Over the past year, I’ve sat with dozens of innovation leaders across industries, from financial services to health care to consumer-packaged goods to construction to even the military. One theme has emerged consistently: Innovation teams are at risk of being early on the CFO’s chopping block whenever uncertainty looms.
Companies invest in innovation during good times but need innovation most during uncertain ones.
This usually plays out in one of two ways.
The first camp of organizations slashes innovation budgets at the first sign of economic headwinds. “We’ll restart when things stabilize,” they promise. But by the time stability returns, competitors who maintained their innovation focus have leapt ahead, securing the very market position that might have saved them.
The second camp is even more frustrating. These organizations keep innovation teams intact but strangle their impact. They demand immediate ROI on experiments, quarterly returns on long-term bets, and zero tolerance for the very failures that drive learning.
THE PREDICTABLE CONSEQUENCES OF CUTTING INNOVATION
I’ve witnessed both camps within the same organization. The results are predictable and devastating:
- Innovation teams become demoralized, and the best talent disengages or walks out the door.
- Internal stakeholders sense the devaluation and withdraw their support.
- A “one-and-done” mindset takes hold where experiments are labeled “failures” rather than learning, and promising ideas die prematurely.
Look at legacy financial services and insurance companies—consistently late to every technological revolution of the past two decades. They have largely been also-rans for the internet, mobility, social media, and now potentially AI, ceding direct customer relationships to fintech and insurtech companies and other new entrants, risking relegation to utility status.
Why does this cycle persist despite decades of evidence to the contrary?
Because during times of economic uncertainty, the measurable short-term savings of cutting innovation are immediately visible, while the catastrophic long-term costs remain conveniently invisible … until it’s too late. Declines in margin, market share, customer satisfaction, and other key metrics that innovations can impact are attributed elsewhere.
MAINTAINING INNOVATION MOMENTUM
Here’s how to maintain innovation momentum even when budgets tighten and externalities threaten disruption:
1. Dramatically lower the cost of individual experiments.
Since moving on from corporate executive roles, I’ve engaged with hundreds of early-stage startups as an investor and advisor. It’s been eye-opening to see how much these ventures accomplish with so little time, money, and people.
What I’ve witnessed has forced me to reframe what’s necessary to conduct a small-scale experiment. Challenge your assumptions about what’s needed for each experimentation cycle; you’ll likely see costs go down, team motivation increase, and the need to defend the innovation budget mitigate.
2. Focus on customer-backed innovation that brings immediate feedback.
There’s a reason that chapter one of my book, The Change Maker’s Playbook: How to Seek, Seed and Scale Innovation in Any Company, is called “Discovery.” Too many founders and corporate product managers develop products and services that nobody wants—hence, failure.
Be a vigilant explorer, gathering and using insights about customer- and user-expressed and unexpressed needs, both rational and emotional, to drive your innovation priorities. Help the rest of the organization see the connections to build buy-in.
3. Create distributed innovation networks across and beyond the organization.
Cede control. Your job is to foster communities of innovators across the organization and empower them with tools, frameworks, and methods to be successful. Be sure to demonstrate what good looks like to active, supportive allies of innovation—especially those outside your reporting line—whose success will drive the innovation agenda for the organization.
4. Increase speed by challenging status quo processes that slow innovation cycles.
Lead the way by proposing parallel decision-making processes to get approval for your projects. Do not adopt business-as-usual processes and policies—designed to run businesses at a massive scale—for tiny experiments.
5. Position innovation as risk management, not risk-taking.
Engage proactively with the top risk leaders in your organization to share where this might manifest and seek their guidance and support. I’ve been in situations where approaching these leaders, whom the innovation teams may tend to avoid, can lead to incredibly productive dialog. They know the world is changing, and they are looking for clear pathways forward. Served up with humility, your knowledge and insights as an innovator will be appreciated.
TURN UNCERTAINTY INTO OPPORTUNITY
The good news? None of these suggestions are merely theories or ideas. They are all tactics I’ve seen work in organizations I’ve served directly. I’ve also observed them among the global community of changemakers leveraging new technologies to improve marketing effectiveness, create operating efficiencies, transform the customer experience, mitigate business and brand risk, and strengthen the business model.
Don’t let economic uncertainty become the excuse that kills your company’s future. The most resilient organizations don’t innovate despite uncertainty—they innovate because of it. Innovation isn’t a luxury for good times—it’s the lifeline that pulls you through the bad ones.