Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Clicks don’t equal instant credibility

What generational habits reveal about the future of trust in marketing.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Stephanie Harris

Founder & CEO · PartnerCentric

Clicks don’t equal trust.

Marketers have long measured campaign success in impressions, clicks, and conversions. But our latest research reveals something deeper: While every generation spends time on social platforms, their relationship with advertising and influence looks fundamentally different.

This matters because digital ad spend is forecast to reach $965.6 billion by 2028, according to Statista, even as audiences increasingly tune out. Without validation, brands also risk exposure to fraudulent clicks and impressions. These metrics appear strong on paper, but they don’t accurately reflect the true return on marketing investments.

The generational divide in trust

Every generation is online, but they don’t engage with advertising (or assign trust) the same way. “Spray and pray” advertising is inefficient and can lead to a credibility crisis.

Gen Z has a finely tuned radar for authenticity, gravitating to peer voices and creators whose content feels unfiltered. A polished TikTok campaign won’t win them over, but a micro-influencer showing real use might. Increasingly, these micro-influencers participate in commission-based programs, signaling their confidence in performance-based partnerships when the collaboration feels genuine.

Nearly 79% of Gen Z spend close to three hours a day on TikTok, according to recent U.S. data. eMarketer’s Global Creator Shopping Survey adds that 27% of Americans need to see a creator promote a product three to four times before actually purchasing. It’s a reminder that credibility is earned through consistent, authentic exposure—not a single flashy ad.

Millennials are validators. They’ll engage with brand content, but rarely buy without first checking other sources, such as affiliate blogs, price comparisons, or trusted reviews. This is where affiliates play a critical role by providing credibility and bridging the trust gap. 

On average, millennials spend almost two hours a day on Instagram. But what ultimately drives their buying decisions is third-party credibility. Most consumers want to cross-reference creator recommendations by checking brand websites or product reviews before clicking “buy.”

Boomers lean into familiarity and community. Research shows 87% of boomers are still on Facebook, averaging 90 minutes daily. They may spend less time scrolling than younger cohorts, but they are highly active in trusted online spaces, such as Facebook groups. Overt advertising rarely lands, but a consistent presence in those communities does.

A skincare brand might pour millions into Facebook ads targeted at older audiences, only to find that boomers are ignoring them. A direct-to-consumer retailer may push Instagram Stories, hoping to win Gen Z, without realizing that the audience is still waiting on validation from micro-influencers.

People of every generation spend time on social media, but how they assign trust within those platforms is what marketers must adapt to. Data gives us proof points, but the strategic takeaway is clear. Brands can’t rely on a single creative approach or channel mix and expect credibility across audiences.

Earn credibility

If trust is the real currency, then the game is shifting from pushing ads to earning attention. That means brands must:

  • Invest in trusted voices: For Gen Z, that’s micro- and nano-influencers who deliver authenticity over gloss.
  • Double down on validation: For millennials, the affiliates, review partners, and credible third-party content hold the keys.
  • Meet communities where they live: For boomers, that means showing up in groups, forums, publisher partnerships, and content ecosystems that feel relational rather than transactional.
  • Rethink measurement: Clicks, impressions, and conversions are only half the story. The real question is whether the touchpoint increases incrementality, validation, and long-term trust.
  • Transparency: Recent eMarketer research found that transparency around sponsorships doesn’t reduce trust; many consumers even view mixed or negative reviews as a sign of honesty, which can increase credibility.

And let’s not forget the timing. According to eMarketer’s recent survey, many creator-driven purchases don’t happen instantly. For most consumers, social media inspiration leads to a transaction later, whether that’s on a brand’s site, a marketplace, or even at a physical store during a promotion.

The real job for marketers is to ensure that the initial spark of discovery translates into credibility across every touchpoint, and then the appropriate parties are compensated.

Close the trust gap

There’s a temptation to chase what looks immediate, including new ad formats, shiny placements, and bigger budgets. Closing the trust gap requires patience and precision. It’s not about spending more but better allocation.

That could mean shifting dollars from broad campaigns into affiliate partnerships that deliver credible validation, reallocating budget into creator collaborations that feel authentic, or reducing frequency on certain platforms to consistently appear in trusted review channels.

Marketers who embrace this mindset can future-proof their credibility in a world where trust is harder to earn and easier to lose.

A call to action

The trust economy looks different across generations. If we continue to treat clicks as a measure of trust, we’ll misread the signals, misplace our spend, and miss the opportunity to build lasting relationships.

However, if we acknowledge the generational nuances of trust and design strategies that respect them, we’ll earn something far more valuable—belief. And belief is what turns attention into action.

Stephanie Harris is the CEO and founder of PartnerCentric.