Imagine for a moment that you’re a business owner looking to purchase project management software.
You find a company that has an enticing product, and you meet with a salesperson to learn more. The salesperson explains that there’s a “basic” and a “pro” plan. The basic plan allows you to add up to 20 users and includes five features. The “pro” plan enables you to add up to 100 users and includes 10 features. You want to add up to 100 users, but don’t need those 10 features—five will do. You let the salesperson know, and they offer you a discount because you don’t want the extra features, just additional units. This boils down to an expansion sale; you want to expand the number of seats but don’t want the upgraded features.
On the flip side, say you want the additional features, but not the additional seats. You don’t want to pay for dozens of extra user licenses you won’t use. The salesperson is in a tough spot. You’re asking for an upsell on the features without an expansion of the seats. Here, too, the salesperson offers you a discount to make the deal work, so you’re not stuck paying for dozens of unused user licenses.
There’s a catch, however. If you’re in the uncomfortable middle—you need, say, 50 or 60 user licenses—you’ll probably end up paying the full price of the 100 seats, or close to it.
These three dilemmas are, unfortunately, common for software buyers, stemming from many software companies failing to get the trifecta of licensing, packaging, and pricing right.
THE LICENSING, PACKAGING, AND PRICING TRIFECTA EXPLAINED
In the software world, there can be some conflating of the concepts of licensing, packaging, and pricing. But these are three separate elements that software company leaders must tackle in the correct order.
Each element—licensing, packaging, and pricing—is connected to a different revenue growth mechanism. A strong licensing structure enables expansion sales. Put licensing and packaging together with the right pricing, and not only do you enable expansion and upsells, but you enable cross-selling, encouraging customers to invest in the broader portfolio of products and services you offer.
Returning to the hypothetical examples above, if the project management company charged $25 per month per user instead of bundling the number of seats with additional features, you could easily purchase more seats without worrying about incurring extra costs for unneeded features. If the features were separated from user limits, you could get additional features without having to pay for more user seats. As for the uncomfortable middle, well, there wouldn’t be one. You could obtain the number of user seats and the feature options you want without having to go back and forth with the salesperson.
WHY SOFTWARE COMPANY LEADERS SOMETIMES CONFLATE THE THREE ELEMENTS
There are typically two main reasons why some software company leaders conflate these three elements.
First, they’re thinking in terms of pricing in the B2C world, rather than the B2B one. The two are different oceans of complexity. Take a box of cereal—there are only so many attributes you can attach to it, such as ounces, volume, flavor, etc. The manufacturer would take these attributes into account and assign a price to the product. But a software solution can have hundreds of features. The pricing isn’t clear-cut. It’s an amalgamation of a collection of differently valued capabilities. Those capabilities give buyers benefits, such as insights into their business metrics, that many consumer products don’t produce.
Second, they’ve become too focused on segmentation. Segmentation is about differentiation, which is helpful, but only to an extent when it comes to software. When software company leaders look for more differences in buyers than commonalities, it breeds increasingly more complexity in the offerings, especially as a product evolves. Segmentation gone overboard is how a software company can end up basing its pricing on dozens of minute variables, resulting in a hodgepodge of confusing options.
HOW SOFTWARE COMPANY LEADERS MISS OUT BY CONFLATING THE THREE ELEMENTS
At software companies where leaders have conflated the trifecta of licensing, packaging, and pricing, there are usually cascading consequences.
One significant one is friction-filled sales processes. Buyers, in an understandable effort not to pay for more than what they need, enter drawn-out negotiations with salespeople, who are doing their best to hit their KPIs and survive in a chaotic environment. Salespeople often offer discounts to persuade buyers to sign the dotted line. However, news of these discounts often spreads among the prospective customer base, prompting other buyers to request similar treatment, which puts the sales team in a tough spot and jeopardizes the company’s reputation. It also destroys the sales team’s ability to defend its pricing, eroding the software company’s pricing power over time.
Another consequence is limited growth potential. When customers are faced with counterproductive packaging, licensing, and pricing that make it challenging for them to meet their goals, they’re likely to seek alternatives. Consider, for instance, that your company is subscribed to the “basic” plan of accounting software solution. As part of that plan, you get 15 user seats, 10 monthly analytics reports, the ability to add 50 customers to the system, and 50 GB of storage. Your company grows and reaches the point where it needs 20 monthly analytics reports instead of 10. However, the next tier offered includes 75 analytics reports, which you don’t need. The software company’s salespeople offer a slight discount, but it’s still too high a price. So, you start looking for alternative solutions that can cover those 10 additional reports, including competitors and do-it-yourself approaches. In essence, the software company has pushed you toward its competitors or toward taking matters into your own hands with DIY approaches. The result? The software company’s solution is less sticky—it’s not as entangled in your workflow.
THE KEYS TO GETTING ON THE RIGHT TRACK
Getting the trifecta of packaging, licensing, and pricing right is not a one-size-fits-all process, as every software company’s situation is unique.
However, as a starting point, software company leaders should tackle the trifecta in the correct sequence:
• Licensing needs to come first; they must decide what variable should be in the quantity field.
• Packaging should follow, with software company leaders pinpointing the boundaries that define their packages.
• Once they anchor those two elements, they can then attach price points.
Additionally, software company leaders should keep licensing and packaging separate. They shouldn’t try to limit usage across too many features. They should also take an approach that allows for accelerated deal velocity—salespeople and customers should easily and quickly be able to navigate expansion sales, upsells, and cross-sells.
Finally, software company leaders should drive simplicity through licensing, packaging, and pricing in stages, and carefully. Segmentation needs to be balanced with simplicity. That way, in the time their competition takes haggling with buyers over the nuances of over-complicated pricing and packaging on just one deal, sales teams can close multiple. When simplicity is coupled with a continuous monetization approach, it maximizes the chances that software companies’ packaging and pricing will resonate highly with customers in the long term.