Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to achieve nonprofit sustainability by incorporating business principles

The most effective nonprofit leaders aren’t afraid to borrow ideas and practices from the for‑profit world.

How to achieve nonprofit sustainability by incorporating business principles

[Adobe Stock / WinThing]

Profile photo of Jonathon Nevett

President and CEO · Public Interest Registry

Just like art and commerce, business principles may seem to be diametrically opposed to the altruistic values of a nonprofit’s mission. But the most effective nonprofit leaders aren’t afraid to borrow ideas and practices from the for‑profit world, because for nonprofits to be able to continue advocating and pushing for positive change, they need to stay financially successful. 

I know these two worlds well: As the CEO of Public Interest Registry (PIR), a nonprofit created by the Internet Society to manage the .ORG top-level domain, and a board member of several others, I am familiar with the numerous financial challenges many of my peers face—unpredictable funding, donor retention, compliance, and balancing financial responsibility with accountability to the mission. And as a business leader who co-founded Donuts Inc., raised more than $150 million, and became Deloitte’s 2017 fastest growing company in North America, I understand the principles needed to keep a company afloat and to grow sustainably.

Here are three key ways nonprofits can incorporate a business mindset to ensure sustainability in today’s nonprofit landscape.

1. INVEST IN YOUR PEOPLE

One of the most valuable lessons I learned throughout my career is that employees are a company’s greatest asset. For nonprofits, investing in staff is not just a best practice—it’s essential for achieving their missions. At PIR, we absolutely have prioritized our staff, recognizing that their passion and dedication drive our success. When employees feel fulfilled and happy at work, they become more productive.

I’m a strong believer in sharing financial success of a company with staff: when the company does well, staff should do well too. This is easier in the for-profit world by providing equity for all employees, profit sharing plans, etc. It is harder for nonprofits given our missions and models, but we can still challenge the overworked and underpaid stereotypes of our industry with flexible work schedules, bonuses, and great benefits.

Aside from providing competitive compensation and a healthy work-life balance at PIR, we also prioritize fostering a positive and engaging work environment. Nonprofits can create an environment that fosters collaboration, respect, and support by promoting open communication, transparency, recognizing employee achievements, and encouraging teamwork. We consistently invite employees to engage in open dialogue on our goals and mission, to ensure they feel aligned and fulfilled by their work.

2. RESPONSIBLE GROWTH IS YOUR CORNERSTONE

PIR learned the importance of growing responsibly the hard way. In the few years before I started, growth for growth’s sake seemed to be the mantra. Deep discounting led to growth, but many of the domain registrations PIR had acquired were not quality registrations. These names were rife with Domain Name System (DNS) abuse, especially phishing—where individuals or companies register very similar domain names to those of established brands, often to mislead consumers or extort money from the legitimate entity.

We knew that growth for growth’s sake does not result in long-term success, and we had to pivot our strategy. So we began to clean out the “bad” domain registrations, and doubled down on our anti-DNS abuse efforts. A year later, we launched the Quality Performance Index (QPI), a program that incentivizes low abuse rates while continuing to increase registrations. It measures the quality of registrations, not just the quantity, and offers our partners incentives for meeting metrics, indicating quality registrations. In so doing, the program builds credibility for our partners and promotes accountability across the industry to maintain a clean Internet.

We aim to help mission-driven organizations succeed online by focusing on responsible, quality growth and supporting those who truly benefit from the .ORG domain. I believe this credibility we’ve gained as the anti-abuse leader in the domain space has led us to grow and surpass a major milestone of 11 million .ORG domains under management, and for the .ORG domain to have the highest renewal rates of its peers. 

My advice to other nonprofit leaders is this: bigger isn’t always better. Before considering an expansion or a new program, make sure you’re able to execute it in a way that aligns with your core mission. Delivering quality, mission-aligned programming consistently over time is the best formula for long-term success.

3. DIVERSIFY YOUR REVENUE STREAMS

Since one of the most significant challenges faced by nonprofits is financial instability, relying heavily on a single source of income—whether it’s grants, donations, or fundraising events—can leave nonprofit organizations vulnerable during economic downturns or changes in donor behavior. 

When I first joined PIR, our funding relied heavily on one partner. While this provided a solid foundation and they are a great partner, it quickly became clear that relying too much on a single income stream could be risky to the sustainability of any organization in the long term. A downturn in the market or a shift in customer preferences could jeopardize a nonprofit’s mission. To create a more resilient financial foundation, it is imperative to be flexible and adapt to market needs by diversifying revenue streams.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Adopting a business-like approach in nonprofit management doesn’t mean sacrificing your values as a nonprofit—it can mean enhancing your capacity to fulfill your mission. If you invest in employees as your biggest asset, only go after responsible growth, and ensure your nonprofit’s revenue streams are diversified, you can achieve sustainability and greater impact in the communities you serve.