The team sat stunned as their executive sponsor dismissed months of user research with five words: “We already offer this product.” In deep listening sessions with potential customers, the team had uncovered a breakthrough way to help people save while spending. What the sponsor missed was that while their company offered rebates for spending, this concept occupied an entirely different space in users’ minds. Twelve months later, a competitor launched a nearly identical concept with spectacular success.
THE EXPERTISE PARADOX
What went wrong? The sponsor’s expertise in traditional payment products had created a blind spot that cost their company a major market opportunity.
This story illustrates “the curse of expertise”—when knowing too much becomes a liability and prevents us from seeing possibilities that are hiding in plain sight—a paradox faced by leaders and experts today.
As problems become more complex, answers based on expertise derived from experience and data are not only less valuable, but actually inhibit the discovery of contemporary, innovative solutions in tune with today’s context.
THE TURNAROUND MOMENT
What if, instead of rejecting the idea out of hand, the sponsor (let’s call them Resistant Expert) discovered that their real power came not from having answers, but from learning to ask questions that unlocked their team’s collective intelligence? Then, instead of the immediate rejection, Resistant Expert might have instead invited exploration of the idea by asking simple questions like: “Help me understand how this might complement our current products,” or “What drew people to this concept when you shared it?”
From our earliest schooling, we are trained to raise our hand in class with the answer. Compounding that, we operate in an answer-driven culture where the value of spending time on a new possibility is overridden by pressure to make decisions quickly and move on.
AI IS SHIFTING OUR VALUE FROM KNOWING TO ASKING
The power of AI lies in its ability to augment and enhance human thought and creativity. That depends upon our ability to explain the context of whatever is on our mind and ask questions that allow our AI collaborator to help us expand our thinking and iterate toward new possibilities. Failing to accomplish this, the explosion of innovation and creativity possible through human and tech collaboration will not be achieved.
A SIMPLE TECHNIQUE TO SHIFT ANY TEAM’S PROBLEM-SOLVING, QUESTION-ASKING CAPACITY
Try this experiment that’s transformed thinking patterns in organizations from startups to Fortune 500s:
The rules:
- One person takes a minute or less to share a current challenge.
- Each participant gets one turn to ask a single question.
- Critical constraint: No suggestions, solutions, or disguised advice in question form.
- Questions must start with phrases like “How might we…,” “What if…,” or “I wonder why…?”.
- After everyone has contributed, the group reflects upon the differences between focusing on asking questions versus jumping to solutions.
- The problem presenter shares what they’ve learned and how this experience impacts their next steps.
- The participants share how they might translate this experience into daily work habits.
Facilitator’s guide for the debrief:
- Which questions made you see the problem differently?
- What patterns emerged in the questioning?
- Where did people struggle to resist offering solutions?
- What surprised you about the experiment?
- Which questions opened entirely new possibility spaces?
THE IMPACT
This technique reveals how a solution-driven mindset limits innovation. The most valuable moment typically comes when someone asks a question that makes the room go quiet—not because it’s complex, but because it fundamentally reframes the challenge in a way no one had considered.
In a recent workshop with diverse executives from multiple sectors and geographies, participants were moved by the change in the group dynamic, how liberating it was to be more thoughtful and escape from a transacting orientation, how much more valuable that felt, and how many new angles were identified on the problem that otherwise might have been overlooked.
Once you’ve tested it out, introduce this technique and see if you can turn “problem-solving” sessions into “problem-questioning” sessions. What new possibilities emerge? Especially potent areas in which to try this: product development, customer experience redesign, digital transformation, culture change, customer interviews, strategy work, AI implementation, and innovation sessions.
Don’t believe that you’ve got the power to drive transformative change by adopting the simple behavior of asking questions that provoke exploration? According to self-titled “questionologist” Warren Berger:
- Uber started when Travis Kalanick and Garrett Camp couldn’t hail a taxi and asked, “What if you could hail a cab using your phone?”
- “Why isn’t the water reaching the people who need it?” triggered the creation of Water.org, which tackles the problem of one billion people lacking access to safe water.
- The Olympics originated when Baron Pierre de Coubertin of France founded the IOC in 1894 to answer the question, “What if countries competed on playing fields instead of battlefields?”.
In an age of increasing complexity driven by AI, robotics, advanced data analytics, and societal change, the smartest person in the room is no longer the one with all the answers, but the one who can ask the questions that unlock new possibilities.