Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

A balanced approach to tech regulation represents an opportunity for businesses

Let's explore the approaches taken in the EU, US, and UK in three core areas: data protection, artificial intelligence, and Web3.

A balanced approach to tech regulation represents an opportunity for businesses

[Billy / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Stephen Feline

Director of North America · London & Partners

The United States and the European Union offer two radically different value propositions to investors based on their proposed regulation—or lack thereof—for the tech sector. Driven by a focus on fiduciary responsibility to consumers and the protection of smaller businesses, the EU is pursuing tighter legislation governing big tech, enforced with the threat of significant large fines. In contrast, the US is expected to enter a period of looser regulations under the new administration, with many federal agencies being scaled back. 

Meanwhile, the UK is charting a course of agile and flexible legislation that seeks to empower specific industries while balancing opportunities with consumer protection. This builds on the success of initiatives where the UK gained a first-mover advantage in areas like open banking, which created a wave of fintech unicorns such as Wise and Revolut that have since gone global, and the Digital Markets Unit (DMU), which prevented anti-competitive behavior in the tech industry to ensure a level playing field for scale-ups. 

To explore this, we’ll explore the approaches taken in the EU, US, and UK in three core areas: data protection, artificial intelligence, and Web3. 

GDPR: DATA PROTECTION

The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) was launched by the EU in 2016 to protect the personal information of EU citizens and showcases how transatlantic rules work in practice.   

One key part of GDPR legislation is its extraterritorial scope, meaning that EU citizens are covered even if their data is collected and sold without their consent while they are in the United States. With fines representing €20m or 4% of global annual turnover (whichever value is higher), this is something companies can’t ignore.  

While no federal-level equivalent to GDPR has been implemented, several states including California, Colorado, New York, and Virginia have brought in their own data protection regulations based on the GDPR model that also charge fines. With the fragmented and multi-level regulatory landscape in the US, an aggressively pro-business national government could only prevent States from bringing in legislation on the European model with a Supreme Court ruling, so the risk for businesses of restrictions in some of the most populous states remains real.   

The UK is no longer part of the EU but has brought in UK GDPR, which directly mirrors the EU rules.  However, should the EU impose stricter rules in the future, the UK can opt out and keep its balanced approach. A beefed-up GDPR in the EU is a real possibility as adtechs can simply sell information related to the token representing individuals without disclosing names, email addresses, etc., and carry on business as usual, something that may attract the regulators’ attention sooner rather than later. 

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE 

With startups focused on AI receiving 28% of all VC funding in 2024, it’s clear that AI is booming and expected to provide handsome returns to investors. How to protect citizens’ rights, jobs, and well-being is a fundamental challenge to governments and an area the balanced approach of the UK seems to be getting right. 

The EU AI Act was launched in August 2024 and groups AI systems into risk levels with corresponding reporting requirements and fines (maximum penalty of €35m or 7% of global annual turnover). Business criticism of the act focuses on the fact that the wording is vague—making risk difficult to mitigate—creates high compliance costs, and makes the EU a challenging environment to create an AI startup, especially before establishing a profitable business model.

There is no comprehensive AI legislation in the US, with current legislation limited to rules issued by various federal agencies within their own sector (such as the Federal Drug Administration’s instructions related to AI in medical devices). While the new administration shows no appetite for bringing in a regulatory framework for AI, the risk of the same states that brought in data protection laws doing the same for AI remains real for businesses. 

By contrast, the UK has a flexible pro-innovation outlook for AI that uses existing laws and agencies to manage high-risk AI systems and create an environment where AI startups can thrive. It helps that the UK Prime Minister announced in mid-January an AI framework with new dedicated AI Growth Zones to speed up planning for AI infrastructure. This open, agile, and proactive approach allows the UK government to be supportive yet vigilant and keep pace with the fast-evolving world of AI.

The results have already been prevalent; Salesforce opened up a $4bn AI hub in London in 2024, while innovators including OpenAI, Scale AI, and Symbolica AI have all established significant London presences. Our data also shows that London-headquartered AI startups raised a record $3.5B in VC in 2024. This reflects a 52% increase to the levels raised in 2023 ($2.3B). 

WEB3

How to balance the opportunities and risks for consumers from digital assets and cryptocurrencies is an ongoing debate in the EU, US, and UK with a similar pattern emerging. The Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) Regulation launched in the EU provides a comprehensive legal framework for digital assets involving registration, AML requirements, transparency, fines, and a requirement for companies to mitigate their environmental impact. 

In the US, organizations including the CFTC and SEC regulate crypto assets, and the new President has stated during his election campaign that he will replace the chair of the SEC with a pro-industry alternative and empower businesses and individuals in this space. The UK implemented the Digital Assets Bill in 2024 which provides basic consumer protection for holders of digital assets while maintaining a flexible approach overall. It’s telling that US Web3 giants including Coinbase, MoonPay, and Zero Hash have established sizable offices in London, voting with their feet and wallets on where the business opportunity lies. 

Overall, it’s evident that London’s innovation and strategic regulation will not only be impactful for its own citizens but the transatlantic and European communities, as well.