Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

It’s time to rethink “quality of hire”

Here's why you should sack "quality of hire" and focus on retention instead.

It’s time to rethink “quality of hire”

[Prostock-studio / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Caitlin MacGregor

CEO & Co-Founder · Plum

It’s no secret that the adoption of AI in the hiring process has created an arms race between talent acquisition teams using the technology to sift through increasingly large mountains of applications and job seekers who have been deploying AI to submit to hundreds of positions to gain a leg up on their competition. This wave of escalation, driven in part by a fixation on metrics like time-to-hire, cost-per-hire, and most problematically, quality of hire, has led to this crossroads, where recruiters feel compelled to measure every action and candidates suffer the consequences.

The search for a solution to the quality of hire formula stretches back decades, and despite a growing industry built around the problem, no one has quite cracked the code—though not for lack of trying.

WHAT TO KNOW ABOUT QUALITY

Considering all this, I think it is time to abandon the search for a few reasons. The primary issue is that quality of hire is just not calculable. It represents a more complex problem than cost or time, with too many variables to boil down to a single, neat data point that can be presented to the C-suite.

Expanding on that, there is the subjective nature of quality when it comes to the workforce. The value an employee brings to their job on day 60 may radically differ from day 120 or day 720. As lives change, personal and professional, so do goals, aspirations, and even base needs, making it nearly impossible to pin the quality of one’s hire to a set point in time. Even as the metric has evolved, an attempt to make it quantifiable still fails to account for what makes recruiting so challenging in the first place—the unpredictable human element.

Even Dr. Sullivan, one of the earliest and most ardent proponents of quality of hire, has said, “Selecting HR metrics is unfortunately not a scientific process.”

THE CASE FOR RETENTION

Instead of focusing on the traditional recruiting metrics, I propose a much simpler method for determining success: employee retention. In fact, I believe that any time you hear “quality of hire,” you can swap in “employee retention” and reach nearly the same conclusion. Here’s why: When retention is prioritized above all other metrics, internal attitudes and hiring strategies are allowed to shift in a way that supports recruiting teams—and candidates.

Taking off the pressure to hire quickly and cheaply lets recruiters take a more nuanced, skills-based approach, allowing them to find candidates who will be effective in the role and happy and loyal to the company. The hiring managers who always want to see “one more candidate” can take the time with their search and potentially uncover a diamond in the rough. This change in tactic also has a ripple effect on job seekers, who come out of the process feeling less like data points in an ATS and more like human beings, bolstering the candidate experience and the company’s employer brand.

PUTTING RETENTION FIRST

Now for the hard part: breaking free from the “measure everything” mindset. Inevitably, leadership will have questions. Your CFO will want to know how you plan to determine the return on investment without knowing time, cost, and quality. Rest assured, retention prioritization is not a switch you can flip. It’s a cultural shift—and a long play. But ultimately, if the goal of hiring is to attract and retain effective employees, then that’s what you need to prove.

Knowing how and when a candidate became an employee, how long they’ve stayed with the organization, and what they’ve done during their tenure provides necessary context. It also serves to bridge the gap between talent acquisition and human resources, enabling your organization to gain a better understanding of the skills and talent that already exist within its workforce. Doing so can help create a loop of facilitating thoughtful hiring aligned with strategic workforce planning initiatives, and breaking the cycle of time, cost, and quality in favor of a productive, vibrant workforce that demonstrates its worth every day.