Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Redefining insurance careers: Not your grandfather’s 9 to 5

An aging workforce, a leadership gap, and an evolving industry mean insurance isn't just hiring—it's transforming. Here's why the next generation should pay attention.

Redefining insurance carriers: Not your grandfather's 9 to 5

[Adobe Stock / insta_photos]

Profile photo of Julie Turpin

Chief People Officer & Executive Vice President · Brown & Brown (Brown & Brown, Inc. – NYSE:BRO)

For decades, insurance was seen as a buttoned-up, traditional industry—stable but slow-moving, male-dominated, and primarily focused on spreadsheets and policies. Today, the story is a little different.

Nearly 60% of the insurance workforce is now female, bringing new leadership styles and perspectives. But the pipeline still narrows at the top—only 28.5% of board seats and 22.3% of C-suite positions are held by women. Racial diversity is another area of focus. While progress is being made, only 30% of teammates in major U.S. insurance companies are people of color, and representation shrinks at senior levels.

These gaps present an opportunity. Nearly 50% of the current insurance workforce is set to retire in the next decade, leaving more than 400,000 positions open. Less than 25% of the workforce is currently under 35. That means the next generation isn’t just wanted—it’s needed.

INSURANCE NEEDS MORE THAN SALESPEOPLE

In today’s competitive employment landscape, career growth is ultimately our responsibility, not our company’s. When seeking the right-fit industry, think about what you value in a workplace, teammates, and leadership. If the following traits speak to you, insurance may be a fit.

  • Stability. No matter the economy, people and businesses need coverage for the unknown—hurricanes, data breaches, slips, trips, and falls. That makes insurance one of the most recession-proof careers.
  • Protection. Insurance is a safeguard. It helps to shield policyholders from an unnecessary loss. There are often negative connotations about the insurance industry, but at its core, it’s about protecting what people value most. There’s real pride in dedicating your career to that.
  • Relationships. Businesses and people buy insurance from those they trust. Strong relationships with customers help brokers, agents, and insurers tailor policies specifically to their customers’ exposures.
  • Financial opportunity. An insurance career pays well. Just to name a few: Actuaries earn a median of $113,990 per year and underwriters $76,390 per year.

When it comes to necessary skills, each one has a place in insurance. Insurance companies need HR leaders, marketing strategists, IT specialists, data analysts, cybersecurity professionals, and even event coordinators to support their operations.

Insurance company marketing strategists don’t just promote products, they educate consumers on complex policies, which requires a mix of storytelling and regulatory knowledge. IT professionals manage massive amounts of sensitive data while ensuring cybersecurity compliance—a critical issue as digital threats in financial services rise. Data analysts and AI specialists help insurers predict risk more accurately, using machine learning to fine-tune policies and pricing.

COMMON INSURANCE ROLES

For those interested in an insurance-specific career path, here are some common insurance roles you’ve likely heard of but may not know what they actually do:

Underwriters

Underwriters evaluate risk and determine policy pricing based on a business’s or a person’s risk factors, which can range from commercial real estate to cybersecurity liability.

  • Skills Needed: Curiosity, strong personal relationships, ability to analyze data
  • Best For: People who love problem-solving and 1:1 interaction

Claims Professionals

Claims professionals oversee payments when accidents happen, helping individuals and businesses recover financially. No two claims are alike, so claims professionals juggle fast-moving situations ranging from storm damage to liability lawsuits.

  • Skills: Adaptability, customer service, ability to work under pressure
  • Best For: People who thrive in fast-paced environments and enjoy helping others

Actuaries

Actuaries analyze data to assess financial risk, helping insurers price policies accurately. As AI and automation take hold in insurance, actuaries play a role in shaping digital transformation.

  • Skills: Analytical thinking, mathematics, computer science, problem-solving
  • Best for: Data-driven minds who enjoy working with numbers and predictive models

Risk Managers

Risk managers focus on preventing accidents before they happen—whether ensuring workplace safety, managing climate-related risks, or advising businesses on cybersecurity threats.

  • Skills: Technical knowledge, problem-solving, ability to work in both office and field settings
  • Best For: Detail-oriented people who enjoy a mix of analytics and hands-on work

THE FUTURE OF INSURANCE NEEDS YOU

The insurance industry is at a turning point that demands fresh talent, new ideas, and people willing to embrace what’s next. In an era of constant disruption—climate change, cyber threats, evolving regulations—there’s no shortage of big, meaningful problems to solve.

When you find the right career, it won’t feel like a job your parents expect you to take—it’ll be the career move that makes sense for you. So, ask yourself: Could this be the career path you didn’t see coming?