Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Yes, you can be sued for a cyberbreach

How one company was saved by “reasonable security.”

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Stan Stahl

Founder / President · SecureTheVillage

The people and company in this story are fictitious, but the scenario is not.

Evan felt the courtroom’s chill, but his nerves were ablaze. Seated under oath, he squared his shoulders as the plaintiff’s attorney pressed forward.

“Evan,” the lawyer intoned, “did your company—or did it not—expose tens of thousands of customers’ credit card numbers?”

Evan held his gaze. “We experienced a breach,” he admitted. “But not because we ignored the risk.”

THE BREACH

Evan is the founder and CEO of a direct‑to‑consumer brand celebrated for its sleek, artisanal kitchenware.

Six months ago, a third‑party plugin used for checkout was hit with a zero-day attack. Before the vendor even knew there was a vulnerability, cybercriminals had attacked it, gaining access to the company’s customer database. Within days, more than 20,000 customers’ contact details and credit card numbers were stolen. A lawsuit resulted.

From the company’s early days, Evan and his team took cybersecurity every bit as seriously as they took operations and finance.

They knew what sensitive information they had.

They knew it was stored securely, and they controlled access to it.

They kept their IT infrastructure locked down.

And they had plans for what to do when the inevitable ransomware attack happened.

THE RULING

Months later, the judge’s decision came down to a single point: Had the company met the legal standard of “reasonable security?”

The court’s ruling was explicit:

“The company maintained an active, ongoing cybersecurity program aligned with recognized industry standards for its size and sector—namely the NIST Cybersecurity Framework and CIS Controls. The evidence shows they acted with diligence and consistency prior to—and during—the incident. The court finds this meets the threshold of reasonable security.”

Case dismissed.

Reasonable security stopped the breach from becoming an extinction event.

That legal victory didn’t erase the costs, though. The company spent hundreds of thousands on response, remediation, and customer support. Legal fees cost them even more. Sales dipped as customers lost trust. But they avoided what could have been far worse—millions in damages, years of litigation, and a potentially fatal blow to the business’s reputation.

In today’s connected commerce, breaches are not a matter of if but when. But with a documented, framework-based cybersecurity program—based on NIST or CIS—you don’t just act with care, you build a legal shield around your business.

Too often, small and mid-sized companies see cybersecurity as a technology problem—or worse, a nice-to-have. In reality, it’s a leadership discipline, every bit as necessary as financial controls or workplace safety.

Evan’s success took advantage of cybersecurity laws being enacted in several states. Having a documented cybersecurity program based on frameworks like NIST or CIS can offer a legal safe harbor—a kind of “get‑of‑jail‑free” card in breach litigation.

  • Ohio: The Ohio Data Protection Act allows businesses that implement and maintain a written cybersecurity program aligned with NIST, CIS, ISO 27000, and others to assert an affirmative defense in tort‑based lawsuits after a breach.
  • Utah: The state adopted a similar safe‑harbor statute in 2021. Entities with cybersecurity programs that reasonably conform to NIST, CIS, ISO 27000, FedRAMP, or HIPAA can use that compliance as an affirmative defense to breach claims under Utah law.
  • Connecticut: Public Act 21-119 passed in 2021 offers businesses a safe harbor against punitive damages brought under CT law for businesses aligning to recognized frameworks like NIST or CIS.
  • Iowa: Passed in mid‑2023, House File 553 provides a safe harbor for businesses that implement cybersecurity programs, including NIST or CIS controls, with additional scope tied to probable loss.
  • Oklahoma (hospitals only): Its Hospital Cybersecurity Protection Act (2023) offers safe harbor for hospitals with security programs aligning with NIST or similar frameworks.
  • Texas: Starting September 1, 2025, SB 2610 offers businesses with fewer than 250 employees a safe harbor against exemplary (punitive) damages provided they implement security programs aligned with NIST or similar frameworks.

This means businesses like Evan’s, operating in these states, gain a tangible legal shield—if they prepared properly beforehand.

BOTTOM LINE

In the world of connected commerce, the question isn’t if a breach will happen—it’s when. The real test is whether you’ll be able to show you were ready. For the example company here, that readiness meant the difference between a bad quarter and the end of the company.

Stan Stahl is founder and president of SecureTheVillage.