Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The 4 rituals for great decision making in the AI age

Rituals create the scaffolding that turns culture into momentum.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Shishir Mehrotra

CEO · Superhuman

Running a company doesn’t leave much room for hobbies. But if you know me, you know I make time for one obsession: rituals.

My fascination with rituals started from a conversation with my friend Bing Gordon, former chief creative officer at Electronic Arts and an early investor in Amazon and Zynga. Bing told me the most effective companies have golden rituals—practices that are named, templated, and known by every employee by their first Friday.

Over the past few years, my curiosity turned into a side project. I’ve interviewed over 1,000 founders and leaders, cataloging their habits into repeatable blueprints. One of my favorite conversations was with Dharmesh Shah, founder and CTO of HubSpot. He reminded me that every company produces two products: one for customers, and one for employees. The latter is called culture, and rituals bring culture to life.

When I spoke at Lenny’s Summit last year, I shared four rituals for better decision making. This article adds a new layer to that talk: how AI reshapes the choices we face and the rituals we rely on to make them. I’ll explore more rituals in the future, but today we’re focusing on these four decision rituals because, in the age of AI, the best leaders won’t just make better decisions, they’ll build better ways of deciding.

1. Ask the right questions

Every decision starts with a question, not an answer. I call these eigenquestions, a term borrowed from linear algebra. Just as an eigenvector represents the most defining direction in a multi-dimensional space, eigenquestions are those that, once answered, resolve many others.

At YouTube, we once struggled with what I called the “Modern Family question.” The show was one of our top searches, but the content wasn’t on YouTube. Should we link out to ABC.com? We debated endlessly until we reframed the issue: “In 5–10 years, will the online video market value consistency or comprehensiveness?” Once we clarified that eigenquestion, the rest fell into place.

2. Build a better decision process

When making decisions, most companies still rely on one-way feedback—comments on documents that are read inconsistently, weighted unevenly, and buried in threads.

A better approach is the two-way write-up. At Coda and now at Grammarly, we’ve built rituals around this idea through tools we call Dory and Pulse.

  • Dory (named after the fish who asks all the questions) lets team members submit and upvote questions after reading a write-up.
  • Pulse gathers anonymous sentiment, allowing each person to express their position on the decision without being influenced by groupthink.

The result: a structured conversation where the right questions and the real perspectives rise above the noise.

3. Create the right forums

Even with better inputs, many decisions get bogged down in recurring, one-size-fits-all meetings. The better question is: Does this forum accelerate or slow down decisions?

At Grammarly, we reserve a daily hour called Catalyst. It’s a flexible forum where project leads submit topics in advance, each with prework, approvers, and stakeholders. Half the time, completing the prework reveals the decision, making the meeting unnecessary.

4. Involve the right stakeholders

The best rituals for decision making don’t just capture feedback; they ensure the right people are involved at the right time, with clarity on how much their input matters.

Dharmesh of HubSpot faced a dilemma familiar to every leader. His feedback was necessary but often misread. Was he riffing, or issuing a directive? His solution was flashtags, a system for tagging his comments by intensity, e.g. if it was a hill he would die on:

  1. #fyi: No hill in sight.
  2. #suggestion: Saw the hill, not worth climbing.
  3. #recommendation: Climbed the hill, thought about it, walked back down.
  4. #plea: If I were going to die on a hill, this would be it.

At Grammarly, we extended flashtags with a timing dimension: proactive versus reactive. Some stakeholders want to shape direction early; others prefer to respond once something tangible exists. Both modes are valuable if you’re clear which one you’re using.

By combining intensity and timing, feedback becomes legible. Teams avoid wasted effort, leaders avoid being misinterpreted, and decisions accelerate with fewer surprises.

HOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY WE DECIDE

Even with strong decision-making rituals in place, today, we must also consider AI. It’s reshaping the decisions we face and how we make them by speeding up the process, making options feel more tangible, and raising new challenges for leaders.

AI can spin up scenarios, strategies, or prototypes in seconds. That speed helps teams move past abstract debates and react to something concrete, but it also makes it easy to get distracted. Leaders have to be vigilant about steering toward what really matters, not just what’s immediately in front of them.

AI can also synthesize feedback and highlight trade-offs, giving leaders clearer inputs without replacing their judgment. The effect is that hotly debated decisions can now be closed with more speed and confidence. But AI doesn’t replace decision rituals. It makes them more essential. While technology can accelerate decisions, rituals are what ensure that acceleration moves in the right direction.

WHAT LEADERS CAN DO NOW

Rituals aren’t about adding process for process’s sake. They’re about designing habits that make decision making faster, fairer, and more consistent. In the age of AI, they’re also guardrails that keep technology serving culture, not the other way around.

If you’re a leader looking to strengthen your decision making, here are four takeaways you can put to work immediately:

  • Name and templatize your rituals. If a practice matters, formalize it. Give it a name people remember.
  • Prioritize questions before answers. Identify the eigenquestion in every major decision and resist the temptation to chase flashy but irrelevant options.
  • Redesign feedback loops. Move from one-way comment threads to structured, two-way interactions where AI artifacts help accelerate clarity.
  • Signal strength of opinion. Use frameworks like flashtags so stakeholders can clarify the weight their input should carry and when they should weigh in.

Rituals are creating the scaffolding that turns culture into momentum. In the age of AI, the best leaders won’t just make faster choices; they’ll build the rituals that make those choices count.

Shishir Mehrotra is CEO of Grammarly.