searched for the shoes on Google and purchased them, last-touch attribution would credit the sale to Google search. However, it was the emotional connection for the product built through the featured athletes and the initial CTV campaign that truly motivated his purchase.

This reliance on last-touch attribution stems from recency bias—the tendency to weigh recent events more heavily than earlier ones in determining an outcome. As a result, channels like CTV and streaming audio—where real brand loyalty and customer connection are forged—are undervalued.

Ignoring these touchpoints, which inspire trust, can erode long-term brand value. In fact, 71% of consumers say it’s more important than ever to trust a brand they buy from, and over half are willing to pay more for trusted brands.

THE POWER OF FULL-FUNNEL MARKETING

The key to overcoming this challenge is adopting a marketing strategy that values both brand-building and performance marketing.

By recognizing that upper-funnel activities like athlete endorsements and CTV advertising contribute significantly to creating demand, brands can allocate their budgets more effectively. In fact, brands that add upper-funnel marketing such as these to their campaigns can see a 70% increase in ROI. This holistic approach ensures the entire customer journey is accounted for from awareness to purchase, rather than just the final click.

In baseball terms, rethinking attribution is akin to digital marketing Moneyball. Instead of just measuring baseball hits, it’s key to also measure walks, since they both result in runs. This was famously illustrated by Billy Beane’s management of the Oakland A’s, resulting in an overhaul of major league baseball measurement and management. 

Last-click attribution is no different—focusing on the final touchpoint while ignoring the actions that set it all in motion.

To effectively adopt a marketing strategy that values both brand-building and performance marketing, start by setting clear objectives that distinguish between upper and lower-funnel activities. Track KPIs like awareness and sentiment for brand-building, and pair them with performance metrics like conversions and ROAS. That way, you’re playing the long game while still getting those short-term gains. 

Furthermore, brands can set themselves up to win by adopting an omnichannel mindset. For example, you can launch sequential messaging across devices, where ads follow consumers from CTV to mobile, keeping the narrative consistent across the customer journey. Another powerful tactic is contextual advertising based on content genres, ensuring ads align naturally with the content your consumers are already interested in.

STOP CHASING VANITY METRICS

Brands must shift their focus from simply attributing sales to truly understanding the contributions of various marketing efforts. This means investing in comprehensive measurement frameworks and platforms that capture the full impact of both upper- and lower-funnel activities, providing a full picture of multi-touch attribution.

Investing in a holistic measurement framework, such as platforms that integrate multi-touch attribution (MTA) or marketing mix modeling (MMM), provides a comprehensive view of how upper-funnel activities, like CTV ads, influence lower-funnel conversions (full disclosure: Viant offers an MTA solution).

Platforms with customizable, cross-channel dashboards enable teams to track multiple KPIs for each marketing strategy, providing a unified understanding of the customer journey from initial awareness to conversion. This real-time visibility allows marketing, sales, and data teams to collaborate effectively and adjust strategies based on shared, actionable insights.

Additionally, AI-powered analytics can improve measurement by spotting patterns in the customer journey, revealing which channels—or channel combinations—drive the most sales and loyalty.

By making these changes, advertisers can avoid the pitfalls of chasing misleading metrics and instead capture holistic reporting. 

INVEST IN THE TRUE VALUE OF YOUR MARKETING EFFORTS

As Chris aptly put it in his post: “The best time to change direction was yesterday. The second best time to change direction is today.”

By embracing a more nuanced approach to marketing attribution, brands can ensure they are not only driving immediate sales but also cultivating lasting relationships with their consumers.

As the advertising landscape continues to evolve with the advent of AI, the brands that succeed will be those that understand and invest in the measurement of the true value of their marketing efforts—beyond the last click.