Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Driving success through intentional and inclusive mentorship initiatives

Inclusive mentorship programs can create strategic advantages for your business.

Driving success through intentional and inclusive mentorship initiatives

[Adobe Stock / Stock 4 You]

Profile photo of Heidi Jannenga

Co-Founder and Member of the Board of Directors · WebPT

Every young professional deserves to have a community at their back. Communities offer advice, connect their members to networking opportunities, and cheer from the sidelines as they watch each other succeed.

However, the unfortunate reality is that upon entering the workforce, many young professionals feel disconnected from their communities—and they often struggle to find new ones. This can be especially true for those who are the minority in their chosen fields—whether due to race, gender, ethnicity, or experience—and feel like outsiders as they face challenges with few mentors to look to for guidance.   

As the daughter of immigrants, I empathize with this experience. As I progressed in my career as a physical therapist and then co-founder of a software company, I struggled to find those who looked like me or could provide sage guidance from lived experience due to the acute lack of diversity in both the PT field and technology world.

Since then, I’ve discovered that organizations with inclusive (and thus diverse) workforces reap the benefits—and that mentorship programs play a transformative role in attracting and retaining talented employees. Here’s some insight into why, as well as how to implement such an initiative in your organization. 

BUILDING A BUSINESS CASE FOR INCLUSIVITY

Assembling a team of people from different backgrounds and experiences enriches your company. Organizations benefit from a wealth of unique perspectives (think of the problem-solving potential!)—and individual team members benefit from feeling like they belong. According to BetterUp research, belonging (i.e., not feeling like an outsider) corresponds with a 56% increase in job performance and roughly a 50% reduction in turnover risk.

The benefits extend even further than that.McKinsey performed a study on the odds of financial outperformance in diverse executive teams. They found that “a strong business case for ethnic diversity is also consistent over time, with a 39% increased likelihood of outperformance for those in the top quartile of ethnic representation versus the bottom quartile.”

Inclusive mentorship initiatives that reinforce belonging and support diverse teams are some of the most powerful ways to drive both employee satisfaction and business success.

OVERCOMING IMPLICIT BIAS

In order to build an inclusive mentorship initiative, business leaders must first challenge their biases. Why? Because even the most aware and well-meaning people are prone to unconscious bias—the automatic, unintentional judgments we make about others based on factors like race, gender, or age—which then influences our actions and decisions. 

Consider the similar-to-me effect. Connecting with (and hiring) like-minded people feels easy and natural—but falling back on those easy interactions can limit your ability to uplift diverse viewpoints, making teams more one-note. The good news is that simple awareness of these biases can help your business catch poor habits and course-correct toward a more intellectually diverse and inclusive environment.

UNDERSTANDING THE “WHY” OF MENTORSHIP

Mentorship is one of the best ways to support your employees as they navigate the complexities of the modern workforce. A majority of employees long for a mentor’s professional guidance; mentors can encourage self-confidence and job satisfaction while also reducing stress levels. Furthermore, solid mentorship can connect experienced leaders with new talent, paving the way for innovation, adaptability, and resilience.

BUILDING A HIGHLY STRUCTURED MENTORSHIP PROGRAM

Here’s how to create an inclusive mentorship program that will yield powerful results. 

1. Devise clear guidelines and objectives.

Train your mentors on effective mentoring techniques (e.g., active listening, building trust) and cultural sensitivity. During this time, impart the importance of setting clear expectations for both mentors and mentees. Ask them to establish goals and milestones, and check on those objectives regularly. 

2. Formalize the matching process.

Some team members might want to pick their mentor or mentee, however, this can promote biases in the program. Instead, take time to explain why matching based on skills, goals, and development needs promotes equity.

You can also reference examples of successful structured mentorship programs at leading companies. Consider Ford’s Mentoring Circles Program, a year-long relationship matching employees with a senior-level manager to work on skill-building and goal-setting, or Costco’s career development initiatives, which include leadership and supervisor training courses and scholarship programs to pursue both two- and four-year degrees.

3. Structure time for mentorship.

Of course, if you tell people to engage in mentorship but don’t set aside time for it, they’ll prioritize their daily tasks over the mentorship itself. To this end, provide clear guidelines that allow employees to balance mentorship alongside regular duties.

HR can help support this by recognizing mentorship contributions in performance reviews and aligning them with business goals. Keep in mind you may need to adjust hourly employees’ schedules to accommodate mentorship activities in a way that does not affect their measured productivity or compensation.

PROMOTING MENTORSHIP ACROSS DIVERSE GROUPS

When developing these programs, remember that mentors and mentees can extend beyond a traditional manager-employee relationship. Organizations can work internally with employee resource groups (ERGs) to facilitate mentorship for underrepresented employees, providing tailored support and creating a sense of community.

Additionally, consider cross-departmental and cross-level mentorship. These pairings can help break down information silos, nurturing organization-wide collaboration and broadening employee perspectives. Remember that “when employees engage with colleagues from different backgrounds and areas of expertise, they broaden their perspectives on various aspects of the business.”

TRACKING AND MEASURING SUCCESS

Accountability is a must for the overall success of your inclusive mentorship program. As such, plan to ask for regular reporting and feedback from your mentors and mentees. Also, invite participants in the mentorship program to share their success stories. This may inspire their peers and reinforce the value of these initiatives.

Make use of data, too, by tracking key metrics like mentee satisfaction, career progression, and retention rates. Some ideas for collecting and utilizing feedback to continuously improve mentorship programs include: 

  • Pre- and post-program surveys
  • Tracking the number of participants, frequency of meetings, and duration of mentee/mentor relationships
  • Career progression tracking
  • Employee promotion from within
  • Employee retention

Inclusive mentorship programs can create strategic advantages for businesses. Implement inclusive mentorship initiatives and see the results in your business’ connectivity, cohesiveness, and productivity.