If everybody is talking about generative AI, does that necessarily mean everyone wants to use it?
No.
That bucks the conventional wisdom that assumes business leaders spend every waking moment wondering how to jump on the AI bandwagon. Instead, they are worried about data security and privacy, and they’re not rushing out to introduce yet another new technology into their organizations until they get some answers.
PARTY LIKE IT’S 2022
Numerous studies show GenAI adoption is low—Goldman Sachs even said the quiet part out loud in a report titled “Gen AI: Too much spend, too little benefit?”
Leaders’ skittishness is all the more noteworthy considering the blaring headlines from just two years ago when ChatGPT burst upon the scene. Tech publications couldn’t cover the story fast enough. Suddenly, organizations were pouring millions into the tech and getting impressive returns on their investment—or so it seemed.
“While there is no question that generative AI models, including ChatGPT, have impressive achievements and have great potential for beneficial economic effects, the extent of their macroeconomic consequences remains an open question,” a leading MIT professor concluded.
This is not to imply GenAI doesn’t have value. It does. Some organizations remain all in on it. Amazon points to past success in driving enough operating income and free cash flow to see ROI in other aspects of its business.
“We expect the same thing will happen here with generative AI,” CEO Andy Jassy said of Amazon’s AI investments. The online retailer is spending huge sums on data centers, networking gear, and hardware to meet demand for the technology.
WHAT DO HR EXECUTIVES REALLY THINK OF AI?
HR responsibilities (i.e., writing emails and job descriptions) are a perfect testing ground for GenAI, so it was only natural that I asked a roomful of HR leaders where they were in their tech journeys. They represented a variety of industries, including utilities, government, finance, and tech. What they said surprised me.
Hands down the consensus in the room was GenAI forced them to rethink what they thought they knew about AI. We talked a lot about core, or traditional, AI. By that, I mean the technology that has been around for decades and is used to calculate a person’s credit score, diagnose and prescribe treatment for an illness, and predict the weather. Most people don’t even think about it because it quietly does its job in the background.
GenAI, on the other hand, generates things—text, video, music, and world-famous paintings. The inherent problem is that it uses publicly available data, which raises a host of thorny legal issues—is it permissible to use someone else’s work and make it part of something new?
AI VS. EXCEL SPREADSHEETS
Getting back to the topic of HR: GenAI is causing agita around security and privacy. Employees are still asking if it’s going to take their jobs.
An HR leader at a nationally known utility company said the average tenure at his organization is 17 years. Employees are used to working on Excel spreadsheets. That’s where their value to the organization lies. That may explain their reluctance to learn anything new about AI. They feel they’re going to be replaced. That, in turn, impacts adoption, and companies lose out on the benefits of machine learning.
There is such a lack of understanding of what AI is, how it affects businesses, and how companies are going to scale it. Companies have a responsibility to educate their employees to remove the fear factor. Here are a couple of ways to do that.
A DIFFERENT WAY TO LOOK AT ADOPTION
- Bite-sized use cases such as email and job description generation are a safe way to show reluctant employees what AI actually does. Show them how the technology can save a recruiter an hour a day and generate higher response rates. Show how automated interview scheduling (which is more core AI) saves eight to 12 hours a week by removing the human from the repetitive, mind-numbing chore of slotting interviews.
- Tech vendors have a role to play in educating leaders. Our industry does a better job than most, but there’s still plenty of runway in terms of teaching managers what these technologies can and can’t do.
- Understanding the team’s work is another way for managers to introduce these technologies. To help build better teams, leaders have to really understand the work their teams are already doing. Most executives actually don’t. They understand a job description, but they don’t understand the practical application of that job description inside of their organization.
One day, teams will be run by managers and leaders who can manage AI as both a persona of a team and the human component.
THE LIGHTS GO ON
As I talked through these use case scenarios, I could gradually see the light bulbs going off and lots of nodding. They got it. They were not thinking about AI in that way. This was a different way to look at adoption, because what we have been told for generations is here are a list of processes that technology can handle.
A process isn’t necessarily a use case, but it can be part of one.
A leading newspaper rightly asks, “What if A.I. Is Actually Good for Hollywood?” I would ask the same question in the context of HR. We are well past the hypothetical stage and now in the realm of actual time and cost savings. At the same time, I understand the reluctance of some to take that next step.
It can feel like the Wild West out there. People are not being given much direction. But I do see a very strong desire and willingness to learn. We should do everything possible to inspire, educate, and energize around this transformational technology.