Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to tackle the trust problem in remote hiring

AI introduces challenges to the hiring process. Here’s how employers can ensure authenticity and fairness.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Volen Vulkov

Co-Founder · Enhancv

The abrupt transformation to fully remote work in 2020 opened our talent pool and taught us the ups and downs of hiring via video interviews. The upside is obvious: access to global talent and faster processes. The hard part is trust.  

I once had a candidate who was clearly using AI-generated notes during a video interview. Their eyes flicked off-screen and their phrasing felt unnaturally polished. When we asked spontaneous follow-up questions, the script fell apart. 

AI can streamline screening and push forward well-prepared candidates, but it can’t substitute for the authenticity and adaptability employers need to see in live interactions. True fit becomes visible only when a candidate moves beyond the rehearsed responses. How they think, react, and connect under real conditions reveals far more than any algorithm ever could. 

REMOTE HIRING IN 2025 

Hybrid is now offered by most companies and is the top choice for employees. Retention is critical: 76% of remote workers would look elsewhere if flexibility disappeared. 

Currently, about 22% of the U.S. workforce—34.3 million people—work remotely. It’s attractive for everyone involved, yet remote hiring surfaces a core challenge—authenticity. 

Tech CEOs from U.S. companies have already faced deepfakes in interviews. In our research, we found that although only 8% of recruiters reported that their applicant tracking systems automatically reject resumes, the vast volume of applications and early knockout filters raise very real concerns about fairness and visibility in the hiring process.  

It’s not just about AI enhancing applicants’ materials. Many use the tools available legitimately, but there are those who cross into deception—including deepfakes during interviews. 

This leads to financial hardships. Employment scams have led to $2.7 billion in losses in Q1 2025 alone. Those numbers are expected to climb as AI tools become more widely available. 

That’s why employers should not rely on instinct alone when assessing candidates. Treat common red flags, such as scripted answers, off-screen eye movement, inconsistencies across resumes, LinkedIn, and portfolios as something to follow up on. Light verification, such as real-time skill assessments, can go a long way. The goal? To see the work behind the words. 

4 TIPS TO DESIGN FOR AUTHENTICITY 

In my hiring experience, there are four tensions in the process that must be balanced. Here’s how to keep the signal authentic in each. 

1. Speed versus depth 

Remote hiring means you’re receiving more applicants than ever. Sometimes a candidate’s fast talk can drown out their real capability. Inserting short purposeful interviews and quick work simulations into the interview process can offer a view into the candidate’s problem-solving, collaboration skills, and how they think about challenges and teamwork beyond a slick answer. 

2. Access versus bias 

Global hiring brings more cultural diversity—a real advantage. The challenge is to discern the cultural nuances—humility in one context can be deemed as lack of competence in another. Balancing structured interviews with a short written or work sample to reduce presentation bias and asking multiple interviewers for input helps ensure one view doesn’t dominate. 

3. Assistance versus automation 

AI should improve recruiting efficiency rather than making it less human. It’s a valuable tool for optimizing procedures like screening applicants, structuring interviews, and decreasing administrative workload. However, when the process is performed on autopilot, employers risk overlooking what is genuinely important: the person behind the profile.  

Instead of depending just on automatic scoring or pre-written screenings, businesses should create situations that demonstrate human judgment and initiative. Ask candidates to go through their decisions, results, and takeaways in real time to eliminate obvious AI-generated responses, which gives hiring managers a better understanding of how someone thinks, collaborates, and learns. 

4. Surface versus substance 

Remote hiring allows us to meet people we’d never reach otherwise. But how do we discern AI polish from real qualifications? Trust now comes from transparency and context. 

Digging into prior work—KPIs, collaborators, references, and adding a short work simulation, when possible, helps both sides feel like they’re solving a problem together. Since the market is flooded with AI generated content with resumes and cover letters that are too polished, employers are leaning more on who vouches for a candidate than on the materials themselves. In fact, some candidates skip the traditional process altogether and go straight through a recommendation. This carries a human validation that AI can’t fake. 

That said, it also risks making hiring less accessible to people without strong networks. Balance matters—and while in some cases referrals work wonders, they should complement resumes and portfolios, not replace them. 

FINAL THOUGHTS 

Trust in remote hiring is a two-way street. The hiring process should be transparent to the applicants: They should be aware of the decision timeline and have a point of contact. It’s also important employers clearly define—internally and to the candidate—what success in the role looks like to the candidate. 

We’re living through a permanent shift in how authenticity is judged. Deepfakes and generative AI are reshaping the environment, and the definition of “real” is no longer about whether something’s made by hand but rather about truthful intentions. 

This is why it’s important to keep processes clear and human. If remote hiring has a north star, it’s this: Transparency beats polish every time. The last thing we need is to automate communication or human connection. 

Volen Vulkov is the co-founder of Enhancv.