Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How 23 Leaders Choose Who to Mentor

Follow-through matters more than curiosity alone.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Fast Company Executive Board

Mentoring can be a rewarding experience for both the mentor and the mentee, if the fit is right. With limited time, mentors must be deliberate in who they choose to work with, formally or informally. A mentee can be a junior employee in the organization or someone external, but deciding whether to invest the time isn’t always an easy choice. It helps to have evaluation criteria. We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members how they determine who to invest their time in with mentoring. While there were some common themes, our members also had unique views on what they look for in a good mentor partnership.

1. SOMEONE READY TO ENGAGE

I pay attention to how someone handles small feedback. Not the big moments, but the subtle ones, like do they get defensive, or do they get curious? That reaction tells you everything. Mentorship requires trust in the process, and you can see early on who’s ready to engage with it. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv

2. SHOWS CURIOSITY AND FOLLOW-THROUGH

I mentor when someone shows real curiosity, follow-through, and a desire to build something meaningful. I look for people who want a collaborative relationship and are ready to put in the work, not just seek access. When that foundation is there, the relationship becomes a space where we can learn from each other and move their goals forward with clarity and momentum. — Val Vacante, Collabsco

3. UNDERSTAND THEIR GOALS

Choosing the right person to mentor starts with a real conversation. We ask key questions upfront. Understanding whether someone is introverted or extroverted tells us a lot about whether they can command a crowd of 500 people or thrive better behind the scenes keeping everything running smoothly. From there, it’s about understanding their goals and placing them where their passion already lives, because in this industry, that energy is visible and guests feel it. The best part? Our work is so hands-on that we can bring someone on-site and let them dive straight in. There’s no better classroom than a live event. — Diana Sabb, Create Something Amazing

4. COLLEGE FELLOWSHIP PROGRAM

I mentor internally to build loyalty, and I mentor externally to build legacy. In the consulting industry, you have to be selective with who you lend your time to so externally, I channel that energy into our First and Last PR University Fellowship, a program designed to bridge book knowledge with real world experience. We don’t just give advice, we cocreate a capstone project together that the student can use during interviews and as the student starts their career. — Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw, First and Last PR

5. DURING TRANSITIONS

Mentorship isn’t a one-time favor, but a constant investment in people and the future of the business. It’s most impactful during moments of transition, when someone is taking on a new responsibility, navigating uncertainty, or showing readiness to grow. For small businesses, consistent mentorship builds continuity by sharing knowledge early and developing leaders over time. That approach ensures the business isn’t dependent on any single individual when change inevitably comes. — Mark Valentino, Citizens

6. PEOPLE ALREADY PUSHING THEMSELVES

Mentorship is a two-way street. I’m always open to it, both inside our company and externally, but the strongest relationships tend to happen with people already pushing themselves. I look for proactivity, curiosity, initiative, and follow-through. It’s less about formal structure and more about ongoing dialogue, creating a dynamic that’s mutually energizing and rewarding. I’ve had and continue to have incredible mentors, and if I can play even a small part of that for someone else, it’s worth prioritizing. There’s always something new to learn on both sides. — Alex Seaman, Furniture.com

7. GRIT AND GRATITUDE

I look for eagerness, gratitude, and grit. Entitled people usually do not want mentorship, they want validation. The people worth mentoring are the ones who act on feedback, stay attentive, and keep putting in the work over time. When I was learning to fly, I mentally rehearsed for over 100 hours and chased every opportunity to learn. Mentors invest more when they can feel that their effort is deeply valued. — Sima Mosbacher, HIGHSCALE

8. MOTIVATION

I mentor when someone shows real follow-through, meaning they’ve already tried things, they come with a sharp question, and they are open to blunt feedback. My filter questions are usually these “What did you try, what happened, and what decision do you need to make next?” I start with a specific timeline like a month trial. We set up one call, one goal, one action item due before the next chat, and if that cadence slips, we stop. — Daniel Haiem, AppMakers USA

9. CAN BE INFORMAL

Mentorship is a powerful tool, and it’s not something that’s always a formal arrangement. Mentorship can simply be sharing a point of view or encouraging the younger generation to keep going. Early in my career when I was unsure of my direction, my manager told me to pause and find a way to revamp myself. So, I started reading. That advice stuck with me, and critical thinking has become a key part of how I approach both life and business. I try to share those lessons with others whenever I can. — Richard McWhorter, SRM Private Wealth

10. SPECIFIC CHALLENGES

Mentorship works best when it adds real value for the mentee. I keep an open mind but look for people who are engaged, committed, and facing specific challenges. While these relationships often provide me with learning opportunities, the real reward is seeing the mentee succeed. Being part of that journey is why I enjoy mentoring and staying active in the community. — Jani Hirvonen, Google

11. WHEN ACTIONS SHOW THEY’RE READY

I choose to mentor when someone is ready for it. Not when they say they want it, but when their actions show it. Curiosity, follow- through, and a willingness to be coached matter more than experience. Mentorship is an investment, so I look for people who are open to feedback and willing to do the work. When that is there, I will show up fully. It is not about mentoring everyone. It is about mentoring the right people at the right time. — Rachel Shaw, Rachel Shaw, Inc.

