Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Do you need a ’no’ person? Encourage your team to give honest feedback without encouraging negativity

How you react to criticism or objections tells people whether you really do welcome it. 

Do you need a “no” person? Encourage your team to give honest feedback without encouraging negativity

[Adobe Stock / fizkes]

Profile photo of Ray Titus

Chief Executive Officer · United Franchise Group

Everyone knows the danger of surrounding yourself with so-called “yes” people. They tell you what they think you want to hear, and they usually think you only want to hear how wonderful everything is. But all that praise and affirmation might not be helpful and can lead to frustrating moments. So can the person who offers nothing but objections and sees nothing but problems.  

What you need are people who are willing to voice their true thoughts, positive or negative, and give you accurate feedback that takes you in the right direction. You don’t want someone who only says “no,” but your team should feel comfortable saying it when necessary. All “yes” and all “no” can be equally damaging.  

Having the “yes” and “no” people in the right positions is critical. The devil’s advocate is valuable in the early stages of a project, when they can open people’s eyes to issues before they become problems. Don’t give them a seat at the final decision table, when last-minute objections can derail the whole thing. That’s when I expect to hear concerns from our senior leadership team, especially when finalizing significant matters like buying or selling a brand or finding employee positions. 

New team members should also be heard, but they should be encouraged to first ask questions to understand the project. Many people are afraid to ask questions for fear of looking less knowledgeable, when the opposite happens. By asking questions, they look smarter. 

HANDLING NEGATIVE FEEDBACK 

How you react to criticism or objections tells people whether you really do welcome it. 

Don’t Criticize The Objection Right Away 

Arguing makes you look defensive and suggests you’re just pretending to accept criticism. Instead, ask probing questions to help you understand their point of view. “Why do you see it that way?”

After hearing all the objections, you can still stick to your original decision, but people will feel heard and respected. 

Never Fire An Employee For A Comment  

Even if their comment is personally insulting, refrain from dismissing them or disciplining them. It immediately sends the message that people can be punished for telling you what they think. 

Praise People For Speaking Up  

Thank them for letting you know how they feel, especially if it is a sensitive topic. Tell success stories of people who spoke up to encourage them to do the same if you sense hesitation. 

Discourage Anonymous Criticism 

It’s okay for opinion surveys but not for projects that matter. Anonymity encourages pointless negativity that can even be insulting. If you create an environment that welcomes feedback of all kinds, people won’t feel they must hide. 

Don’t Take It Personally

This can be very hard. We become attached to our ideas, especially if we think they are good. But objections are rarely personal, so accept them without taking offense.  

REMEMBER: OBJECTIONS STEER THE SHIP 

It always feels good to hear good things, but no one can succeed on praise alone. Think of your team as a ship. If it’s headed for the rocks, you want someone who can alert you, so you change course and keep from running aground. 

Look for a balance between negative and positive feedback. Your team should know you’ll listen and accept objections. The culture of the business should allow everyone to voice their opinions, whether good or bad.