Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The human side of records retrieval

Creativity and empathy can improve response speed for records retrievals.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Jens Erik Gould

Founder & CEO · Amalga Group

In legal services, records retrieval is often treated like a simple administrative function—a box to check, a form to submit, a phone call to make. But anyone who’s led or built a serious records retrieval and legal services operation knows the truth: Records retrieval is a relationship business.

As CEO of Amalga Group, serving legal service providers and law firms across the country, I’ve seen time and again that what separates average records retrieval (RR) teams from high-performing ones comes down to two qualities: creativity and empathy. These insights aren’t only applicable to the legal industry. As a business process outsourcing company, we work in a variety of sectors—from financial services to healthcare to technology—and we see the same truth repeat itself.

So, whether you’re retrieving records, processing claims, or supporting customers, service-driven work always comes down to people. The more you engage on a human level with the person on the other end of the line, the better the collaboration, the faster the response, and the stronger the results.

WHY CUSTODIANS DELAY DELIVERING RECORDS

It’s easy to assume that once a subpoena is sent or a medical authorization is provided, the custodians will process the request and deliver the records. Anyone who has spent time on the phone with a busy records department knows it rarely works that way.

The reality is: Many custodians have little incentive to complete records requests quickly—or at all. There’s often no legal consequence for delays or inaction. Their departments are overworked, backlogged, or understaffed. Records retrieval becomes one more thing on an endless to-do list.

This is where creativity matters.

“WE’RE WORKING ON IT” IS NOT AN ANSWER

When a records retrieval specialist dials into a custodian’s office and hears, “We’re working on it” or gets sent to voicemail for the third time, the easy path is to log the call and move on. But that doesn’t close orders.

The best RR specialists don’t stop at the first—or fifth—hurdle. They get creative:

  • They find alternative contacts inside the organization.
  • They adjust call times based on the custodian’s work patterns.
  • They politely escalate when appropriate.
  • They send well-timed, tactful emails to keep the request on the custodian’s radar.
  • They track down supervisors when roadblocks arise.

The difference between a file delivered in 10 days versus 60 days often comes down to whether the specialist treated the request as static or dynamic. Creative problem-solving moves orders forward.

THE SOFT SKILL THAT OPENS DOORS

But creativity alone isn’t enough. Empathy is what builds real momentum.

Records retrieval specialists must remember that behind every request is a person juggling multiple demands. Coaching teams to adopt this mindset transforms routine interactions into relationship-building opportunities. Training RR specialists to ask questions, listen actively, and remember key personal details humanize the process and build rapport, which creates momentum.

Some of the best RR team members build true rapport with custodians. They remember which days the custodian must leave early for a child’s soccer game. They acknowledge workload challenges. They know when to follow up gently and when to give breathing room—while moving the order forward.

Over time, custodians recognize those voices on the phone. They feel appreciated and often prioritize those requests because of the professional relationship that’s been built.

FINAL THOUGHTS

The legal services industry is fast-moving, and client expectations are, understandably, high. Delays in records retrieval can slow down litigation, insurance claims, and case preparation. High order completion rates aren’t achieved by simply having a dialer and a script—they’re achieved by having specialists who combine persistence, creative problem-solving, and emotional intelligence on every call.

For legal operations leaders, building a team with both tenacity and emotional intelligence can directly impact turnaround times and client satisfaction. When specialists approach custodians with empathy and persistence, completion rates improve measurably.

If you’re an operations leader managing RR teams, remember that it’s the human side that starts and keeps turnaround times moving.

Jens Erik Gould is the founder and CEO of Amalga.