Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Healthcare data is being held hostage—and it’s costing millions

It's like asking the fox to audit the henhouse.

Healthcare data is being held hostage—and it’s costing millions

[Adobe Stock / Elnur]

Profile photo of Mark Newman

CEO · Nomi Health

Private health insurance spending in the U.S. is projected to exceed $1.5 trillion in 2025. That’s approximately the GDP of Australia, and the number continues to grow. But here’s the stunning part: Most can’t tell you where a single dollar goes. 

It’s not that they don’t want to know. They’re literally prevented from seeing their own data.

Imagine running a company where your second largest expense (healthcare averages $2.83 per employee per hour, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics) operates as a complete black box. You’d demand transparency, right? You’d want dashboards, analytics, and the ability to optimize spending. Yet in healthcare, we’ve accepted a system that treats employers like ATMs.

This isn’t just frustrating. It’s becoming legally dangerous. Johnson & Johnson faces a class action lawsuit claiming fiduciary breaches in managing its pharmacy benefit plan—a case that recently survived a motion to dismiss, signaling courts are taking these claims seriously. JPMorgan Chase employees filed suit alleging the bank paid inflated prices for generic drugs. Mayo Clinic and Northwestern University face similar litigation.

And while a similar lawsuit against Wells Fargo was dismissed in March, the court’s reasoning perfectly illustrates the problem: The judge found that employees’ harm was too “speculative” to prove, because the employees don’t have access to the underlying data that would show exactly how much they overpaid. It’s a Catch-22 that protects the broken system.

THE MANUFACTURED INFORMATION GAP

The healthcare industry has perfected what I call “strategic opacity.” Insurance companies, pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), and other intermediaries have built an intricate web of data silos that obscure true costs and outcomes. They create the illusion of transparency by issuing useless documents like monthly aggregate reports or utilization summaries, but never the granular data an employer would need to analyze their healthcare spending, benchmark against peers, negotiate better rates, or identify waste. Instead, they’re forced to rely on the very intermediaries who profit from the current system to tell them if they’re getting a good deal. It’s like asking the fox to audit the henhouse.

The Johnson & Johnson lawsuit perfectly illustrates this problem. Employees allege the company’s prescription plan paid $10,239 for a generic cancer drug that costs $28 at the Mark Cuban Cost Plus Drug Company. That’s a staggering 36,000% markup. But how could Johnson & Johnson’s benefits team know they were overpaying by this astronomical amount if they couldn’t see the data?

DATA ACCESS ISN’T DATA OWNERSHIP

Here’s where it gets even more Kafkaesque. Even when employers fight for and occasionally win “access” to their data, they often discover they don’t actually own it. They can look, but they can’t touch. They can view reports, but they can’t export raw data for independent analysis. They can see aggregate trends, but they can’t drill down to understand what’s driving costs.

This view-only relationship with your own healthcare data would be laughable if it weren’t so expensive. Companies routinely make multi-million-dollar benefits decisions based on PowerPoint presentations from vendors rather than hard data analysis. In any other business function, this would be considered gross negligence.

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) requires employers to act as prudent fiduciaries when managing employee benefit plans, explicitly tasking them with a “continuing duty to monitor” their healthcare plans, extending well beyond the initial selection of service providers. But how can you be prudent when you’re blindfolded? Courts are increasingly recognizing this tension, though, as the Wells Fargo dismissal shows, the lack of data transparency can paradoxically shield the very system that creates the problem. For now.

Fortunately, we’re seeing the emergence of coalitions and companies that refuse to accept the status quo. At companies like mine, we’ve built our entire model around radical transparency and direct data ownership. This isn’t just about technology. It’s about power.

YOUR DATA RIGHTS CHECKLIST

If you’re an employer, here’s what you should demand from any healthcare partner:

1. Full Data Ownership: Not just access but the legal right to your data

2. Raw Data Exports: The ability to download and analyze data independently

3. Real-Time Access: Not quarterly reports but live dashboards

4. Granular Detail: Claims-level data, not just aggregated summaries

5. Interoperability: Data that works with standard analytics tools

The healthcare establishment won’t give up its information monopoly without a fight. But the combination of legal pressure, employer coalitions, and innovative companies is creating unstoppable momentum. Employers can help by demanding full data ownership and transparency from all healthcare vendors, documenting all efforts to obtain data and monitor plans, considering alternative models that provide direct access to claims data, and joining employer coalitions pushing for systemic change. 

This movement isn’t just about avoiding lawsuits—it’s about recognizing that the current system is fundamentally broken. When a system actively prevents employers from being good stewards of employees’ healthcare dollars, fighting for transparency becomes more than a business decision. It becomes a moral imperative.

In my experience, healthcare is already the second or third largest line item in most corporate budgets. It’s time we managed it with the same rigor we apply to every other major expense. And that starts with a simple but revolutionary act: demanding ownership of your own data.

Because in healthcare, as in every other aspect of business, you can’t manage what you can’t measure. And you can’t measure what you can’t see.