Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Digital identity in the age of agentic AI: Who’s in control?

What happens to identity and trust when our digital presence is determined by machines? 

Digital identity in the age of agentic AI: Who’s in control?

[Shalf Design / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Andre Durand

CEO · Ping Identity

C-suite leaders need to sit with this uncomfortable reality: Today’s brands will be reduced to ChatGPT prompts. This isn’t a provocation, but a strategic reality check based on the current, rising state of agentic AI. 

In fact, Capgemini recently reported that 50% of business executives have plans to implement AI agents this year. Within three years, this number is expected to rise to 82%. We’re rapidly hurtling into a world where AI agents make decisions on our behalf, such as recommending what we buy, authorizing transactions, and even determining which companies get seen—all without brand input or visibility. These agents don’t care about traditional marketing muscle, loyalty campaigns, or promotional deals. They care about structured data and signal-to-noise ratios.

Which leads to the deeper question: What happens to identity and trust when our digital presence is determined by machines? 

FROM HUMAN IDENTITY TO AI-DETERMINED PROBABILITY

Historically, identity has always had an interface, whether that’s in the form of a login page, a driver’s license, or even an in-person handshake. This human-led identity interface is often the start of customer interactions and longer-term loyalty.

But with the rise of agentic AI, this identity interface disappears. Today, identity is no longer human-facing, as brands shift from speaking to an individual to interacting with a machine. 

Consider this scenario: A CFO asks its AI assistant which accounting software the company should use. Instead of researching a dozen websites, the AI agent scans structured reviews, ingests language patterns, checks for trusted metadata, and makes a near-instant selection. During a time when C-suite leaders are forced to do more with less—and every minute can equate to ROI savings—it’s understandable why the CFO would trust this recommendation. But here’s the catch: the software company’s brand just became a weighted probability.

If companies fail to structure and assert their identity in AI-native environments, they will be misrepresented, hallucinated, or ignored. As agentic AI begins to reshape every business decision and customer interaction, we need to prepare ourselves by asking:

  • What happens when AI bots get gamed?
  • Who’s liable when an AI agent chooses a vendor based on false data?
  • What are the ethics when the assistant’s only loyalty is to efficiency?

These questions are uncomfortable—but they’re already on the table. The time is now to adequately understand and prepare for this next chapter of agentic AI.

THE NEW AI ATTACK SURFACE? BRAND IDENTITY 

Tucked beneath these questions is a broader topic of identity. Identity is no longer what you say it is, but rather what the machines interpret it to be. Adding to the complexity, machines are notoriously agnostic to intent, meaning they don’t care if you meant to update documentation and they certainly don’t give you the benefit of the doubt. Worse, these AI machines can be manipulated by adversarial data, prompted with biased intent and spoofed with lookalike sources, making hallucinations and errors far too likely.

In this new AI-fueled attack surface against brand identity, the winners won’t shout louder; they’ll be machine-readable, structured, and verifiable. The representation of truth, authority, and permission between autonomous agents will be more critical than ever before, not just for customers and brands, but for society at large.

IDENTITY AS THE NEW MORAL INFRASTRUCTURE 

Identity has always been rooted in trust and ethics. Historically, at the human identity layer, we’re inclined to trust what we hear, see, and read. But now, AI has completely changed trust, and as a result, ethics is also now being questioned. If an AI agent makes a decision that causes harm, who’s to blame? The prompt? The model? The human behind it? The data it ingested?

We’re entering an era where intent is synthetic, action is automated, and consequence is unclear. Our human-led approaches and legacy systems aren’t designed for this. We need a new layer of ethical mediation that lives inside digital identity.

WHAT CAN BE DONE—RIGHT NOW

The first step to seizing the agentic AI shift is education and awareness. It’s important to understand how consumers are making decisions, and how a brand is coming up—or not—in LLM search.

Once general awareness is established, there are a few immediate steps leaders can take to be prepared for what’s next. Here’s what I recommend: 

  • Provision AI Agents Like Users: Even these machines need identities, credentials, and policies. This treatment will also help when establishing ethical mediation.
  • Monitor Behavior Continuously: Risk isn’t static, but neither is trust. Constantly monitor behavior—whether from human users or machines—to identify any unusual patterns.
  • Build Revocation Into The Stack: When an AI agent goes rogue, pull the plug. Stop it before it’s too late.
  • Structure Identity For Machines: Human-readability isn’t enough. Your brand needs a metadata layer.
  • Audit Every Decision: If an agent acts, the trail should be visible, explainable, and reversible. Treat agent decisions like you would human-led actions.

Identity is no longer just about who logs in. It’s now about who acts, on whose behalf, and with what authority. We are in the next great transformation of digital identity, but the power remains in the hands of the people if the proper precautions are taken.

Action must be taken now to preserve trust. And that trust? It’ll be the most valuable currency in the AI age.