Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Truth is a wolf

The best way to deal with criticism that keeps following you around and won’t go away is to merge with it. Here's what you need to know.

Truth is a wolf

[Adobe Stock / AB Photography]

Profile photo of Cathy Graham

“Bill says that your new campaign sucks,” my co-worker informed me.

“Oh, really?” I asked, feeling my hands become tight fists. I was the head of marketing, and Bill was my peer in another part of the organization. He was also an opinionated, rude know-it-all who openly criticized everyone at work. His latest rant was about me. The core of the message was that I was bad at digital marketing.

“Bill thinks everyone sucks,” I said.

“I don’t know,” she replied. “I heard him talking to Tony and it sounded like they were in agreement.”

Bill was such an equal-opportunity trash talker that most people just ignored his outbursts, writing his opinions off as garbage. I know I did. But this was different. People were starting to listen to him. This was not good. And his narrative was picking up steam. More people were buying into his campaign.

It felt so awful. How could people actually take his side? Couldn’t they see it was just the same B.S. as usual?

“But wait,” my inner voice whispered. “Could Bill actually be… right?” It was a mortifying thought.

So, there we were. Each solidly in our own corners. What was my next move? How could I make this go away?

THE TRUTH IS A WOLF

After reflecting on this experience and also observing how other people reacted in similar situations, I discovered the key to navigating feedback that you just don’t agree with.

You can’t wish it away or try to avoid it. You can’t outrun it—especially if there’s some truth to it (and spoiler alert: There’s almost always some grain of truth to it). It will follow you, showing up again and again, until you face it.

The best way to deal with criticism that keeps following you around and won’t go away is to merge with it. I know that’s not what you want to hear, but it’s true.

TURN AROUND AND FACE IT

There’s a song by Mollie Marriott and the chorus says, “The truth is a wolf. It’ll hunt you down.” When you feel the wolf breathing down your neck and you just want it to go away, turn around and face it.

Here’s what that looks like:

1. Accept The Reality Of The Feedback

Resist the temptation to dismiss the feedback as completely inaccurate. Ask yourself, “How might this appear to be true to others?”

2. Understand Your Part In The Feedback

Take ownership of your part in creating the situation, even if it’s a very small part. Ask yourself, “What am I doing or not doing that is contributing to these perceptions?”

As painful as it was to admit, there was some truth to what Bill was saying. Digital marketing was not my thing. I was more interested in data and creative strategy. Bill was an arrogant jerk, but he was also kind of right. Ouch!

3. Be Conscious Of Your Ego’s Narration Of The Feedback

Do not view yourself as the good guy and the feedback provider as the bad guy. It’s not as simple as that. Ask yourself, “What story am I telling myself that is distracting me from seeing this objectively?”

Initially, Bill’s bad behavior created a great distraction from the actual feedback. But honestly, would I have been any more open to the feedback if he was nice about it? I doubt it. As a marketer, I was used to people being in my business. “Everyone thinks they’re a marketer,” I lamented, giving myself permission to ignore the feedback.

4. Step Into The Power You Have To Create The Future You Want

Let go of any baggage that is distracting you from the work you need to do. Ask yourself, “What are all the ways I could lead myself differently to create the perception I want?”

THE VALUE OF FEEDBACK

Remy Blumenfeld, who coaches creative leaders and entrepreneurs, says people are hard-wired to reject criticism. We experience it as a threat. Even feedback stated in a caring, empathetic manner is received as criticism. So, imagine how it feels when feedback is couched in highly critical remarks from someone who is not in your corner.

Let’s be clear: Insulting someone and passing it off as feedback is not okay. But sometimes your critics will give you the most accurate view of your areas for improvement. Unlike friends who may sometimes shy away from providing feedback for fear of damaging the relationship, critics just don’t care. They’re more than happy to be free with their observations of how you’re messing up.

Once I could see there was something to the criticism coming from Bill, I couldn’t ignore it. The wolf was at my door, and I couldn’t run from it anymore.

So, what did I do? Did I tell Bill or anyone else that he was right? No way.

But I stopped fighting the feedback and merged with it instead. I made a commitment to myself that I was going to dive into digital marketing, learn all that I could, and demonstrate results so no one could ever say that I was bad at it again.

And I had a blast doing it.

I haven’t seen Bill in years and I can’t say I miss him. But I can say that I am grateful that he shined a light on an area of development that I did not have on my radar. It gave me an opportunity to step out of my comfort zone and into the learning zone where growth happens. 

The next time you’re faced with feedback that stings, you can buy a pair of good running shoes and try to keep the wolf behind you, or you can remember there is an empowered approach that minimizes the feeling of threat and enables you to create the perceptions that will serve you best. You know what I would recommend.