Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Reasons to get back to the office that don’t suck

Here's why I'm introducing a new hybrid work policy to get my team back into the office.

Reasons to get back to the office that don't suck

[Adobe Stock / Jeff Whyte]

Profile photo of Nisha Anand

Chief Executive Officer · Dream.Org

I’m the CEO of a 60-person organization that spans the country. I value the flexibility of remote work, and I am skeptical of many of the reasons employers use to force people to stop working from home.

So, why am I introducing a new hybrid work policy to get my teams back into offices? 

BAD REASONS FOR HEADING BACK TO THE OFFICE

If COVID-19 birthed a golden age of working from home, the last two years have been all about the backlash. Multiple employers are rescinding remote work policies and forcing their employees back into offices. I find most of the rationales unconvincing at best.

For starters, much of this trend seems to be downstream of a corporate-landlord freakout over office space sitting empty. I’m sympathetic to small businesses that rely on daily office traffic to make ends meet, but it seems silly to ask employees to bail out the owners of office spaces who bet, wrongly, that remote work would never take off.

I also hear a lot of talk about productivity. In this case, the term is too broad to be helpful. When speaking to fellow CEOs or reading the statements of business leaders, I get the sense that some confuse productivity with control or oversight over their employees. If all that matters is getting the work done, then we should be as flexible as possible: Some folks work better in the office, and others better at home. (The “water cooler conversation” wouldn’t be a thing if offices were magically more productive spaces.) If outcomes were all that mattered, we would focus on hiring good people and managing them well. Instead, talk of having people in the office where they can be supervised rigorously smacks of micromanaging work processes. I want to ask people: “Do you care about the work your team is producing, or do you really just care about making sure they look like they’re working eight hours a day?”

Another obvious bad reason: To make employees miserable so they quit instead of having to be fired. This seems to be driving the new administration’s crackdown on federal employee remote work. 

It seems like the common underlying assumption to all this is that management needs to crack down on employees by forcing them back into the office. But what if hybrid work policies actually benefit employees as much, or more, than leadership?

WHY HYBRID WORK POLICIES WORK

I can hire amazing people to do good work remotely, but I think all-remote work is doing my team a disservice.

I want my teams to lead with soul, embody servant leadership, and be solution-driven. It’s pretty hard to be soulful through screens alone. Servant leadership, for us, means knowing people’s personal stories and connecting on a human level. I don’t see that happening well remotely. The kind of creativity that leads to great solutions usually comes from people being together in one space and able to draw connections, rather than geniuses working independently.

We are a nonprofit that aims to close prison doors and open doors of opportunity. We have three major programs that work semi-independently, and teams that support those programs. We aim to find common ground across lines of division to make tangible progress on big problems. Asking people to do such work—work that requires deep human connection—without making space for deep human connection feels like a values mismatch and bad management.

Human beings are social creatures. As good as digital tools are, they cannot fully replicate the benefits of being together in person. We get to know each other on a more personal level, we connect with people we wouldn’t otherwise talk to in a Zoom meeting, and we come up with more creative ideas in informal brainstorms or overheard conversations than we do in Slack threads.

None of this is precisely about productivity—in fact, I am actually hoping to encourage the kind of water-cooler conversations that seem, on the surface, to be distractions from getting things done. I want the polite interaction to turn into a long conversation sharing personal experiences and an unprompted, out-of-the-box brainstorm about how to tackle problems. All that leads to real trust and bonds between people, and more creative and daring thinking. 

HOW TO MAKE A HYBRID POLICY WORK

So, why not just make office work optional? Well, imagine you come to the office seeking connection and creativity. But your coworker doesn’t. The next day, you decide to stay home, while another coworker comes to the office and you aren’t there. Gradually, everyone gives up. In this way, remote or optional-in-office policies punish those who benefit from creative environments.

At some point, you need to set a floor for in-office days so everyone can depend on there being the kind of critical mass of folks present to see actual benefits. At Dream.Org, we’ve decided that staff will have to be in an office at least three days a week, and we will no longer hire for remote positions outside of the communities we serve. We think this gives folks a lot of flexibility to balance families and lives with work. 

Any barriers this creates to hiring the best people will, I think, be outweighed by our people feeling more connected to each other and the mission of our organization. That, in turn, tends to bring out the best in people. If I ask my team to do that work without structured opportunities for them to interact and connect in person, I am setting them up to fail.

We aren’t giving up on flexibility or all working from home, or forcing all staff to relocate to an office. We’re just hoping to turn the dial a little bit more toward in-person interactions, in the hope that it fosters more spontaneity, collaboration, and soul.