Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

AI and reputation management in 2026

What actually changed and what didn't.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Travis Schreiber

Director of Operations · erase.com

In 2026, reputation management still covers the basics, including search results, news coverage, reviews, social posts, and what shows up when someone types a name into Google.

What changed is where the first impression happens. More people now get an answer before they click anything, and that answer often comes from an AI summary.

That shift doesn’t make reputation management “an AI problem.” It just adds another surface area where context can get lost, outdated information can resurface, and weak sources can gain influence because they get repeated.

One practical way to deal with it is to treat AI summaries as another channel that needs monitoring and maintenance, just as teams treat search results or press.

The first impression gets shorter

Search used to force people to browse. They’d see multiple results, scan headlines, and click around. Now, many users stop at the summary because it feels like a shortcut. That’s great when the summary is accurate, current, and balanced.

It’s not great when it’s confidently vague or missing key context.

This is where reputation issues show up in a new form. A person or company can have an acceptable search page but still get a summary that tilts negative, feels suspicious, or repeats an old storyline. Sometimes the source material is technically accurate, but the takeaway is wrong. Sometimes the summary combines sources in ways never intended.

From a business standpoint, this matters. Buyers don’t separate “what an AI said” from “what is true.” They just decide whether to trust you.

The big risk is ambiguity

Much of the reputation damage we see at Erase.com stems from ambiguity. Unclear ownership, inconsistent bios, mismatched locations, outdated “about” pages, and random third-party listings in conflict with each other.

Humans can often reconcile that conflict. AI systems tend to compress it into a simple story.

This is why the evidence layer matters more than it used to. Not a content flood or a gimmick. Just clear, consistent information so people and systems can easily understand who you are.

In practice, that means tightening the basics:

  • One consistent description of what the company does and whom it serves
  • Matching bios across major platforms
  • Clear ownership and leadership information
  • Updated pages that remove old positioning and old language
  • Fewer contradictions across listings and profiles

When those pieces are messy, the resulting summaries get messy.

Use AI but don’t let it take over the business

The conversation around AI tends to swing between extremes. Either leaders want to automate everything, including customer-facing communication, or they want to ignore AI until it settles. Neither approach holds up well when reputation is part of what’s on the line.

The main risk with AI-written text isn’t just that it sounds robotic. It’s that it creates extra versions of your story that spread fast and get repeated, then show up later as an AI summary that feels authoritative but misses context.

One way to keep that under control is to set internal rules for where AI is allowed to speak externally, and where it can only support drafts. AI can speed up internal work, such as summaries and first-pass drafts, but anything public-facing that could shape trust needs a human owner and a final pass.

Unwanted associations

One problem we’ve seen more and more from our clients is what I’d call unwanted association. A brand is mentioned alongside the wrong company, in the wrong thread, or in a piece of content that drifts into a completely different narrative. Over time, those co-mentions can start to shape how a brand is described, even when the original context is weak.

This isn’t always resolved by a single removal request. Sometimes removal is possible and worth pursuing. Other times, the better move is reinforcement by creating clearer context on owned pages, correcting errors where they exist, and building more reliable references around the brand so the neighborhood improves.

It’s not glamorous work. It’s closer to maintenance. But it’s often what prevents a bad summary from becoming the default story.

Practical reputation management in the AI era

Executives don’t need a massive initiative to take this seriously. A lightweight system is usually enough.

One approach that works:

  • List the real questions people ask before they buy or engage. Not brand slogans, but actual concerns. Keep them in one shared place your team can maintain, like a simple internal doc, or build an internal wiki using a tool like Notion.
  • Run a repeatable check across major AI assistants using the questions from above, and save the outputs. This can be as simple as a person copying the same questions into a few tools each month, pasting the responses into a document, and noting any changes.
  • Track what shows up repeatedly. Patterns matter more than one weird response.
  • Decide what’s a removal problem versus a clarity problem. Some issues are about taking content down. Others are about reducing confusion.
  • Set internal rules for where AI is allowed to speak externally, and where it can only support drafts.

This keeps the work grounded in reputation operations and adapted to how people gather information now.

AI has changed how quickly a narrative can form and how little information someone needs before making a decision. In 2026, the teams that handle this best are the ones that reduce ambiguity, keep their facts consistent, and use AI where it adds speed without eroding trust.

In 2026, reputation management is partly about what ranks and partly about what gets summarized. Clarity and consistency are what keep both from drifting in the wrong direction.

Travis Schreiber is the director of operations at Erase.com.