Queue NSYNC’s “Bye Bye Bye” because a breakup may be in your future.
Finding the right PR agency can feel like dating. You may think you’ve found the right PR fit when they’re telling you everything you want to hear and the outlook is promising. Then suddenly, you’re six months into the relationship and you’ve got the ick.
I meet with a lot of marketing teams, and many of them share horror stories about their ex-PR agency: processes that didn’t work and communication that left them frustrated.
So, how do you choose a PR agency that will meet your high expectations? Well, like dating, it can be tricky—but it’s possible to find the one.
Here are the three non-negotiables you should expect from your PR agency for a successful partnership. If they aren’t living up to these standards, it’s time to switch to a team that will.
CONNECTING BACK TO YOUR BUSINESS OBJECTIVES
Your PR agency should be telling you how the numbers they report on are connected to your business’s goals. This one seems obvious, right? You’d be surprised how many agencies report PR metrics with little-to-no context tying back to ROI.
You’ve probably seen this reporting in practice with an agency. Because PR is what your PR team knows best, they might throw some arbitrary numbers at you with no explanation or put a PR spin on why those numbers are great. How are you supposed to know if 100 mentions of your company is a good result? Compared to what?
Once you’ve communicated your business objectives to your agency, they should be connecting their work to those objectives. A lot of that connection comes with context.
Let’s say your primary objective is receiving investor funding. You don’t care that your PR agency secured four podcast opportunities. In fact, you already knew that from your weekly update. But I’m sure you’d want to know if one of your CEO’s podcast appearances resulted in social media engagement from a VC firm.
A PR agency should know your goals and report on metrics that connect back to those objectives.
PROVIDING STRATEGY REAL TALK
You don’t want a PR team that’s going to be intimidated by the big dogs on a conference call. You need a team that knows what they’re talking about and is willing to push back if your idea isn’t going to work. Chances are, they’ve seen similar mistakes play out countless times before and can help you avoid them entirely. This is the reason you pay PR teams, and I call it “strategy real talk.”
Maybe your team wants to launch a new product in the last week of the year. You know, the week everyone is on winter break? Bad idea. Maybe your C-Suite wants to issue a press release on a weekly basis, oversaturating the market and making it impossible for the target audience to know what the real news is and what is fluff. Another bad idea. We’ve seen it all before, and it’s our job to give you good advice.
When choosing or evaluating a PR agency, it shouldn’t be the one that is afraid to tell you “no.” A true partnership is about bringing the best ideas together. Any PR agency letting you fail is not a true partner.
SPEAKING YOUR LOVE LANGUAGE
I like to think there are professional love languages that help people connect and become productive teams. At Next PR, we wear many hats for our clients, from project managers to creative strategists and everything in between. The most common complaint I hear from prospective clients is that they feel like they were the ones managing their previous agency, when it should be the reverse. The client constantly had to check in, ask questions the PR team didn’t have the answers to, and hold the PR team’s hand when it came to understanding their services.
Let’s get one thing straight: Hiring a PR agency is supposed to make your life easier. If you want a weekly to-do list with status updates on all the moving parts, your PR agency should do exactly that. If you want short and sweet emails with action items highlighted for easy reading, your PR agency should be sending you those formatted emails.
I had a client once tell me she hated small talk at the top of our weekly syncs. While it felt weird to immediately jump into our agenda without a “Hi, how are you?,” I knew talking about the weather or weekend plans was just not important to her.
A good PR agency can adapt to your preferences.
THE FINAL WORD
If your current PR agency is missing the connection between results and your business objectives, not giving you “strategy real talk,” or making your life more difficult, it may be time to find a better partnership. Now that you know how to choose a PR agency that works for you …
“Hey Siri, play ‘Bye Bye Bye’ again.”