When I was 5 or 6 years old, my grandparents took my younger brother and me for our first miniature golf outing. On the first tee, my little brother stepped up to the ball for his turn and did what he had seen adults do while playing golf: He took a full backswing. I was standing a little too close behind him and I took his putter full in the face. Fortunately, he missed my eye, but I received a nasty gash on my forehead. My brother and I both remember this incident vividly—only my brother is firmly convinced to this day that it was I who hit him.
This is just one example of how fallible human memory can be. Between my brother and me, at least one of us is completely wrong. Not only do we not know, but we also don’t know we don’t know. Broaden this out to a lifetime of memories—some of them are accurate, but many have been altered by the passage of time or made up out of whole cloth.
Ask former NBC anchorman Brian Williams. He was accused of lying and forced to resign after saying that he had come under fire while riding in a helicopter in Iraq. Williams said that he had no doubt that what he remembered was true. Public figures from George W. Bush to Hillary Clinton have been tripped up by similar misremembering. Police and prosecutors have come to realize that “eyewitness” testimony is exceedingly unreliable. Witnesses will swear to accounts that have little resemblance to what actually transpired. Furthermore, their memories can change significantly over time.
Face it, a lot of what you think you know is based on what you remember, and what you remember can be very wrong. But that’s not all.
Behavioral science has shown that humans are deeply affected by biases in our thinking. We see patterns where none exist. We frame things based on comparative instead of absolute value. We believe what confirms our opinions and disregard what doesn’t. We fear dying in a plane crash much more than dying on the highway. We get excited about saving $10 on a hamburger but think saving $10 on a house is negligible. But if we’re biased, that means that we’re often wrong—and that, once again, we don’t know.
Want more? Sure. We can’t even count on what our senses tell us. It used to be that “seeing is believing,” but even discounting AI deepfakes and optical illusions, it’s clear that we are easily deceived by what we see and hear. Think you can tell the difference between red and green? While human beings have photoreceptors for red, green, and blue, there is a prawn called a mantis shrimp that can see in twelve channels of color plus UV and polarized light. We’re even wrong when we say something is red or green, because the truth is that they are simply absorbing all other frequencies of light.
Feel that solid chair under your butt? No, you don’t. Most of the space within atoms is empty, to the extent that if the nucleus of a hydrogen atom was the size of a basketball, its electron would be about two miles away. But if you thought you knew where that electron was, and you tried to find it there, you would be wrong again. Quantum mechanics tells us that the act of observing an electron can affect its location.
Everything you know is wrong. A slight exaggeration, but only slight.
So what’s the point? Should you feel stupid? Give up? I don’t think so. In fact, I find the presumption that I am wrong about nearly everything to be liberating. Perhaps you will, too.
First, there is nothing wrong with a little humility. If we admit that we are wrong, in many ways, at many times, about many things, it makes us less high and mighty. We become just a little more open to other opinions. We’re a little more tolerant.
Second, being wrong is a lot more interesting than being right. Knowing that we’re probably wrong gives us permission to be surprised, and challenged, and to look at the world in new ways. If we learn something new, we don’t have to be ashamed or defensive that we were wrong before.
In business, assuming we are wrong can be the secret to success. It motivates us to find out what our customers are really thinking, or whether there is a better way to operate, or whether there is an untapped market we can pursue. Technology, communications, and consumer expectations change daily, so even if we were right before, we’re probably wrong now; being open to that likelihood puts us ahead of competitors who are convinced of their own infallibility.
I submit that the world has seldom been changed for the better by people who were sure they were right. I say, give yourself the freedom. Assume you’re wrong, and see where it takes you. Listen with an open mind, instead of trying to justify your position.
You’ll find yourself with a little less certainty but a lot more delight. And that’s a good thing. Right?