12. BASED ON BEHAVIOR

I don’t choose based on title or proximity, I choose based on behavior. If someone is curious, asks good questions, and acts on my input, I’ll keep investing. If it’s just a conversation with no follow-through, it tends to be a one-and-done. Mentorship isn’t about talking, it’s about progress. The people worth investing in are the ones who take what you say, challenge it, and then go out and apply it in the real world. — Daragh Mahon, Werner

13. HOW THEY OPERATE

First, ask yourself whether you have the time needed to dedicate to mentorship? Someone is asking for feedback, help, and opening themselves up—take that seriously. I also want to interact with people first, not in the context of evaluating mentorship, but to see how they operate, what’s important to them, are they tuned in, paying attention, and importantly—do they lead with kindness. Finally, there must be a mutual understanding that this isn’t me imparting my knowledge but a collective experience where we’re learning from each other and taking steps forward towards our individual goals. — Jeffrey Whitford, MilliporeSigma, a business of Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany.

14. AN ORGANIC RELATIONSHIP

For me, it usually starts as an organic relationship. It’s not just expressing their interest in being mentored; it’s showing they have the energy and willingness to do the work. If someone is already taking steps, asking thoughtful questions, and applying feedback that I’ve provided, that’s an investment of time I’m happy to make. Often, I’ll find that I get more from the relationship than they get from me, which is the gift of giving. — Heather Jerrehian, H22 AI, Inc.

15. A REAL INTENT TO LEARN

I never try to play the “expert” in the room. I pay attention to real energy. When someone feels ready to grow, I tell them honestly that there is potential here. Then I share everything I know that can help. That mindset makes it easy for me to invest my time. It feels natural when the intent to learn is real. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, cofounder of Blushush and Ohh My Brand

16. READY TO ACT

I choose to mentor someone when I see they are genuinely ready to listen and apply what I share. Interest matters more than titles. If a person is curious, asks thoughtful questions and shows they are open to learning, I am much more willing to invest time. Mentoring works best when the other person is ready to turn experience into action, not just collect advice. — Boris Dzhingarov, ESBO ltd

17. THEY KNOW WHAT THEY WANT

The biggest factor is clarity. It’s tough to have a productive mentoring relationship if someone doesn’t know what they want to get out of it or hasn’t defined their goals. When someone does have a clear sense of what they want to learn, then it’s easier to assess whether my experience aligns in a way that would actually help them. And practically speaking, I also make sure I have the time to truly commit. Because good mentoring requires consistency and attention. — Kimberly Ferro, Kawneer

18. THOSE WHO EXECUTE

I mentor people who execute, not just ask. Curiosity matters, but follow-through matters more. Time is allocated to those who convert guidance into action. — Kevin Leyes, LeyesX

19. GENUINE CURIOSITY

I choose to mentor when there’s genuine curiosity and follow-through. It’s less about where someone is in their career and more about how they show up: are they asking thoughtful questions, applying feedback, and doing the work? The most meaningful mentorships are always a two-way investment. — Sharon Lee Thony, SLT Consulting (SLTC)

20. AMBITION

Mentorship is a two-way street, but the onus is on the mentee to use their mentor. So for me, what I look for in a mentee is both curiosity and ambition. Are they driven enough to seek me out? Are they curious enough to learn? And finally, are they open enough to hear feedback? — Roger Wong, BuildOps

21. SHOWS OWNERSHIP

Mentorship runs in concentric circles. The innermost circle is my team, where every partner gets continuous, direct, first-principles feedback baked into our operating system. The next circle out is people I meet outside the company who are already in motion, building something real and stuck on a problem they cannot see around. The further out you go, the more the filter tightens to one thing: ownership. I can hand someone a framework or a connection in a single conversation, but I cannot give them the instinct to own the outcome. —  Michael Quoc, Product.ai

22. DRIVE

I mentor across startup founders, students, and executives—but I’m looking for the same thing every time: drive. Are they in motion, pushing toward escape velocity? If they are, I’ll invest quickly. If not, I’ll point them in the right direction and move on. Mentorship compounds when both sides are already in motion. — Isaiah Steinfeld, Neue Alchemy

23. NEED A CLEARER PATH

I look for people who are already moving and just need a clearer path, not people who need convincing that effort is worth it. That’s not mentorship, that’s management. Outside the workplace, I’m more selective. The people worth mentoring show you that before you even agree to it. — Travis Schreiber, Erase.com