Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

What Marketers Are Getting Wrong About AI

The future of marketing isn’t AI replacing people. Brands that win the AI race will be the ones that use AI to supercharge their people, not do the same things cheaper.

What Marketers Are Getting Wrong About AI

[Courtesy of Michael Aaron Flicker]

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

Most marketers’ obsession with AI is misdirected. Yes, AI can run your chatbots and take meeting notes, but deploying it to take over tasks that humans once did is not the best use of AI’s incredible power. For XenoPsi Venture’s Founder and CEO MichaelAaron Flicker, the most impactful way to use AI is to enhance human creativity, not the other way around.

“This generation of AI isn’t here to replace human creativity, it’s here to supercharge it,” Flicker says. “The best marketers will be the ones who harness AI  to go beyond cutting costs, but to unlock new levels of imagination, strategy and execution.”

THAT TRAGIC COCA-COLA COMMERCIAL

Did you see this holiday commercial for Coca-Cola, the one that managed to make the Christmas spirit creepy? The AI-generated commercial was widely panned for being an eerie, uncanny valley-type holiday scene, giving a skin-crawling vibe rather than the warm and fuzzy holiday commercials the brand is known for. Why the “Real Thing” thought making a very unreal commercial was a good idea, audiences may never know, but that poor decision was founded in the idea that AI should create. It shouldn’t. 

LINE COOK VERSUS MASTER CHEF

All AI can do is take information that already exists and consolidate it into images, text or sound following instructions input by the AI operator. It can’t think, use judgement or be creative. Large language models today rely on deductive reasoning, which means they start with general rules and apply them to specific cases. This works well for tasks like summarizing information or predicting the next words in a sentence, but it’s not yet capable of conjuring breakthrough ideas.

AI AS A STRATEGIC THOUGHT PARTNER

No matter how good AI gets, it will never replace the human imagination. Instead of using it to create, Flicker believes marketers should view AI as a strategic thought partner. Instead of asking AI questions and hoping it can deliver useful results, humans should be the ones in the hot seat with AI doing the prompting.  

“The future of marketing isn’t AI replacing people, it’s AI making people more innovative and effective,” Flicker says. “The brands that win won’t be the ones that use AI to do the same things cheaper. They’ll be the ones that use AI to do things that were never possible before.”

AI has passed the bar exam and United States Medical Licensing Exam. It may not be creative, but it’s really, really smart. It’s the uber-knowledgeable, multi-degreed colleague you want at the table when you’re brainstorming and need someone to bounce ideas off of.

In 2023, Boston Consulting Group Harvard Business School released a study that compared two groups of BCG consultants: those with access to AI and those without. The consultants with AI completed 12% more tasks and did so 25% faster. They also produced results their bosses thought were 40% better. 

As a result of Flicker’s passion for the amazing things AI can do, his advertising agency, Method1, has AI mandates across the company focusing on the 20% of use that garners 80% of the results.  

“At Method1, we see AI as a creative partner, not just an efficiency tool,” Flicker says. “We are much more concerned about how AI helps unlock the creativity and power of our people rather than only seeing how it can save costs.”

One way Method1 is leveraging AI is in how it approaches creative development. Instead of asking AI to come up with campaign ideas, which currently results in generic, soulless work, Method1 uses AI as a sounding board for human creativity. In early-stage concepting, the creative team loads detailed audience personas and past brand advertising into AI and tests new campaign concepts against them to pressure-test ideas, uncover blind spots and fine-tune language or messaging.

As Flicker put it, “AI is not likely to generate the idea, but it can help make the idea better.”

Another example is how Method1 uses AI as embedded app developers to create in-house tools and generate new media capabilities. 

For example, Method1’s media team builds custom web apps using “AI on the fly.” With this approach, their media team connects disparate data sets like competitor spend data, market share data and ad attention analytics to unlock insight into what creative executions and media strategies drive the most impact. Using AI allows analysis of hundreds of thousands of data points to better deploy innovative buying for its clients.

“This is a revolutionary change to buying media, which has historically relied on antiquated and biased attribution models. Using high quality, disaggregated data increases the confidence of both Method1 and its clients that their media budgets are being put to best use,” Flicker says. 

FOUR STEPS TO USING AI AS A THOUGHT PARTNER

Here’s how to position an AI to operate as a strategic thought partner. 

1. Give it background context. Prompt the AI to find background information to better understand the problem you want it to solve.

2. Assign it a role. For example, you could ask the AI to take on the role of a marketing expert with deep expertise in creating brand personas or a consumer who is wary of buying your product.

3. Tell it how to interact with you. You can ask it to interview you, find the weaknesses in your theories, make your arguments more concise or compare your ideas to what’s already in the public sphere.

4. Direct it to use your responses in a certain way. This is where AI can step in to polish up your work, making it better rather than doing it for you. 

THE REAL AI OPPORTUNITY 

Using AI as a strategic thought partner is a much more effective—and less lazy—way to use AI to its full potential. It requires more effort from a human standpoint, but the result is greater innovation.

“For sure, AI should be used as an efficiency play, helping us automate, streamline and cut costs, but the real opportunity is far bigger,” Flicker says. “AI is the ultimate creative amplifier, giving marketers the ability to think faster, experiment more and build brands in ways we’ve never seen before.”