We all know that the customer is always right, and we need to respond to their concerns within minutes or risk losing the customer for good. But maybe we’ve been thinking about customer service the wrong way and we’re shooting ourselves in the foot believing in these long-held truisms. Counterintuitive moves might actually come with a better result. We asked our Fast Company Executive Board members what counterintuitive moves they’ve made in customer service that have paid off for them—and for their customers. We share 21 of those responses here.
1. COMEDY TRAINING
We launched our comedy training service over a decade ago. Through this we employ the tenets of comedy to help our teams and our clients think like improvisers rather than traditional consultants. Instead of rigid scripts and polished presentations, we emphasize storytelling, listening, adaptability, and quick thinking—all skills rooted in comedy. This approach helps teams respond more authentically, build stronger relationships, and navigate unpredictable situations with confidence and creativity. — Maggie ONeill, Peppercomm
2. DOUBLE DOWN ON HUMAN CONNECTION
In a world where most companies are pushing toward automation and offshore support, we’ve doubled down on real human interaction. Creating trust is massive in our industry, so when customers call us, they can talk to an actual person here in the U.S., and that speed and quality of communication really stands out. It’s somewhat counterintuitive today, but prioritizing human connection—especially early in the experience—has been a big differentiator for us. — Zander Cook, Lease End
3. INVEST IN PERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS
One of the most effective things I’ve done is invest deeply in personal relationships—understanding what’s happening in my customers’ lives and remembering to follow up on it. That human connection builds trust far beyond any transaction. Even small gestures, like sending handwritten notes, can create a lasting impact and set the tone for a true partnership. — Irina Soriano, Seismic
4. SLOW DOWN AND UNDERSTAND
We stopped trying to resolve issues as fast as possible. Instead, we slowed down just enough to fully understand what actually went wrong. It felt risky, especially in terms of longer interactions and more effort, but customers noticed. They didn’t just want speed, they wanted to feel understood. That shift turned frustrated customers into surprisingly loyal ones. — Volen Vulkov, Enhancv
5. INCREASE CLIENT SELECTIVITY
We are being more selective about who we work with. It sounds counterintuitive, but saying no (or redirecting someone who isn’t the right fit) has significantly improved both client outcomes and overall satisfaction. When expectations, budget, and timing are aligned from the start, the entire experience is better. It also reinforces trust, because clients can feel that you’re prioritizing quality and fit over volume. — Kristin Marquet, Marquet Media, LLC
6. PULL BACK ON AI IN CUSTOMER INTERACTIONS
We pulled back on AI in customer-facing interactions when most of our competitors were doubling down. Turns out people notice when a response doesn’t sound like a person wrote it, and in reputation management of all industries, that’s a credibility problem you can’t afford. The efficiency gains weren’t worth the trust cost. Sometimes the counterintuitive move is just doing the thing that takes more effort and not pretending there’s a shortcut. — Travis Schreiber, Erase.com
7. THE CUSTOMER IS NOT ALWAYS RIGHT
I stopped thinking that great service means agreeing with everything because we are taught that “customer is always right.” Ask yourself this first: Are they the long-term customers you want to have? Especially for founders, and often for women founders, there can be pressure to be endlessly accommodating. But in practice, clients respect expertise, authority, and confidence more than they respect a pushover. People do not hire you to say yes to everything. They hire you to bring judgment. If you abandon that, the value of the engagement starts to disappear. — Sima Mosbacher, HIGHSCALE
8. HUMANS IN CUSTOMER SERVICE
Over the past few years, companies have devoted time and resources to automate, move to low-cost locations, and outsource customer service functions. I use my own experience as a consumer as a guidepost. How do you feel when you are forced to engage with a complex phone menu or chat with a bot that couldn’t solve your problem, without the option of connecting with a real person? Customers have repeatedly told us how much they value calling customer service and having a human on the other end to assist them. It’s counterintuitive, but that option for human assistance is a true differentiator for our company, paying off in loyalty and trust. — Martin Mrugal, Alchemer
9. LEAD WITH VALUE
One of the most counterintuitive things we have done is stop “selling” in the traditional sense. Instead, we focus on showing up, teaching, and helping first. We give clients clarity, tools, and honest guidance, even when it does not immediately lead to work. That approach builds trust quickly and attracts the right clients, those who value the work and are ready to do it well. It also filters out engagements that are not the right fit. In customer service, I recommend leading with value over volume. When you focus on being genuinely useful, the business follows. — Rachel Shaw, Rachel Shaw, Inc.
