In the world of public relations, we used to treat bad press like a five-alarm fire—contain it, control the narrative, and repair the damage. Today, the rules are a little murkier. In the attention economy, outrage has become its own form of currency. A scandal can skyrocket brand visibility. A misstep can morph into viral engagement. Sometimes, bad press doesn’t just survive the news cycle, it thrives in it.
We’ve seen it play out again and again. A celebrity embroiled in controversy sees a spike in followers. A brand rolls out a tone-deaf campaign, only to watch sales climb. A CEO makes a divisive comment and suddenly becomes the face of a new movement. Welcome to the messy middle of modern PR, where negative attention doesn’t always hurt, and sometimes even helps.
But the operative word here is sometimes.
Let’s be clear: Riding the wave of public outrage is not a crisis communications strategy—it’s a gamble. And even when it “works,” it often carries hidden costs that surface long after the metrics stop trending.
Here’s what leaders need to understand before they mistake attention for success.
OUTRAGE DRIVES EYEBALLS, BUT NOT LOYALTY
In the short term, controversy can create what feels like momentum. Social media lights up. Website traffic spikes. The press calls. It feels like relevance. And in many ways, it is.
But attention isn’t the same as affinity. You can be known without being respected. Worse, you can be known because you’re not respected. The risk here is confusing visibility with value, thinking that more clicks mean more brand equity. They don’t. Not unless those clicks are grounded in credibility and trust.
THE METRICS THAT MATTER (AND THE ONES THAT MISLEAD)
If you’re only looking at reach and engagement, bad press can look like a win. But those metrics are surface-level only. The real impact of a reputational firestorm shows up deeper, in customer retention, employee morale, investor confidence, and long-term brand strength.
For example, a provocative campaign may drive a short-term sales bump, but if it alienates your core customer base or demoralizes your internal team, that gain becomes a loss over time. Culture and reputation are slow to build and fast to fracture.
THE MYTH OF THE “ANY PRESS IS GOOD PRESS” PLAYBOOK
Some organizations try to manufacture controversy as a tactic. They lean into outrage bait. They push boundaries not to make a point, but to provoke a reaction. And in a media environment built on speed and sensation, they often succeed, if only temporarily.
But here’s the catch: Audiences are getting smarter. They can sense when they’re being manipulated. And when the stunt becomes the story, the brand starts to look unserious or insincere. There’s a fine line between bold and reckless. Once you cross it, you lose more than goodwill. You lose credibility.
CRISIS AS AN OPPORTUNITY, IF HANDLED RIGHT
Not all bad press is engineered. Sometimes it’s earned, through missteps, mistakes, or moments that spiral. And yes, these crises can become opportunities, but only with the right response. That means accountability, transparency, and real action, not spin.
The brands and leaders who survive (and sometimes grow stronger) from a reputational crisis are the ones who meet the moment with honesty. They face the music, fix the issue, and rebuild trust, not just for the media but for their core audience.
A good example of this occurred in early 2022 when Joe Rogan faced backlash after a video montage surfaced showing him using the N-word on past episodes of The Joe Rogan Experience. The controversy gained traction when artists like India Arie publicly criticized Rogan and pulled their content from Spotify. Rogan responded with a public apology, calling his past language “shameful,” but arguing the clips were taken out of context. Spotify removed dozens of episodes and pledged $100 million toward marginalized creators, but ultimately continued supporting Rogan. Thanks to his loyal fan base and strategic handling, Rogan weathered the storm and maintained his influential platform.
THE LONG GAME
In a world where everyone’s chasing the algorithm, the real edge comes from playing the long game. That means building a reputation that can withstand scrutiny, not just generate buzz. It means knowing when to speak up and when silence says more. It means understanding that not every trend needs your take, not every criticism needs a clapback, and not every controversy is worth courting.
Communications leaders need to help their organizations think bigger than the news cycle. Because when you trade trust for traffic, you’re making a deal that rarely pays off in the long run.
Yes, bad press can create attention. Sometimes it can even drive growth. But don’t mistake the spark for the fire. True brand strength isn’t built in moments of outrage—it’s tested by them.
So, the next time a firestorm hits—or tempts—you, ask yourself: Is the white hot spotlight of attention worth the burn?