Spend a minute in a corporate setting and you’ll see that AI is everywhere. It’s helpful in lots of ways, but it fails in one crucial way: Large Language Models think they know everything. And if you’re not careful, they’ll make you think you do, too.
There’s a reason for AI’s false bravado. According to a major report recently released by OpenAI, language models hallucinate because they “reward guessing over acknowledging uncertainty.” In other words, this is a feature, not a bug.
Avoiding uncertainty is human nature
This same dynamic often plays out in human behavior. Uncertainty can feel like weakness, especially early in our careers. When you first start getting invited “into the room” where decisions are made, it’s easy to think you need to understand everything immediately—even if that means trying to bluster your way through a smart-sounding response when you’re called on.
The problem is that your boss wasn’t born yesterday. Your boss might not call you out in front of your colleagues, but he sure won’t forget the time you tried to bluff your way through an answer. And if that happens, you’ve just missed your chance to impress your boss and colleagues. You broke their trust before you could even really build it.
Try this instead
So, let’s rewind. You’re in the conference room. Your boss asks you and your coworker a question neither of you know the answer to. Your colleague, in an effort to appear smart, stumbles through a half-baked reply that at best is a guess and at worst is a lie.
You take a different approach. You share what you do know, admit what you don’t, and commit to closing that gap. Why? Because the appearance of intelligence isn’t the most important thing early in your career; it’s understanding the stakes involved in your assignment and pledging to get it right.
It may seem counterintuitive, but if you’re the one who’s willing to admit what you don’t know, you’ll come across as confident and competent. Your blustery colleague will lose trust.
Don’t pretend to know it all
Not to burst your bubble, but you weren’t hired because your bosses thought you were all-knowing. No one is. Odds are, you were hired because of your creativity, or your critical thinking skills, or your drive to succeed. Now your focus should be on adding maturity and good judgement to that list of skills.
Early on in my career, I worked under some pretty tough, high-performing CEOs. As a young speechwriter, I sat in on meeting after meeting with high-performing CEOs. I saw plenty of smart people sink themselves by pretending to know everything. The ones who thrived weren’t the smooth talkers—they were the ones who came prepared, admitted to knowledge gaps, and then came back with the answer.
It never fails to amaze me how frequently people get this lesson wrong. They came into their meeting rigid and self-assured, thinking the way to curry favor with the boss was to assert total subject matter expertise.
Great leaders can instantly spot uncertainty. I watched as educated guesses masked as certainties—even if they were probably right—eroded trust and ended relationships. Meanwhile, those who came prepared, yet grounded were able to pivot in response to hard questions. More importantly, they could admit deficits in their knowledge when they arose, in turn building trust and rapport.
If used right, “I don’t know” isn’t the end of a conversation, it’s the beginning. It’s not you admitting defeat; it’s you saying that you’re willing to work even harder to find the answer.
Congratulations, you just earned yourself a seat at the table for the next meeting.
How to impress your boss
If you know me, you’ve probably heard me talk about the distinction between middling work and exceptional work. It’s the difference between someone content with meeting expectations and another who craves to exceed them.
A middling employee, like your favorite AI software, is okay with the most-likely-to-be-correct answer. They’ll tell you that being 85% certain is better than not knowing at all.
An exceptional employee won’t settle for anything less than 100% certainty, even if that means not having an answer right away. But give them some time, and they’ll get you what you need, no doubt about it.
And as AI makes average work a commodity that’s ubiquitous and free, the honesty and curiosity of outstanding work is more treasured than ever. If your boss wanted 85% certainty, she’d ask ChatGPT.
These LLMs have tremendous power to make us more efficient. They also reinforce some really bad habits. Remember, when you’re starting out, trust is your most valuable currency. Bluffing spends it; honesty earns it.
You want to be impressive? You want your boss to think you’re smart? Then the best answer isn’t always going to be the clever one.
The best answer will be “I don’t know…but I’m going to find out.”
David Meadvin is CEO of the One Strategy Group.