In power, you can literally see oversupply in the number. When there’s too much supply at the wrong time, the price can go negative. And that forces you to confront something that many leaders don’t want to say out loud: producing more is not always good.
Too much supply, wrong time
A negative price results from oversupply. That’s the whole idea. If you’re long on supply at the wrong time, you can end up paying someone to take it. Power makes this feel obvious because you can’t store it easily, and supply has to meet demand on the grid in real time.
You see this in places like West Texas: When wind output is high and local demand is weak, prices can go negative because the system still has to clear. If supply and demand fall out of balance, grid frequency changes, so the market has to solve that imbalance immediately.
When there’s too much supply and not enough demand, the market still has to clear, and the price is how it does so. That’s also a useful general rule for interpreting strange outcomes in any system: Before calling it irrational, ask what incentives keep it in motion.
In North and West Texas, a lot of the renewable supply is wind. It can be expensive to shut turbines down, so even when there’s too much supply, operators may keep running. Subsidies can reinforce that incentive.
That’s negative pricing in plain terms. The system has excess supply, and incentives keep supply online anyway, and the price forces the market to clear.
And this is where the leadership lesson starts. Sometimes, your market looks weird, not because it’s broken, but because you have too much supply relative to the demand you can actually support.
Oversupply can be a liability
When oversupply is a liability, supply is sometimes destroyed because there is no economic use for it. But in software, leaders don’t always realize they control the supply. And by distributing supply too broadly, you can hurt your market.
In many businesses, especially service businesses that pretend to be self-serve products, the supply is your ability to support customers, handle edge cases, do custom work, answer questions, onboard people, maintain quality, and keep the whole thing from becoming a mess.
If you distribute that supply too broadly, you can end up in the business version of negative prices and negative outcomes: Support load that eats the team, margins that collapse, and a product that starts to feel broken, because it’s being used in low-value ways that it was never designed to support.
The value of the negative-price example is that it forces the right question: Are you actually long on supply in the wrong part of the market? Oversupply can also be more volume than you can handle profitably.
The practical fix
Leaders will mistakenly sell their product as if it’s for mass markets when it should be limited to the highest-value customers.
In a business, your equivalent of the power supply is unit economics. If you have a services-heavy product, there are customers you can afford to support and customers you cannot.
And when you treat it like self-serve anyway, you’re effectively creating oversupply. You’re choosing to distribute broadly to low-value use cases that don’t cover the real costs.
So, the practical advice is uncomplicated:
- Look at your unit economics
- Ask which customers you can afford to support
- Stop treating a service business like a self-serve product, unless your margins can support it
If your margins can support it, then broad distribution can work. If your margins cannot support it, then broad distribution is how you drift into a situation where the market feels broken. But what’s actually happening is that you are long supply in the wrong place.
Many leaders think the answer is to “grow into it.” Sometimes that’s true. But the negative-price lesson is that you do not want to drift into oversupply by accident. You want to make an explicit choice about whom you serve and why.
That can mean:
- Limit yourself to the highest-value customers
- Be more selective about use cases
- Say no to low-value accounts that create a ton of work
- Build an actual self-serve product before you sell it like one
Because the moment you pay a hidden cost to support low-value demand, you’re living the business version of negative prices. You’re effectively paying someone to take your supply.
Don’t confuse more with better
If you remember one thing, make it this: Negative prices are oversupply. Ask whether you have too much supply relative to the demand you can profitably support.
In power, that shows up directly in the price. In your business, it shows up in margins, support load, churn, and the gap between what you sell and what you can actually deliver.
The leadership move is to be intentional. Based on your unit economics, what customers can you afford to support? And if the answer is “Not all of them,” then do not pretend you’re mass market. Limit yourself to the highest-value use cases and build from there.
That’s how you avoid drifting into oversupply, paying the hidden cost of the business version of negative prices, and start treating the weird outcome as what it actually is: a signal.
Neel Somani is the founder of Eclipse Labs.