Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Advertising’s sustainability problem

It’s time for the advertising industry to embrace new technologies and innovation—not regulation and degrowth—to solve its climate crisis.

Advertising's sustainability problem

[Natalia / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Rio Longacre

Managing Director · Slalom Consulting

Sustainability has emerged as a key topic in the world of advertising, and many organizations are grappling with reducing their carbon footprint. Faced with these challenges, it’s time for the industry to embrace new technologies and innovation—not regulation and degrowth—to solve its climate crisis.

THE CLIMATE CRISIS

The modern economy runs on electricity, which comes from power generation activities that produce immense amounts of carbon dioxide, a significant contributor to climate change. In the U.S., only 21% of energy is produced by renewable sources. If we add nuclear, this number rises to 40%, but this still means that 60% of all power is produced by burning fossil fuels.

Globally, CO2 emissions surpassed 37 billion metric tons last year, rising by approximately 0.8%. To add to the mix, the rise of AI has accelerated this trend. The energy demand from AI-specific data centers alone could require an additional 14 gigawatts (GW) of new power capacity by 2030, reports the Center for Global Energy Policy.  

ADVERTISING’S ROLE IN THE CRISIS

The advertising world is a major contributor to global carbon dioxide emissions, mostly because it takes immense amounts of energy to power billions of computers, laptops, and cellphone data centers; power vast data centers; and run an interconnected worldwide web that underpins advertising technology, or AdTech.

As the media landscape has shifted from traditional to digital, the industry’s carbon footprint has grown. In 2019, digital advertising surpassed traditional advertising in the U.S. for the first time, and in 2022 it accounted for 67% of total ad revenue worldwide, with this number expected to balloon to 73% by 2028.

Looking at advertising’s carbon footprint, the Drum wrote that the typical online ad campaign emits approximately 5.4 tons of CO2, and each digital ad impression itself can produce up to 1.09 grams. Digital advertising generates approximately 3.5% of global greenhouse emissions. The airline industry, by contrast, produces 2.5% of global energy-related CO2.

INDUSTRY UNDER FIRE

Advertising and AdTech have come under a lot of fire in recent years for wasteful and unsustainable practices, and much of it is deserved. In December 2024, AdTech Radar reported that only 14% of bids are unique, with the remaining 86% duplicative or waste.

Bid duplication occurs when an SSP sends multiple requests for the same ad impression, resulting in a “convoluted ecosystem where the same impression is bid on multiple times, driving up costs for the buy-side.” This wasteful practice brings no actual benefit to advertisers or publishers.

When you look across the programmatic ecosystem, there are many such examples. The ANA put out a report that said 15% of ad spend is wasted on made-for-advertising (MFA) sites. Plus, click and ad fraud make up close to 15% of all digital traffic, estimated to reach $100 billion by the end of 2024.

All this fraudulent activity takes storage and processing power which generates a huge carbon footprint—without getting better results for marketers. The industry can and should do better. Considering these worrying trends, many argue for new regulations, and we can expect these efforts to intensify as the shift from traditional to digital advertising accelerates.

LIMITS TO DEGROWTH

A book titled The Limits to Growth was published in 1972. The book essentially said the global system cannot support present rates of economic and population growth beyond the year 2100, painting a dreary, Malthusian picture of the world.

While on one hand, the book’s thesis about the world’s interlocking/interconnected resources is important, the book failed to predict the incredible progress we would make through increases in productivity and the introduction of new, sustainable technologies.

Worse, the book helped fuel the rise of the degrowth movement and its calls for new regulations in a misguided effort to save the world by shrinking the economy. Believe it or not, some degrowthers infamously argued for a return to handwashing clothes in communal washing facilities. No, thank you.

INNOVATION, NOT REGULATION

Instead of degrowth, technology and innovation are the obvious solutions. A recent report by Accenture showed that cloud migrations alone can reduce carbon emissions by more than 84%. This report proves what a lot of us who have been working in tech have believed for a long time, namely that the shift to the cloud will have long-term benefits for society. 

Further, Microsoft made a deal to help reopen Three Mile Island’s Unit 1 by purchasing the plant’s entire net-zero electric generating capacity over the next 20 years to support the tech company’s AI ambitions. Amazon’s small batch modular reactor investment will play a big part in the company’s plan to transition to carbon-free energy in advance of its 2030 goal.

UNLOCKING THE POTENTIAL OF AI

Looking at AI, everyone talks about the impact on carbon footprint, but almost no one is talking about the potential upside. The company Linear published a list of AI tools that can ostensibly 10X an agency’s productivity. While this may be hyperbole, AI will undoubtedly create efficiencies in advertising that bend the curve of the industry’s carbon footprint.

Martin Sorrell famously said the days of 25-year-olds running paid media are over. They aren’t over yet, but his point was that trafficking ads is very time-consuming and has many steps, and this is where AI comes in. If we can speed up processes by 20, 30, or 40 percent—which doesn’t sound unreasonable—it will result in huge efficiencies with commensurate reductions in the industry’s carbon footprint.

A BRIGHT FUTURE

People may not realize it, but we are producing more today with less, and this is due mostly to technological advancements and innovation. The road may be bumpy, but it’s possible to build a future powered by technology and innovation that’s cleaner, greener, and more sustainable.