Something I’ve learned as an entrepreneur is that what works for someone else won’t necessarily work for you.
It’s really common—especially for startups—to see a big, popular brand and assume that everything they do is the reason they’re successful. Younger companies try to learn from them and sometimes even copy them.
This is a big mistake. It’s called the brand imitation trap. And in today’s business landscape where having a distinct and authentic brand identity is more important than ever, it’s a trap you should do your best to avoid.
UNDERSTANDING THE LIMITATIONS OF IMITATION
The reality is that bigger brands have more flexibility and freedom to try different things since their brand is already so well known. When your smaller brand tries to mimic a certain tactic or campaign put out by a bigger company, try to remember that what works for them likely won’t work for you.
An established brand with a big community can produce mediocre content and will still blow your metrics out of the water simply due to A) the size of their existing community, and B) the trust they’ve already built with their customers. They are also more likely to leave a risky situation unscathed due to their existing brand awareness.
Take Coca-Cola for example. One of their biggest and longest-standing slogans is simply the word “Enjoy.” Could a small startup pull something like this off? Without the same tenure or recognition, probably not.
AVOID THE BRAND IMITATION TRAP WITH AUTHENTICITY AND TRUST
Luckily, there are a few steps smaller brands can take to avoid falling into this trap. Here are my recommendations.
First, it pays to be yourself over time.
With persistence and consistency, you can build a community around your company that supports and loves you for “being you.” This authenticity is key to building trust in your company and brand.
I’ve also come to realize that nowadays people tend to trust individuals over brands specifically. So my advice would be to really lean into the leaders in your organization to help differentiate and build trust around them. Trust in your company/brand will soon follow.
START SMALL AND PLAY THE LONG GAME
Building this trust also requires you to start small with your platform. Find something niche and unique that you have an opinion on. When others can’t speak to something as well or as informed as you, that’s when the magic happens. You stand out and become a trusted voice. Then, as you grow your audience, you essentially “earn the right” to get more broad with what you can talk about.
For example, at Wistia, we found early on that by teaching people how to turn conference rooms into a company studio, we could help the small group of companies ready to DIY video. This ended up resonating massively with our audience at the beginning of our company’s journey.
Yes, this all takes time. But great things usually do. Positive and extensive brand recognition does not happen overnight.
GET TO KNOW YOUR CUSTOMERS
Brand imitation is often driven by a short-term mindset, so don’t take shortcuts. In my experience, when you chase the shortcuts instead of doing the necessary work, it’s harder to be successful in the long run.
This is especially true when it comes to your customers. For smaller brands, it’s important to figure out what actually works for your customer base and do that—and it’s not necessarily going to look the same as bigger brands. Mirroring larger companies often leads to smaller ones overpromising and under-delivering, which squashes customer trust moving forward.
If your campaign or marketing effort happens to look like what a big brand is doing, then great! But at least you know that you’re giving your customers what they want because you’ve done the work.
Continue measuring this success with customer surveys and tracking metrics around performance and brand traffic.
CRAFT YOUR OWN STORY
I know this is all easier said than done. Startup culture conditions us to hustle as entrepreneurs. It does not encourage us to play the long game, and thus makes it easier to fall into the brand imitation trap.
But I’m here to tell you, the long game pays off. At Wistia, we just celebrated our 18th birthday. How did we get here? Largely by being our most authentic selves and building trust with our customers over the years.
Craft your own story for your company. It takes a huge amount of effort and work, but trust me, it’s worth it in the end.