10. INVEST IN HUMAN TEAM MEMBERS
Contrary to today’s usual practice, we have continued to invest in customer service team members, while many organizations are cutting people and turning toward automation, especially tech companies. While chatbots and dashboards are great for many things, most instances necessitating true customer service require a human who understands the business, can provide clarity, and support better decisioning. Computers and AI are wonderful for so many things, but humans are usually a lot better at navigating bumps in the road. And there will always be bumps in the road where guidance is more valuable than automation. — Kurt Donnell, Freestar
11. LEAD, INSTRUCT, PROVIDE EXPERTISE
I have never subscribed to the idea that the customer is always right. In the communications and learning space, our job is to instruct, lead, and provide expertise, which is why companies hire us. If you don’t want to listen or follow that advice, we can’t guarantee results or the outcome you want. We are very clear about how we work and our clients respect it, because the results speak for themselves. — Kim Bode, 8THIRTYFOUR
12. DON’T RUSH RESPONSES
One counterintuitive move we’ve made is slowing down responses to be more thoughtful. Instead of rushing to reply, we take the time to truly understand the issue and respond with context and care. It’s led to stronger relationships, more trust, and ultimately better outcomes for our clients. — Sharon Lee Thony, SLT Consulting (SLTC)
13. REWRITE AUTOMATED COMMUNICATIONS
One counterintuitive move was revisiting automated communications. Rather than optimizing solely for efficiency, we rewrote them with warmer, more human language that genuinely conveyed appreciation. It required more upfront effort, but it shifted the tone of the entire experience. Engagement improved, sentiment strengthened, and customers felt recognized—not processed. — Britton Bloch, Navy Federal Credit Union
14. TAKE TIME TO ALIGN
Sometimes, the most counterintuitive move in customer service is not rushing. Taking time to align on expectations may slow things down at first, but it builds trust. Customers stay longer and increase engagement over time. In enterprise software, durability often matters more than speed to close. Investing that time early often leads to stronger partnerships and more sustainable growth. — Dan Amzallag, Ivalua
15. BE SELECTIVE IN SAYING YES
One counterintuitive move was being more selective instead of saying yes to everything. In customer service, many teams think speed alone solves problems, but rushed answers often create more frustration. We focus on setting clear expectations, asking a few better questions first, and giving clients a more precise solution. That reduced back-and-forth, improved trust, and led to better long-term relationships. Sometimes the best service is slowing down enough to get it right. — Boris Dzhingarov, ESBO ltd
16. PRECISE COMMUNICATION
We sometimes slow down responses instead of rushing them. In high-stakes environments, thoughtful, precise communication builds more trust than speed alone. — Kevin Leyes, LeyesX
17. BE DIRECT
If the timing’s wrong or they’re solving the wrong problem, we say it directly. It feels counterintuitive, but it builds trust fast. People remember who didn’t push them into something. And when the problem becomes real, they come back already convinced. It’s okay to say no, and I think people tend to forget that. — Justin Inman, Emberos
18. SLOW THE PACE
We’ve learned to slow things down. Instead of rushing to respond, we take time to understand the context before acting. Clients feel the difference because the work becomes more thoughtful, reflective, and meaningful. We also try to bring that pace to them, since many are operating in busy corporate worlds filled with urgency. — Goran Paun, ArtVersion
19. TURN DOWN CLIENTS WHO AREN’T A FIT
I always go with my gut, including declining a contract from a legacy contact whose terms didn’t align with ours. In public relations, there’s a “starving artist” myth that you should be grateful for any prestige interest. But passion doesn’t pay invoices and PR firms aren’t meant to subsidize a client’s vision with their own margins, whether it’s discounted fees or absorbing late payments. We are a value-based consultancy. We don’t trade in potential, we trade in proven expertise, and that has a fixed floor. Standing firm earned more respect and left the door open for future partnerships. — Stephanie Scott-Bradshaw, First and Last PR
20. HAVE A SPINE
A client once called me mid-project, absolutely certain we’d messed up. I pulled up the brief, sat with them, and just walked through it, slowly, with so much warmth I surprised even myself. They thanked me and stayed for two years after that. They sent referrals without me ever asking. Telling the truth with care is honestly the most slept-on skill in client work. People want someone who’s got their back, and sometimes who will hold their ground instead of folding. Real service has a spine. That’s what makes people stay. — Bhavik Sarkhedi, cofounder of Blushush and Ohh My Brand
21. SPEED IS OVERRATED
Speed is overrated in high-value conversations. Slow down, get the full context, and come back with something sharper than expected. It feels counterintuitive, but it builds trust quickly—and turns support into a real advantage. — Isaiah Steinfeld, Neue Alchemy