Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

AI requires first principles thinking

The right vector matters more than velocity.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Kurt Donnell

CEO · Freestar

Management consultant Peter Drucker once taught Jim Collins, author of Good to Great, a principle that transformed how he approached business: Don’t make a hundred decisions when one will do. The insight is deceptively simple—what appear to be countless disparate decisions are often the same decision wearing different disguises.

Steve Jobs famously wore the same outfit daily to eliminate fashion decisions, although the real power of this thinking went far beyond wardrobe choices. It was about identifying strategic decisions that categorically remove entire categories of future decisions.

Leaders who effectively manage decision fatigue outperform peers by 22%, so we know this principle is relevant. But in today’s AI-powered world, it’s become absolutely critical.

THE IMPACT OF DECISION FATIGUE

The average person makes an estimated 35,000 decisions per day. By the time they reach the important ones, their mental fuel tank is often empty. This cognitive overload impairs self-regulation and can lead to suboptimal choices, costing the global economy billions annually in lost productivity.

When cognitive load exceeds capacity, the brain’s ability to regulate impulses and emotions is diminished, often leading to us making knee-jerk reactions, becoming overly risk-averse, or avoiding decisions altogether.

THE RIGHT ANSWER TO THE WRONG QUESTION

AI hasn’t reduced our decision load, but it’s amplified the consequences of getting our foundational decisions wrong. For instance, if you decide to choose between A or B, you might then build an AI system that does an amazing job selecting between A and B, taking in all the relevant factors and optimizing beautifully.

However, you may not have needed to choose in the first place, because choosing both A and B, or picking neither option may have been better. You’ve just spent enormous time, energy, and resources optimizing for the wrong question entirely. For example, a car manufacturer with flagging sedan sales could build a complex, multi-variate AI-enhanced system to optimize which sedan colors to manufacture and send to dealers in each market, when the more important question is whether to manufacture sedans, SUVs, or trucks.  

SPEED MAGNIFIES THE ERROR

AI allows us to move faster. Prototyping apps, testing assumptions, and generating solutions is happening at unprecedented speed. But a plane off course by one degree ends up a full nautical mile off course for every 60 nautical miles flown. When you’re building at AI speed, a one-degree error compounds exponentially.

The danger isn’t AI, but that it is easier to go down rabbit holes, building sophisticated solutions to problems that don’t need solving. We’ve accelerated accomplishment. But unless we’re all heading toward the correct goal with the right foundational assumptions, what’s the point of going faster?

I’ve seen this firsthand. You can show tremendous output—generate reams of code, build impressive features, create beautiful dashboards. But if it’s not driving the right outcome, it’s a waste of time and energy.

USE FIRST PRINCIPLES THINKING

This is where first principles thinking becomes your competitive advantage. It’s a problem-solving method that breaks complex problems down into their most basic, fundamental truths. It eliminates assumptions and builds solutions from scratch rather than reasoning by analogy.

When something starts feeling complex, that’s your signal to stop and go back to the beginning. What was the first assumption we made? Test that, and if it’s wrong, it explains why everything downstream is compromised.

Before implementing an AI solution or asking a team to optimize a process, answer these three questions:

1. What problem are we actually trying to solve? Not the symptom, not the immediate pain point, but the foundational problem.

2. What assumption are we making about why this is a problem? Challenge whether that assumption is true.

3. What would solving this accomplish for our core goals? If you can’t draw a straight line from this solution to your primary objectives, you’re likely optimizing for the wrong thing.

MISALIGNED METRICS MAKE AI USELESS

The most insidious form of wrong first decisions is when different teams are working toward different goals and using different metrics to measure success. I’ve watched companies implement incredible AI capabilities while their teams speak different languages about what success means. They become their own barrier to achievement.

It doesn’t matter how sophisticated your AI is or how fast you can execute if different parts of your organization are on different vectors. You need clarity on the decision that matters—your true north—before accelerating everything else.

This isn’t to say that you shouldn’t have creative vibe coding sessions to explore the art of the possible. But treat the sessions as proofs of concept. Pressure test, ensure the proof of concept is heading the direction that will solve your challenge, then unleash the full power of your AI-supercharged team. 

EARN THE RIGHT TO SCALE

Here’s the counterintuitive part: Sometimes you need permission to be inefficient first. As Jesse Cole, the yellow tuxedo-clad founder of the Savannah Bananas said, “You need to do the unscalable to do the scalable.”

At Freestar, we’ve purposefully thrown people at problems that undoubtedly would be better handled by automation. It felt inefficient in the moment. But doing things the hard way first taught us what the efficient way looks like. We had to understand the problem deeply before we could systematize the solution. That’s not wasted time—that’s first principles thinking in action.

MAKE BETTER FIRST DECISIONS

AI can help you test foundational assumptions faster if you use it correctly. You can prototype solutions, gather data, and validate (or invalidate) theories in days instead of months. Before you accelerate with AI, anchor yourself with these three decision-making frameworks:

1. Decide once, apply everywhere

    What recurring decisions can you make categorically? Document them. Systematize them. Free your team’s cognitive resources for genuinely novel situations.

    2. Challenge the question

      When someone asks you to choose between options, pause and ask whether the entire framing is correct. Often, the best answer is hidden in questioning the premise.

      3. Measure what matters

        Align your entire organization on shared definitions of success. If teams are optimizing for different metrics, you’re already off course.

        Once you’re pointed in the right direction, AI becomes your amplifier. But if you’re aimed wrong, you just get lost faster. So, when AI lets us make 100 decisions in the time it used to take to make one, you don’t need to be the fastest; you just need to focus on getting the first decision right.

        Kurt Donnell is the CEO of Freestar.