In 1931, during the Great Depression, James Truslow Adams introduced a novel concept into the American lexicon. In his historical and cultural analysis of the United States, The Epic of America, Adams pioneered the term “American dream,” instituting the idea that “life should be better and richer and fuller for everyone, with opportunity for each according to ability or achievement.”
Defined differently, the American dream is the idea that “anyone can achieve success in the United States through hard work and determination.”
It was a big idea with different expressions for everyone.
However, just a few decades later, after World War II and the subsequent enactment of policies like the G.I. Bill and the creation of the Federal Housing Administration, the dream took on a more singular definition: Go to college, get married, have children, and buy a home.
Owning a home was a finish line—a sure sign that you “made it.” You achieved the American dream for you and your family. In this way, homeownership wasn’t just about housing. It was a status symbol, representing security, legacy, and future prosperity.
Baby boomers, adults ages 59 to 77, overwhelmingly embrace this definition, with 84% saying that owning a home is a foundational part of the American dream.
This definition is less appealing and important for younger generations, as just 74% of Gen X, 69% of millennials, and 67% of Gen Z agree that homeownership is an integral part of the American dream.
This shift is reshaping industries like real estate development, mortgage lending, and workforce management, making rental construction more compelling while facilitating the flexibility and adaptability that many people require.
There are many reasons for this shift. What’s clear is that people are redefining the American dream on their own terms, moving away from homeownership as the ultimate goal and toward strategic financial decisions that align with their individual priorities and lifestyle goals.
They may be on to something. Here are three key arguments for renting in 2025 and what they mean for business leaders.
THE ECONOMIC CASE
This one is easy.
Constrained supply and surging demand have coalesced to increase housing prices, leaving up to 55% of active home buyers unable to find one at a price they can afford.
A separate survey of potential home buyers found that 87% of respondents are worried about the cost of housing, while 73% of aspiring homeowners cite affordability as their primary obstacle to home ownership.
Currently, buying a home is 52% more expensive than renting, marking the largest cost gap since 1996. This has prompted the Wall Street Journal to declare it the worst time to buy instead of rent.
For the 50% of prospective home buyers who say they can’t afford a down payment or closing costs, renting offers an opportunity to attain high-quality housing while controlling expenses, including down payments, closing costs, and maintenance costs that add to a home’s total cost over time.
As a result, there is a compelling case for real estate developers (and the financial institutions funding their efforts) to prioritize building flexible, affordable rental units, catering to the growing demographic priced out of homeownership.
THE LIFESTYLE CASE
While many people choose to rent because the economics of ownership don’t make sense, many others choose to rent because of the freedom and flexibility it affords.
In this case, the equation is simple: Renters can move when and where they want without worrying about selling a home.
For example, one survey found 17% of Americans want to move outside the U.S. in the next five years, bolstering a flexible living trend with implications for national and international housing.
In this way, renting is a significant advantage for people who are unsure where they want to live or may need to relocate for work.
For businesses, this trend may impact the practicality of their return-to-office polices. In short, if you want access to the best Gen Z talent, you may have to consider more flexible work arrangements to adapt to the flexibility afforded by compelling rental options.
THE COMMUNITY CASE
Renting used to be defined by two dichotomies: scattered single-family homes for rent or apartment complexes. While both rental options are valuable, they also have certain stigmas and limitations.
Renting a single-family home in a neighborhood with owners can be isolating, as renters often feel like outsiders. At the same time, living in an apartment complex isn’t for everyone, as the constant noise and proximity to neighbors can be overwhelming.
The rise of build-to-rent (BTR) communities is changing the perception of renting. Unlike scattered single-family rentals, these purpose-built neighborhoods offer a shared experience, resources, and community that renters crave.
Put differently, today’s renters have more options than ever before, making it easier for them to find the housing situation that is right for them.
The implications are far-reaching, as BTR is being embraced by major real estate firms and institutional investors. Driven by strong demand from renters seeking flexible housing solutions, these firms are allocating substantial capital to develop and acquire BTR assets.
REDEFINING THE DREAM
The American dream was never supposed to be about achieving a specific socioeconomic status or always attaining more stuff. It was not about buying a house. It was about the freedom to pursue happiness and opportunity on your terms.
For some, that still means working to buy a home. For others, it means leveraging rental housing to achieve their financial goals, prioritize flexibility and experiences, and live in thriving communities.
Companies recognizing and responding to these shifts will be better positioned to attract talent, optimize investments, and drive sustainable growth.
Buy or rent? It’s a question everyone has to ask themselves. There are strong arguments to make on both sides, but one option doesn’t define the dream. Only we do that.