Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Making sense of humor

Constraints may inspire innovation and ingenuity, but they can also kill the vibe. How do we get to a place where we have intent and directive, but with the creative brain firmly in the driving seat?

A man sits at a typewriter with magical letters coming out of the top as he writes

[Adobe Stock / Sergey Nivens]

Profile photo of Neil Whitfield

Creative Director · Reed Words

“Analyzing a joke is like dissecting a frog. Nobody laughs, and the frog dies.” — Barry Cryer

It’s a funny thing, humor. The need to laugh, and to make others do the same. It’s an elusive quality, existing as it does between the highly personal and the universal, vacillating between the comforting and the downright offensive. We use humor for both self-defense and attack—and as a substitute for chiseled abs. It’s arguably our most mercurial and human trait.

Why, then, would anyone expect it from a packet of cheese? Or a bottle of beer? Or a carton of oat milk? Why do brands insist on trying to be funny?

THE ART OF ARTIFICE

Consumers form emotional, para-social relationships with brands and products, and we, as brand creators, use this to our advantage. It’s how brand platforms are constructed: from a core value or idea to a codified personality. It’s how stories are crafted, and how we (and the algorithm) model our audience in order to design them the perfect partner. And everyone wants a relationship with someone who makes them laugh.

It can be transformative. An effective use of humor gave mulched oat-water a personality and a point of view. And it’s not a passing phase—as a verbal branding specialist, I’ve had to walk into the comedy minefield at least four times in the last year: for toilet paper, whiskey, fintech, and self-driving vehicles. 

SO WHY DOES EVERYONE WANT IN ON THE JOKE? 

Nothing gets clicks or Linkedin shares like a well-crafted zinger. But I think it’s less superficial than that.

Over the last 20 years, we’ve seen organizations cede control of their brands to the people as the internet and social media have laid waste to the old broadcast model. We can no longer tell people what brands are about, they have to feel and experience it at every moment. If a brand feels inauthentic or cynical, consumers will reject it. Or worse, call it out.

Brands need to use their voices in a way that feels like an active participant in the conversation. The para-social relationship has become social.

And there it is. The bogey-word of brand strategists: authenticity. Humor works as a shorthand to evoke human relatability, but to do it authentically takes nuance and precision. Get it wrong—try too hard to be funny, be too broad with execution, or confuse ‘edgy’ with ‘obnoxious’—and the brand can fall into a ruinous uncanny valley of insincerity. 

So, we end up in this paradoxical space where we need to place careful guidance around what sense of humor a brand has—the language choices it makes, the kind of jokes they crack—and to do it in a way that doesn’t feel over-engineered. Precise and intentional, yet completely natural. Tricky.

LANDING THE JOKE

Constraints may inspire innovation and ingenuity, but they can also kill the vibe. How do we get to a place where we have intent and directive, but with the creative brain firmly in the driving seat?

• Embody the voice. Have a character in mind—one universally recognized and easy to emulate while writing. Be the avuncular Billy Crystal of breakfast cereal or the disruptive Mitch Hedberg of Californian wine. Anthropomorphizing a bold, clearly defined character can put the linguistic decision-making into an intuitive mode. “Would Taylor Tomlinson use that word?” is a lot easier to answer than, “What word sounds like weaponized vulnerability?”

• Set as few rules as possible. And make them clear and binary. The more complex the guidance, the less fun it is to use. And less fun = less funny. A brand either does or doesn’t use puns. It takes snarky shots or it doesn’t. Clarity of voice helps avoid a disconnected brand experience.

• Remember that it’s the brand’s sense of humor, not the writer’s. We all love our own jokes. As a brand writer, it’s easy to fall in love with your own work, and to resist feedback when a killer line lands badly with a different audience. ‘Kill your darlings’ has never been more important than when bringing humor into a branded space. We need to listen keenly to the crowd and have the self-awareness to step away from the work and really ask if everyone else will find it as funny or clever as we do.

• Not everyone gets to be funny. It’s a question of differentiation, and whether or not it’s right for the brand in the moment. There is nothing more infuriating than smart-arsed, whacky copy getting in the way of information. Good humor requires a canny sense of timing and not only a metrically robust understanding of the audience, but a profound sense of empathy. Understand what jokes you can make and when you can make them. Nobody wants pharma to be funny, for example, and financial institutions should never, ever say, ‘Whoopsie!’

Lastly, my advice is to always respect the challenge. Be ready to hate the joke. Comedy is hard, and proper comics spend painful decades dying on stage in half-empty rooms, honing their tone, their voice, their rhythm. Brands don’t have that luxury, and brand writers are not comedians (as much as we would like to think we are). 

In a world where people are getting more adept at ignoring traditional media, it’s never been more important to appear as human and authentic as possible in new and unexpected spaces.

Is humor a hack for humanity? Absolutely. Is it for every brand? Absolutely not. But is it possible to do it well? Only if you take it very, very seriously.