President Trump’s reciprocal tariffs have wreaked economic havoc—setting off banner losses on Wall Street, spurring a growing crisis in the bond market, devaluing the dollar, and disrupting private fixed investment decisions. With all of the turmoil, you’d be forgiven for missing one of the administration’s stated rationales for tariffs: a robotics-fueled “renaissance” in U.S. manufacturing.
Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick made a pitch for increased robotics repeatedly in the lead-up to “Liberation Day”—noting on CNBC that “American workers can be so much more efficient with robotics.”
Of course, there is value in boosting American manufacturing. But at the end of that goal, what’s the point? Surely, it should be to provide well-paid jobs for American working families that boost U.S. productivity and standards of living. What else could it be?
And yet, putting aside the (large) question of whether tariffs would achieve this goal, calls for a robot renaissance are deeply alarming for a U.S. economy that is already grappling with the real practice and threat of AI job replacement.
After all, AI job replacement is happening now and will only grow. Earlier this year, Workday debuted AI agents with the goal of taking over entire roles at the company. McKinsey estimates up to 800 million workers globally could see their jobs displaced in the next five years.
This scale of disruption won’t just affect workers—it also threatens to restructure entire industries, strain consumer demands, and upend economic stability. It is already being felt deeply in industries like video gaming, computer programming, and software development, and it will be felt in most workplaces.
This is not a moment when business leaders can afford to bury their heads in the sand. Smart employers can harness the power of AI while ensuring a thriving workforce—but only by prioritizing transparency, accountability, and partnership with workers. Here are three ways to do so:
1. RECOGNIZE AI’S LONG-TERM THREATS AND ACT ACCORDINGLY
There’s a misconception that AI only threatens blue-collar jobs, likely rooted in the painful history of the automation growth that impacted industrial work, coupled with the 2 million+ jobs lost in manufacturing due to trade shocks between 1999-2011. But the rise of GenAI has put a wide range of white-collar jobs, including financial and administrative roles, at greater risk of disruption than blue-collar jobs. Between 2000 and 2020, we lost over 1.6 million secretarial and administrative assistant jobs, largely due to technological advances.
Further, many workers still underestimate their own vulnerability. A 2024 FGS Global study surveyed 1,600 union and non-union workers and found that three-quarters of workers are most worried about their personal data privacy in an AI-based workplace, not job loss. Yet a third of workers believe that AI will replace many jobs across sectors—they just think their job is safer than others.
But while the threat of job displacement is real, we’ve also seen effective means of addressing it: SAG-AFTRA actors and writers secured critical protections from unauthorized replicas, and fashion industry workers in New York state successfully codified new guardrails around AI use in modeling. Workers across industries are beginning to understand how AI specifically impacts their jobs and take action, and employers must take their concerns seriously.
Business leaders must recognize these long-term threats and act accordingly by identifying at-risk roles now and developing proactive plans for upskilling and role evolution.
2. BRING WORKERS TO THE TABLE
Employers have the potential to reap huge gains from AI deployment in the workplace, but only when deployed strategically and responsibly. Right now, most aren’t doing either.
Only 4% of companies have a clear AI strategy. And many executives making AI decisions are far removed from day-to-day operations, creating a disconnect that fosters mistrust and inefficiency. Often, the primary purchaser is the CIO, rather than an executive who is considering employee skills, productivity, and trajectories more broadly.
This gap can be bridged by bringing workers into the conversation. Pennsylvania’s generative AI pilot program offers a strong example: Departments from HR to IT reported efficiency gains, with employees saving an average of 95 minutes per day on administrative tasks, alongside a clear need for human oversight. Regular worker feedback improved the rollout and outcomes, and the governor’s office has doubled down by establishing a worker board to help oversee future implementation of GenAI tools across state government.
To bring workers to the table, employers should establish feedback loops, advisory groups, or cross-functional committees that include employee input at every stage of AI adoption.
3. MODEL WHAT WORKS
Some companies are already embedding worker voices into AI governance—and it’s working.
Anthropic’s Long-Term Benefit Trust gives an independent body the power to influence board makeup. Microsoft’s partnership with AFL-CIO is educating workers and incorporating their feedback into product development. (Full disclosure: Omidyar Network is an investor in Anthropic and grant funds the AFL-CIO Tech Institute.) These are not PR plays—they’re blueprints.
Unions are also helping to shape AI policy. The Teamsters’ UPS deal curbed surveillance and automation threats. Las Vegas casino workers won severance protections for jobs displaced by AI, and the SEIU partnered with Gov. Shapiro on the Pennsylvania pilot. In each case, worker inclusion led to stronger protections and more productive outcomes.
Business leaders can model what works by piloting similar initiatives like co-creating guidelines with employees or partnering with other organizations to anticipate and address workforce concerns.
UNLOCKING AI’S POTENTIAL REQUIRES PUTTING WORKERS FIRST
Business leaders understand the potential for AI. If deployed responsibly, it can improve work conditions, boost productivity, and unlock new avenues of workforce collaboration and innovation. But these outcomes won’t happen by default. They require a worker-centered approach that prioritizes transparency, accountability, and partnership, as well as employers who see worker inclusion as a competitive advantage, not a box to check.
The future of work is being shaped now. Whether AI replaces or empowers us depends on the choices we make today.