Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

The future of work is where?

Hint: It’s not hybrid versus office

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Andrew Deutscher

Founder · Regenerate

The return-to-office debate is often framed as a power struggle—organizations demanding presence and employees demanding flexibility. This is not a new conflict. It is a modern expression of an old one: the evolving value exchange between organizations and the people who power them.

The real issue isn’t where work happens. It’s whether the workplace is designed to support sustained human performance at all. Performance has never been a location problem. It’s an energy problem.

Having worked inside executive leadership teams, led business development for a workplace flexibility platform, and advised organizations navigating modern workforce design, I’ve seen this pattern repeat: Leaders mandate presence without redesigning the value of being present. The result is compliance without commitment, and short-term output at the expense of long-term value creation.

WHAT DOES PRESENCE IMPROVE?

Organizations are right to care about collaboration, culture, onboarding, and innovation. Many of these outcomes benefit from shared physical space. Informal mentorship accelerates when people spend time together. Trust builds faster in person. Complex problem-solving often improves with real-time interaction.

Most return-to-office conversations rest on the assumption that performance improves with visibility, proximity, and time spent together. But proximity alone does not create performance. Purposeful collaboration does.

When employees are asked to give up flexibility—longer commutes, fragmented schedules, caregiving strain, health trade-offs—they are making an investment. Organizations would be well served to consider their investment. Too often, employees return to offices only to spend their days in back-to-back virtual meetings or working independently on laptops. That signals that attendance, not contribution, is the real priority.

This is where many return-to-office strategies break down.

Sustainable performance depends on four critical “energy contracts” between organizations and their people—whether leaders acknowledge them or not.

1. The physical energy contract.

    Do work structures support long-term health and recovery or steadily drain it?

    Commute load, meeting intensity, and lack of recovery time eventually degrade performance everywhere—including the office. Sustainable performance is not built through endurance alone. It is built through cycles of effort and renewal.

    2. The emotional energy contract.

    Do employees feel valued enough to invest discretionary effort?

    Engagement doesn’t come from supervision. It comes from trust. It is created by feeling respected, trusted, and meaningfully included. When return-to-office policies emphasize control rather than contribution, employees may comply—but discretionary effort disappears. Oversight can drive behavior in the short term, but it rarely sustains commitment.

    3. The mental energy contract.

    Does the environment sharpen thinking or fragment it?

    The office cannot simply be a change of Wi-Fi location. Physical presence can accelerate learning and innovation through body language, tone, and real-time feedback, reducing friction and improving decision-making. When it adds noise, interruptions, and meeting overload, it becomes a cognitive tax.

    4. The personal ownership contract.

    Does work strengthen ownership and accountability?

    Autonomy isn’t a perk—it’s a driver of ownership. When people feel trusted to manage their work, they take greater responsibility for outcomes. Remove that trust, and creativity and long-term commitment quietly erode.

    FAILURE TO REDESIGN THE WORKPLACE

    Most return-to-office mandates struggle not because employees reject structure, but because organizations have failed to redesign the workplace experience to justify the trade-offs they’re asking people to make.

    The organizations that will succeed in this moment are not those forcing presence, nor those promising unlimited flexibility. They are the ones that intentionally create environments where human energy and business performance reinforce each other.

    That means designing offices for collision, not attendance—spaces that accelerate mentorship, innovation, and interaction. It means clearly articulating why gathering matters and what improves when people are together. And it means treating flexibility as a strategic business imperative, not a perk.

    The future of work will not be decided by where people sit. It will be decided by whether leaders stop confusing presence with performance, and start building workplaces worth showing up for.

    Andrew Deutscher is founder of Regenerate.