Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Why we eliminated sales commissions

As CEO, I decided to measure three other things instead.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Jeff Schwartz

Earlier in my career, I realized that when you join an executive leadership team, you must always lead from the front. A very wise team member always reminds me that we play for the name on the front of the jersey, never the back.

Ultimately, these small lessons led to the biggest change our industry has seen in decades.

For most companies in the HVAC and home-comfort space, the industry norm is that customer-facing teams operate under a highly variable, commission-driven compensation model. Sales reps are incentivized to close, upsell, and push.

Customers feel it the moment someone walks into their home, after the invoice is paid, and in our industry, long after they sign up for a recurring monthly service. In a space already suffering from a serious trust problem, it was like pouring gasoline on the fire.

So, our company made a decision that most people in our space thought was either brave or crazy. We eliminated aggressive, variable-driven sales compensation entirely.

A new approach

Call one of our competitors, especially the large incumbents in our space, and their key salespeople are either 100% commission or 80% to 90% variable commission.

Think about it: You’re a customer who called for service because you have no heating, cooling, or hot water. You book a service visit appointment to troubleshoot and repair your system.

Upon arrival, the technician immediately starts selling you a new system. The entire goal becomes getting the average Mr. and/or Mrs. Customer to spend as much money as possible, with all sales incentives tied to getting you, as the customer, to buy more and spend more.   

The more services or items sold and the higher the price, the more the salesperson makes. It sounds just like the old mattress industry, used-car sales, or, frankly, like most verticals that have seen massive disruption over the last decade.

We designed our entire ecosystem around transparency and a wholly digital experience where the customer is always in control. Our measurements now include satisfaction scores and first-visit resolution rates. All of our orders come through our e-commerce engine, so we ensure the customer is making the best choice for their home. This way, we always deliver better, customer-led solutions in each and every transaction.

Our own team members who signed on to this journey two years ago saw changes in their pay, and changes to how they had to behave in this new culture. 

I won’t pretend it was seamless, but change never is. Some people on the team weren’t sure this model would work for them, and honestly, for a few, it didn’t. We had several folks leave for the competition, where they continue to visit homes, sell, and continue earning variable commission. Ask these folks, and many earn an amazing living.

A new result

But what emerged on our side was a team that genuinely understood its purpose. We stopped going to customers, and customers started coming to us. That shift alone told us everything we need to know about our future.

The results validated the new approach. Our five-star review count has tripled, and first-visit resolutions improved almost overnight. Perhaps most tellingly, our customers started referring their neighbors, the strongest possible signal of trust for in-home services. Our new spring campaign is anchored in the “your neighbor just switched” language, as our best brand ambassadors are customers who recently switched from an incumbent to us. 

So, what does this mean for leaders outside of my industry? The lesson goes beyond compensation design to asking whether your incentive structures are actually aligned with your stated values.

Here’s a simple gut check: Can you genuinely recommend your products and services to your own parents, your family, and your closest friends?

3 things worth measurement

Here are three things I would encourage any executive to examine honestly.

1. What are you actually measuring? Most organizations measure what is easiest to measure: revenue, units, calls closed, profits. But if your mission includes words like trust, transparency, or customer-first, ask yourself where that shows up in your sales process.

2. Where is the tension between your compensation model and your culture? In our case, the tension was loud because we hadn’t listened closely enough to customers. High-pressure sales tactics were baked into how our people were paid. Culture change without compensation change is just wishful thinking.

3. Are your people solving for the customer, or for the commission? This is a design question, not a values question. People will do what the system rewards. I often call it “coin-operated behavior” for those who remember the old video arcades of earlier eras. When our business shifted the system, the behavior followed.

Lead by example

Every Friday, I send a team-wide email. I highlight a specific story from that week, such as a technician who stayed late to walk a customer through their new system. Or a customer care representative thanked, because a customer sent the CEO a message saying, “This is a different kind of comfortable, and your team made me feel comfortable and confident in our decision.”

I tie every one of those stories back to our mission, because it is the mission, and those moments are the strategy.

Leadership is about building a system in which the right behaviors are rewarded, so you don’t have to be in every room at all times. If your compensation model is asking your people to choose between doing right by the customer and hitting their number, that’s a leadership problem. And the good news is, it’s yours to fix.

Jeff Schwartz is president and CEO of Go Lime Inc.