Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Retailers can’t bring back customers without better data

Retailers make the right changes, but measure the wrong customers.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Enrique Muñoz Torres

Cardlytics

Across retail and foodservice, “win-back” initiatives are everywhere. Refreshed menus, revised store policies, reintroduced value bundles, and retrained associates, among other changes.

Entire experiences are being rethought to bring customers back, and these efforts aren’t necessarily misguided. In many cases, they’re thoughtful and overdue. But we see they underperform far too often. Not because the changes are wrong, but because the underlying diagnosis is incomplete.

Retailers are solving for the customers they can see most clearly, while the customers they actually lost remain largely invisible.

Win-back strategies often start with assumptions

When foot traffic dips or visit frequency declines, we instinctively seek obvious explanations. Prices must be too high, or service slipped. The menu may be outdated and confusing to customers.

The assumptions usually come from internal data that feels comprehensive, such as loyalty programs, app users, CRM records, and logged-in transactions. The dashboards are full, the charts are clean, and the conclusions feel confident. But a fundamental limitation shapes those insights, reflecting customer behaviors for those among the easiest to retain.

Yet loyalty data tells a partial—and sometimes misleading—story. Loyal customers are incredibly valuable. They spend more, visit often, and engage across channels.

They’re also more forgiving, tolerating occasional price increases, operational hiccups, or menu changes because they’ve already chosen the brand. They’re excellent for understanding what’s working well, but risky to exclusively rely on when diagnosing churn.

Retailers analyzing win-back performance primarily through loyalty and self-identified customers are studying a group that is statistically less likely to leave in the first place. Insights drawn from this audience can unintentionally misdirect strategies.

A menu tweak resonating with loyalists might have little impact on sporadic guests. A value bundle driving incremental member visits may not bring back someone who only stopped in occasionally.

The real churn lives outside the loyalty file

A massive portion of retail revenue comes from customers who don’t behave like customers at all, at least not in the traditional sense.

They shop inconsistently, don’t log in to any programs or accounts, and may never join a loyalty program. They appear for a few visits, disappear for months, then reappear elsewhere. They’re making a forgotten-gift run, last-minute meal stop, or unplanned convenience trip.

These shoppers drive volume but rarely appear clearly in customer analytics. Without incorporating these unknown and intermittent profiles into the customer 360, retailers must guess at the most important questions: Why didn’t this shopper come back? What changed in their behavior before they stopped visiting? Which experiences actually increase repeat visits for this group? You can’t win back what you can’t fully see.

Opportunity left unmeasured


Retailers are right to invest in menu innovation, service training, and experience upgrades. But without visibility into responses across different customer segments, the investment impact remains unclear.

The same operational change could produce wildly different outcomes:

  • Increase visit or purchase frequency among loyal customers.
  • No effect on sporadic customers.
  • Push certain shoppers away without anyone noticing.

Retailers incur significant opportunity costs when the analysis focuses only on known customers. This isn’t a critique of existing technology investments, but an acknowledgment of a widely recognized data gap: Not every customer is known, and yet unknown transactions are crucial to a complete picture.

Customer completeness changes the win-back equation

The difference between cosmetic fixes and revenue-driving decisions is a more complete view of who is actually walking through the door and who has stopped.

When retailers analyze both known and unknown customers together, patterns emerge that would otherwise be invisible. Perhaps getting better, more accurate answers to questions like: Which changes influence first repeat visits? What behaviors precede drop-off among sporadic shoppers? These experience improvements actually convert occasional visits into habits.

So, for brands and retailers, instead of asking, “What should we change?” the question becomes, “Which change brings the right customers back and why?”

Win-back starts with the whole picture

Retailers don’t need to abandon their win-back strategies but ground them in a fuller understanding of customer behavior. Loyal customers will always matter, but they’re not the whole story.

Growth lives in the space between loyalty sign-ups and anonymous transactions, with customers who haven’t committed yet, who don’t complain, but might simply choose to stop attending.

Until those customers are included in the analysis, win-back initiatives will remain hit-or-miss.

Not because retailers are making the wrong changes, but because they’re measuring the wrong customers.

Enrique Munoz Torres is the general manager of Bridg.