Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Look below the waterline when hiring leaders

The strongest leaders may not be the ones you consider first.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Ajit Prabhu

After 28 years of building Quest Global, I have hired hundreds of leaders directly. Many brilliant people who I believe would help transform our company. And you know what bothers me? My success rate is still only one in three. 

Despite multiple interviews and conversations, reference checks, and trusting my instincts, two out of every three senior leaders I’ve hired either fail in the role, exit, or move to a different position because they cannot keep up with expectations. This has troubled me for years. How is it that after building a company of over 21,000 Questians, after all the lessons I’ve learned, I still can’t improve this success ratio?  

One day, while reflecting on another failed hire, an image came to me that explained everything. 

THREE PEOPLE IN THE WATER 

Imagine you are standing by the ocean, watching three people in the water. The water comes up to their necks, so you can only see their heads and arms moving.  The first person is absolutely charming, smiling, and talking enthusiastically about strategy and vision while moving their arms gracefully through the water. They acknowledge everyone with praise, “Oh, you did this great thing, and you did that wonderful thing,” and tells compelling stories about past achievements.  

The second is pleasant enough. They say hello, move steadily through the water, and respond when spoken to. Not as charismatic as the first but seemingly competent. 

The third person? No facial expression, heavy breathing, and difficulty holding a conversation. They don’t seem collaborative or interested in engaging with others and appear to be struggling. 

Who would you hire? The first one. Right? But here is what we usually fail to see. When you go below the water and look at what is happening, the truth becomes apparent. The charming first person is walking on the sea floor with their feet firmly planted on the ground. All that graceful movement, that easy confidence comes from having solid ground to stand on. 

The second has a life jacket on and doesn’t need to work as hard to stay afloat. The buoyancy does half the work. The third person, the one who seemed to be struggling, is the only one swimming, moving their arms and legs, keeping themselves afloat through sheer effort and skill. They are breathing hard because swimming is hard work, and they can’t charm you with stories because they are focused on not drowning. 

THE AGGREGATOR WHO COULDN’T SWIM 

This reflection took me back to my experience with an executive I once hired. We would meet occasionally, and they would share their impressive successes. So, I hired them. Once in the role, I found the results were more reports than new business. 

I was flummoxed. I didn’t need to hire a senior executive to generate reports. I hired them to hunt, to win new business, to create something from nothing. But I realized the individual knew how to look good while others did the actual swimming. 

In some companies, a person might be able to succeed by being charming and playing politics. But in growing businesses, including an aspirational company like Quest Global? That doesn’t work. Growth requires swimmers. 

THE TRUTH ABOUT SMOOTH TALKERS 

I have no qualms in admitting that I have been fooled time and again by smooth talkers. They are not bad people; far from it. However, they tend to excel in environments where appearance matters more than outcomes.  

You cannot test a person’s ability to work hard and get things done in an interview. No matter how many questions you ask, you only see what is above the waterline. The most amicable candidate, the one who says all the right things, might just be walking on the sea floor. 

Only when they join your company, and when you work with them for three to six months, do you discover who is really swimming. Who is resourceful enough to figure things out without a life jacket?  

LEARN TO SWIM IN DEEP WATERS 

At Quest Global, everyone must swim. If you are just walking on the bottom, talking nicely, but not delivering results, you must exit the pool. If you need a life jacket, we might give it to you for a short time while you learn to move your legs. But ultimately, everyone must swim on their own. 

What does swimming mean in our context? It means being hungry and aspiring to find a way when there seems to be no way. It means being customer-focused while not giving excuses about missing resources but figuring out how to get things done anyway. It means thinking like an owner, not like an employee waiting for instructions. 

Accountability works when leaders understand what makes things happen. They are used to having the sea floor beneath their feet, used to floating with institutional support. But building a company that will last 100 years? That requires real swimmers with integrity. 

ONE IN THREE IS OK, IF YOU LOOK SOONER 

After all these years, I have come to accept that my success ratio will likely remain one in three. It doesn’t matter how careful I am, how many interviews I conduct. Until someone is in the water with us, until they face the challenge of keeping their own head above water while delivering results, I cannot know if they are truly capable. 

So now I hire with full trust on day one, then watch carefully. Can they swim? Are they just floating? Do they need a life jacket forever? The answer reveals itself quickly enough. This ultimately reinforces my belief that ordinary people can accomplish extraordinary things when they learn to swim and are self-motivated to keep swimming. 

What is your success ratio today? How do you look under the water to see what is really going on? I’d love to hear your ideas and lessons.  

Ajit Prabhu is the cofounder and CEO of Quest Global.