Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Eight common-sense tips (that aren’t as common as you’d think) for managing your board of directors

Whether you're a startup founder or a seasoned CEO, board leadership can make or break your company's trajectory.

Eight common-sense tips (that aren’t as common as you'd think) for managing your board of directors

[wowomnom, Ruan Jordaan/peopleimages.com / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of kmenendez

Leading a board of directors is one of the most critical yet challenging responsibilities for executives and entrepreneurs. Whether you’re a startup founder navigating your first institutional board or a seasoned CEO managing a complex structure, board leadership can make or break your company’s trajectory.

The best Chairs and CEOs understand that a well-managed board isn’t just a governance requirement, but an asset that can unlock growth and open doors to new opportunities.

As a six-time chief executive officer and having directed several boards, here are my eight tips for getting it right:

1. BE CLEAR FROM DAY ONE

Effective board leadership begins with establishing clear expectations about roles, responsibilities, and communication protocols. Many executives assume board members intuitively understand their role, leading to confusion and misaligned priorities.

Create a comprehensive board framework, outlining meeting frequency, decision-making authority, and individual director responsibilities. Be explicit about what you expect from board members beyond attending meetings. It is also important to establish protocols around confidential information and intellectual property discussions to prevent conflicts and build trust.

2. INVEST THROUGH PREPARATION

Nothing undermines board credibility faster than walking into meetings unprepared. Chairs, CEOs, and Board Members must master the art of distilling complex technical concepts into digestible formats that enable informed decision-making.

Develop a standardized board package template that includes key performance indicators, financial updates, market analysis, and strategic initiatives. Send materials at least 72 hours before meetings and strive for a full week to give directors time to review and formulate thoughtful questions.

Board members bring diverse backgrounds and may not have deep technical expertise in your specific domain. Use clear, jargon-free language and provide context for industry-specific metrics. Visual aids like charts, graphs, and product demonstrations can be particularly effective for technology companies. It seems obvious, but it’s not practiced as much as you might think.

3. BE OPEN

The most successful board leaders create environments where difficult conversations happen constructively and in the boardroom. This means sharing both wins and challenges transparently, admitting when you don’t have answers, and creating space for dissenting opinions.

Build trust by consistently delivering on commitments and providing regular updates between formal meetings. When facing significant challenges, bring these to the board early rather than waiting until problems become crises. Board members appreciate proactive leaders who seek guidance.

Encourage active participation by asking specific questions of individual directors based on their expertise. This approach makes directors feel valued while leveraging their unique perspectives.

4. LEVERAGE INDIVIDUAL DIRECTOR EXPERTISE

Every board member brings unique value beyond their investment or governance role—at least they should (but that’s another topic for another article). Board Chairs and CEOs should systematically identify and leverage these individual strengths to drive company success.

Create individual relationships with each director outside of formal board meetings. Schedule quarterly one-on-one conversations to discuss their specific areas of expertise and seek advice on relevant challenges. These relationships often prove more valuable than formal board meetings for gaining insights.

Develop a matrix mapping each director’s expertise areas—whether that’s enterprise sales, product development, or international expansion. When facing decisions, proactively reach out to relevant directors for input before board meetings.

5. FOCUS ON STRATEGY FIRST

Many executives fall into the trap of treating board meetings as detailed operational reviews rather than planning sessions. While operational metrics are important, boards add most value when focused on strategic challenges.

Structure meetings around key questions rather than departmental updates. Instead of spending time reviewing engineering velocity metrics, frame discussions around product roadmap decisions and resource allocation priorities.

Reserve meeting time for topics where board expertise can directly impact outcomes—market expansion strategies, competitive positioning, or organizational scaling challenges. Create specific asks for board members, whether that’s introductions to potential customers or guidance on complex decisions.

6. MANAGE TIME

Board members are typically successful executives with demanding schedules. Respecting their time while maximizing meeting effectiveness demonstrates leadership competence and builds long-term relationships.

Start and end meetings on time, regardless of attendance. Create detailed agendas with time allocations, and designate a timekeeper to maintain schedule adherence. When discussions run long, explicitly ask the group whether to continue or table items for follow-up.

Use executive sessions strategically—these closed-door discussions without management present can provide valuable feedback. However, don’t overuse them, as they can create unnecessary tension.

Consider implementing shorter, more frequent virtual check-ins between quarterly board meetings for time-sensitive decisions or major developments.

7. BUILD AN ‘US’ MENTALITY

Effective board leadership requires balancing collaborative decision-making with decisive leadership. Board leaders must guide discussions toward consensus while maintaining final decision-making authority on operational matters.

When facing contentious decisions, acknowledge different perspectives and work to understand underlying concerns. Sometimes disagreements stem from different assumptions rather than fundamental differences. Facilitate discussions that surface these issues and work toward resolution. And keep in mind, differing opinions are a good thing, not bad! 

However, recognize that when a consensus isn’t possible, a decision needs to be made. And remember, no decision is a decision.

8. EVOLVE YOUR BOARD

Companies face quickly changing markets and challenges. Board composition should evolve accordingly, with regular assessment of skills gaps and strategic needs.

Conduct annual board effectiveness reviews that assess both individual director contributions and overall board composition. As your company scales, different expertise becomes critical. For example, early-stage boards might prioritize product and fundraising expertise, while later-stage boards need operational scaling experience.

Don’t hesitate to refresh board composition when directors no longer align with needs. This might be one of the biggest mistakes I have seen in my career of managing boards. This process requires careful communication, but maintaining an effective board is crucial for long-term success.

Consider expanding board size strategically as you grow, bringing in independent directors with specific expertise relevant to your market expansion or product development strategies.

PARTING THOUGHT

Leading a board of directors effectively is both an art and a science, and mastering these eight principles, although simple, is quite the challenge. But the best board leaders get it done.