Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Storytelling is a strategic imperative in the age of AI

Fast Company Executive Board member Kody Gurfein shares insights on why storytelling is more important than ever.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Kody Gurfein

Chief Marketing Officer · Exiger

For years, business leaders treated discoverability as a technical problem. Optimize for search, invest in content, refine your keywords, and the market would find you. Being surfaced was the primary hurdle. If customers could find you, the assumption was that they would understand you.

That assumption no longer holds. 

In an AI-mediated buying journey, discoverability is still required, but AI systems don’t just surface information; they synthesize it. And what they surface is shaped as much by narrative clarity and consistency as by technical optimization.

Kody Gurfein, chief marketing officer at Exiger, has witnessed this paradigm shift firsthand. “If you don’t deliberately control how your company is understood, AI will make those decisions for you,” she says. “And once that happens, correcting the narrative becomes exponentially harder.”

Exiger isn’t the only company to realize the urgent need to get a clear story out to the public (or into an LLM); Microsoft, Notion, USAA, Marks & Spencer now have “storytelling” roles and LinkedIn reports the term is showing up twice as much in job descriptions as the previous year.

“Storytelling has become a central focus,” said Gurfein. “What may have been treated like a branding exercise in the past is now core strategic infrastructure.”

WHEN GROWTH OUTPACES THE NARRATIVE

Exiger’s challenge wasn’t a lack of innovation. Over more than a decade, the company had evolved significantly, expanding its capabilities, acquiring new businesses, and applying its expertise to increasingly complex global problems. However, the speed of innovation and change outpaced the evolution of Exiger’s public-facing narrative. 

“When people (or AI systems) tried to understand who we were, they were finding versions of Exiger from years ago mixed in with contemporary descriptions,” Gurfein explains. “The story being surfaced didn’t reflect who we are today or the problems we actually solve.”

The need for a solution became a top priority with the emergence of AI-based search engines in the buying funnel. LLMs were generating information based on old news coverage, outdated third-party references, and retired web content. The result was more than noise; it was misrepresentation.

WHY SEO THINKING NO LONGER WORKS

Conventional SEO was built with a different paradigm in mind, one of discovery by link, rank, and keyword. Today, buyers increasingly turn to AI systems that act as answer engines. Increasingly, the customer’s approach is to use an AI solution as an answer box. Rather than searching for a piece of information, they’ll query with a full question, seeking a synthesized answer.

These systems don’t recognize or reward clever optimization tricks. They reward structure, clarity, and consistency, posing a challenge for rapidly evolving companies or even organizations that have simply been around for a long time and gradually changed their offerings. 

“We’ve moved from keyword optimization to answer optimization,” Gurfein explains. “AI isn’t asking who ranks first. It’s asking who provides the clearest, most authoritative answer.”

THE DECISION TO GO BACK TO BASICS—USING AI

At Exiger, the marketing team recognized that the solution wasn’t to produce more content. It was to rebuild the foundation around a clear and comprehensive, yet current, story.

Instead of undertaking a messaging refresh with a slow, static process that would be stale by launch, they asked a different question: If AI is shaping discovery, why not use AI to help design the messaging system itself?

They joined forces with Insight Partners’ Marketing Center of Excellence – part of the firm’s Onsite in-house team of 130+ operational experts – to pilot a completely new methodology. Unlike other AI approaches that were trained primarily on optimized marketing messaging, this one centered the model on pure truth specific to Exiger: customer challenges, competitive data, and input from teams around the company, while still optimizing the results using messaging best practices.

“If you give AI prepackaged marketing language, it just regurgitates and dilutes it,” Gurfein states. “If you give it facts, it helps you surface what’s actually differentiated and real.”

It was an ever-changing, living messaging platform built to communicate with both people and machines.

Teams could tailor messaging by audience, use case, or channel while staying grounded in a core story. Junior employees could move faster without resorting to copy-and-paste shortcuts. AI tools could generate outputs that were consistent, accurate, and aligned with the company’s real value.

“It became a shared language across the organization,” Gurfein explains. “Not just something marketing owned but something everyone could use and trust.”

Just as importantly, the system was built to evolve as Exiger’s real-world story evolved. Instead of revisiting messaging every few years through time-consuming exercises, the company could update and refine its narrative as the market changed and the business grew, at the speed relevance now demands.

WHAT AI RESPONDS TO—AND WHAT IT IGNORES

One of the most counterintuitive lessons from the process was how AI evaluates authority. Creativity and cleverness matter less than many leaders assume. AI prioritizes clarity, repetition, and corroboration.

FAQs, crisp definitions, structured content, and consistent third-party validation carry far more weight than promotional copy. “Authority isn’t what you say about yourself,” Gurfein notes. “It’s what the market can repeat about you and what shows up consistently across trusted sources.”

This mirrors how humans build trust. Clear answers beat vague promises. Consistency beats novelty.

THE COST OF NOT TELLING YOUR STORY

The implications for business leaders are significant. Companies that fail to modernize and rebroadcast their story risk losing control of how they’re defined.

As AI continues to mediate discovery, those narratives will be set whether leaders engage or not. For executives navigating constant change, the message is clear: Storytelling is no longer a creative afterthought. It is a strategic infrastructure that determines whether your organization is understood, trusted, and chosen in an AI-driven market.

Kody Gurfein is the Chief Marketing Officer at Exiger.AI.