AI is everywhere right now, and the choices can feel overwhelming. Should I use ChatGPT or Claude? Should I start with accounting or email?
I often hear these questions on calls with my customers, who operate in the trucking industry. While customers recognize the benefits of automation and express interest in using AI, they aren’t always sure where to start. They don’t have the time to think about or implement new technology. Time is tight and resources are stretched.
Most segments of trucking have operating margins below 2%. Every single dollar counts, and that’s why AI is so important to the trucking industry. With AI, the industry can do more with less and retain a greater share of profits. Even if there’s an upfront investment in AI, the ROI is quickly realized.
We developed an approach called the “three roads” (yes, the trucking pun is 100% intentional) to consider how AI can be applied to support business goals, whether you’re in logistics or any other industry.
Road 1: Focus on the growth-first mindset
This involves scaling the business with the same headcount. In trucking, that might mean adding trucks without hiring more dispatchers, converting the savings into pricing power, and winning more business with competitive rates.
Road 2: Prioritize profits and margins
This approach uses AI to shrink headcount while keeping the same kind of freight volume. AI could automate tasks, so the company needs four dispatchers instead of eight, or three people in billing rather than six.
More money per load means greater profit on the same revenue. It can also protect a business during a down market—something the trucking industry endured for several years as a long freight recession lingers on.
Road 3: Use AI to deliver a premium service
On this path, trucking companies keep their team and rates but use AI to elevate the customer experience. Humans handle the relationships and make judgment calls, while AI delivers instant quotes and error-free billing. This road is about using AI as a differentiator to be the best business possible, and reaping the rewards that accompany offering a high level of service.
How to apply the “3 roads” concept to your business
These roads can help guide your next move with AI, whether you work in logistics or a completely different field, you’re at the start of an AI journey, or looking to refine your AI strategy.
Start with your company’s biggest goal. Do you want to scale without hiring? Is the bottom line the priority? Do you want to offer a premium level of service to your top customers?
A customer recently told me about their business’s many functions, like warehousing and running a depot for storing containers. Employees wore several hats. The customer aimed to streamline the team’s roles, allowing more focused time on customer service while using AI to fill administrative gaps. For that reason, road 1—growing AI with the same employees—was a perfect fit.
Next, assess your competition. If they offer low prices but fall short on service, you can differentiate by pricing slightly higher but offering a much better customer experience.
Finally, look at market conditions. In trucking, imports are expected to fall as tariffs continue to rise, which directly affects my customers in drayage, who haul in and out of ports and rail yards.
One customer told me they were wary of how tariffs might dent future freight volumes. The customer picked road 1, as it offered the option to price competitively and potentially recover lost business.
But if the industry’s outlook seems shaky, taking road 2 to manage profitability can also make sense. When the market improves, it’s possible to pivot your strategy to a different road that fits your business in that present moment.
My customer conversations reveal that no one road is inherently better than the other. It’s all about your business, your goals, your competition, and your industry. While road 1 made sense for some customers who wanted to grow and become more efficient, road 3 was the choice for others who wanted to prioritize human connection and use AI to improve their processes.
The worst thing a business can do is stand still at the intersection, avoiding all roads and maintaining the status quo. It’s a surefire way to make sure your competitors zip past you.
AI is here now, and it’s time to pick your road. Start driving and let AI help you reach your destination.
Toni Pisano is the chief customer officer of PortPro Technologies, Inc.