Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

4 lessons my trucking customers taught me about high-pressure decision making

As a tech leader working closely with frontline problem-solvers, I’ve learned a great deal about making smart, fast decisions when the margin for error is razor-thin.

4 lessons my trucking customers taught me about high-pressure decision making

[Michael, kiimoshi/ Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Toni Ann Careccio

Chief Customer Officer and Board Member · PortPro Technologies, Inc.

We’ve all faced that moment—a dozen eyes fixed on us, waiting for direction. The pressure builds, time ticks, and yet … we freeze. The weight of making the right decision in that instant feels crushing.

For many of us, decision fatigue creeps in quietly through the chaos of everyday life—work, family, a hundred micro-choices a day. What’s for dinner? Which summer camp? It’s why Steve Jobs wore the same outfit daily: to preserve mental energy for decisions that really mattered.

But for my customers, drayage trucking companies, decision fatigue isn’t just an occasional burden—it’s the job. They operate in one of the most intense, unpredictable, high-stakes environments in logistics.

Hauling containers in and out of ports isn’t a straightforward task. It’s a battle against the clock, the port schedule, traffic snarls, broken chassis, gate delays, and surprise cancellations. And when things go sideways—which they often do—dispatchers and drivers don’t have the luxury to freeze. They make calls in real time, under pressure, with limited information, and move on.

As a tech leader working closely with these frontline problem-solvers, I’ve learned a great deal about making smart, fast decisions when the margin for error is razor-thin.

Here are four lessons I’ve picked up from drayage pros about decision-making in high-pressure environments and how you can apply them when the heat is on.

1. GOOD DECISION-MAKING STARTS WITH VISIBILITY

Visibility and real-time data have been big topics in the supply chain world. We have more information at our fingertips today than we’ve ever had before, thanks to technology, GPS, transportation management systems, and so much more. Drayage trucking companies that have implemented modern technology can have full visibility into where their trucks are, when containers are arriving, and how long the line is at the port. 

With abundant and visible data, the key is to interpret that data correctly and make decisions based on the information at hand. 

My advice: Gather as much relevant information as you can to make smart decisions. Even better if you can use AI to make recommendations based on that data. 

2. EVERY DECISION HAS TRADEOFFS

One key thing I’ve learned from my customers is that there’s no perfect decision, and no matter what you decide, there may be tradeoffs. 

Let’s say a road is closed on the way from the port to the retailer’s warehouse. A drayage leader may decide to route the truck around the long way. The upside of that decision: The freight still gets to the warehouse the same day, and the customer is probably happy. The downside: more miles and more time for the truck driver. In the end, drayage firms don’t have the luxury to endlessly deliberate and wait for new information. They have to make a call in real time. 

In the tech world, a decision to scale with AI might increase productivity. But does it impact employee engagement and the authenticity employees have with customers? These are the kinds of decisions we grapple with as executives. Not everyone will love your decision, and that’s the reality of leadership. 

3. TAP INTO THE VALUE OF SCENARIO PLANNING

There’s never a dull day in logistics. Something could break down or be delayed at any link in the supply chain. By having back-up plans or buffers, my drayage customers are able to respond quickly and pivot when things go wrong.

In the supply chain, this is often called scenario planning. What could happen, and what’s the likelihood? Are we prepared if plan B, C, or D occurs? 

Answering those questions proactively can help us all make decisions and adjustments when the time comes, because we’ll have the resources and contingencies in place. 

4. STICK TO YOUR GOALS, EVEN AMID THE CHAOS

Drayage companies are some of the most mission-focused businesses I’ve encountered. They have a clear imperative: Deliver goods safely, accurately, and on time, and, above all, make their customers happy. Through all the volatility of the supply chain, they remain laser-focused on their goals, and that helps form the foundation of their decisions. 

I’ve begun to do the same in my own decision-making. One of PortPro’s big goals is to help our customers deliver exceptional service to their customers through tech tools that offer transparency and efficiency. Every time I feel overwhelmed by a decision, I think about this mission and make a decision based on what best serves our company’s purpose—what helps our customers, and what, in turn, helps their customers.

Through the years, in my own experience and from my customers, I’ve learned that the worst decision is to not to make one. I’m a big believer in making decisions fast, but with the right data points. After you make a decision, follow through, see what’s working and what’s not, and respond even faster. 

TRUST YOUR INSTINCTS

By recognizing information shortfalls, anticipating potential roadblocks, having backup plans ready to go, and always keeping your company’s mission in mind, you can quickly and confidently make decisions even in high-pressure situations. Trust your instincts, and don’t be afraid to make a call.